INTERNATIONAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION DIGEST
September
2006
Copyright © 2006 World Expertise LLC – All rights
reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education
leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S.
Jones, Ph.D.
CONTENTS
1 - International developments
-
India
connects to wireless Internet
- Saudis
fund 15,000 scholarships for
US
higher education
- Iranian
president initiates purge at state universities –
-
Germany
launches a high-tech initiative
- European
science agency gets tag-team leadership
-
Mexico
gets in gear
- US
not lagging in engineering education
-
Italy
’s
universities being scrutinized by ministry
2 -
US
developments
- NCEES
approves BS + 30
- DOE
tightens monitoring of collaborators
- Academic
earmarks
- NAE
nominates next president
- Visa
issues five years after 9/11
- Predictions
for
US
higher ed in 2015
- New
guidelines for teaching math
- CEOs
laud non-Ivy higher ed
- US
is top destination for foreign students
- Levine
strikes out at teacher education programs
-
US
higher ed resting on its laurels, says report
- US
Education Department collaborated with FBI on terrorist search
3 - Technology
- Desperate
whistleblower turns to YouTube
- Tech
transfer, Wisconsin style
- Alternative
view of structure of
New York
’s
twin towers
- Yale
moves to put lectures on-line
- Toys
for engineers
4 - Students, faculty, education
- Renaissance
engineer of 21st century
- Knowledge
integration in science
- Prepackaged
team hired
- SAT
scores see big decline
- Author
warns of overbuilding of university research labs
- Harvard
wants to make teaching count more . . .
- Students
at 2-year colleges unready
- Booting
up in
Texas
- So
that’s why they’re leaving
- Company
designed courses at universities
- The
art of engineering
- National
Academies document persistent bias
- An
alternative view on gender discrimination
- Buying
college admission
- Harvard
drops early admissions
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
- Offshore
outsourcing finds fans
-
India
should prepare for offshoring of engineering services
6 – Journals
- European
Journal of Engineering Education
- STEM
Journal
7 – Meetings
- UPADI
2006 in
Atlanta
- ASEE
annual meeting call for papers
- Colloquium
on international engineering education
- SEFI
and IGIP Joint Annual Conference
________________________________________________________________________
1 - International developments
India
connects to wireless Internet – High speed Internet connectivity is an
elusive luxury for most Indians, with just over a million broadband subscribers
in a country of more than a billion people. According to an article by Seema
Singh in the September IEEE Spectrum, the
new WiMax standard for wide area broadband connectivity could be coming to the
rescue – allowing skipping over DSL links and cable modems that are standard
in other places. According to proponents of the new technology, WiMax offers the
best answer to last-mile broadband connectivity in a country like
India
. Vendors and carriers are rushing in with products and services which utilize
WiMax technology. But Indian regulators have been slow to allocate spectrum for
WiMax, dampening the technology’s prospects. (See http://www.spectrum.ieee.org)
Saudis fund 15,000 scholarships for
US
higher education – The royal family of
Saudi Arabia
is offering 15,000 full scholarships for Saudi students to earn their degrees
in the
US
, in a program designed under the leadership of President George Bush and King
Abdullah. After 9/11, the large
numbers of Saudi students studying in the
US
disappeared, says the article from the September 9 International Herald Tribune. This
initiative is an attempt to rebuild the academic relationship between the two
countries. Supporters see the
program as a way to increase US students’ understanding of Arabs and Muslims.
Some personnel at the Department of Homeland Security are concerned that the
rapid expansion of the program has not given enough time for security checks to
be carried out. (See http://www.iht.com)
Iranian president initiates purge at state universities –
Iranian President Mahmoud Admadinejad recently called for a purge of all liberal
and secular professors from the country’s universities, an attempt which his
critics say is designed to distract attention from his failure to fulfill
campaign promises to improve the economy and strengthen equality.
According to Nazila Fathi, in the September 5 edition of The
New York Times, the purge is part of a succession of moves against social
freedom, which include the confiscation of 110,000 illegal satellite dishes,
suppression of local media, and the intimidation of intellectuals and students.
(See http://www.nytimes.com)
Germany
launches a high-tech initiative – The German government wants to make
it easier for entrepreneurs to translate research discoveries into products,
according to an article in the September 8th Science by Gretchen Vogel. It is increasing support for programs to
help spin scientific findings into commercial ventures by committing
€14.6-billion in the next three years to boost technology-based research and
enterprises. The government wants to ignite ideas with a combination of new
programs, funding schemes, and legislation. Researchers who collaborate with
small and midsized companies, for example, will qualify for 25% premium funding
from the government. The plan also includes several new funding schemes, with
the largest investments going for aerospace research (including satellite
communication and navigation systems) and energy technologies (including
biofuels and nuclear energy). (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
European science agency gets tag-team leadership -
Europe
has selected two leaders as successive heads of its new basic science agency,
the European Research Council. A German biochemist will start the initial 5-year
term, but he will be succeeded by a Spanish economist halfway through the term.
The ERC board created the unusual arrangement to recruit executives with
different skills, according to an article by Gretchen Vogel in the September 8th
Science. The first CEO, Ernst-Ludwig
Winnaker, brings experience in overseeing a large granting organization. The
successor CEO, Andreu Mas-Colell, will bring expertise in seeking increased
funding and dealing with politicians who may be unhappy with grants awarded on
the basis of excellence without regard to geographic distribution. The ERC is
designed to fund cutting-edge research for all of
Europe
, with a $9.6-billion budget over 7 years. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Mexico gets in gear – Mexico
currently enrolls over 450,000 engineering students and may become a major
player in the global economy, according to an article by Jeffrey Selingo in the
September ASEE Prism. The number of
enrolled engineering students is up 20% since 2000, and
Mexico
is attracting more industry as a result. Known more these days for generating
conversations about illegal immigration, the country has quietly been building
up its infrastructure over the past decade to educate more engineers and attract
companies with advanced engineering design work. Observers note that there is
more interest in improving the quality of life in
Mexico
, while the
US
by comparison has had a flattening of the speed of innovation and technical
education. As a result more Mexican students, including engineering majors, are
staying home rather than trekking to the
US
. That trend has in turn improved the quality of
Mexico
’s engineering schools and increases the likelihood that students will want to
remain in the country after graduation. (See http://www.asee.org)
US not lagging in engineering education – Despite a number of
recent articles and stories about the threat to US engineering presented by the
new waves of engineering graduates from China and India, an article by Paul
Mooney and Shailaja Neelakantan in the September 8 issue of The
Chronicle of Higher Education presents evidence that the reality is quite
different. P.V. Indiresan, for
example, the former director of the Indian Institute of Technology in
Madras
, says that beyond the top-tier institutions in
India
, the quality is low. And a report by McKinsey & Company reports that only
about 10% of today’s Chinese college graduates would be competitive for jobs
in a multinational company in areas such as engineering, finance and the life
sciences. A study by faculty and
students at
Duke
University
even questions the data used to count the number of engineering graduates.
In both countries, expansion of higher education has taken place so
rapidly that quality has been seriously compromised, in the eyes of many
observers. (See http://chronicle.com)
Italy’s universities being scrutinized by ministry – Fabio
Mussi, the new Minister of Universities and Research in Italy, has called the
university governance system he took over from the previous administration a
“big bordello,” and has taken rapid steps to raise standards by closing down
one new institution and promising increased funding for university research.
The previous government had expanded rapidly, recognizing 14 new
universities in two years, 10 of those on-line institutions, writes Francis X.
Rocca in The Chronicle of Higher Education. Mussi has proposed an independent
look at hiring of faculty and the distribution of research funds. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/09/2006092106n.htm)
2 -
US
developments
NCEES approves BS + 30 - At the 2006 Annual Business Meeting of
the National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying (NCEES),
delegates voted to modify the NCEES Model
Law requirements for licensure to require additional education for
engineering licensure. The approved language states that an engineer intern with
a bachelor’s degree must have an additional 30 credits of acceptable
upper-level undergraduate or graduate-level coursework from approved providers
in order to be admitted to the Principles and Practice of Engineering (PE)
examination. A master’s degree or PhD from an approved institution would also
qualify. The change, to be effective in 2015, is a recommendation to each of the
state jurisdictions, which individually will have to adopt it for it to be
implemented. (See http://www.ncees.org)
DOE tightens monitoring of collaborators - In an effort to
safeguard sensitive and classified information, the US Department of Energy has
implemented a rule that requires researchers who want to access the agency’s
computers to first give DOE permission to do electronic snooping. According to
an article by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the September 1st Science,
anyone accessing information on computers owned by DOE and its contractors
must first provide “written consent” for investigators to monitor the
computer user’s habits for up to 3 years in the future. Researchers are
complaining that complying with the rule will pose an unnecessary financial
burden due the amount of paperwork involved. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Academic earmarks – An unusual inquiry from a “pork
busting” US Senator has revealed an uneasy ambivalence among university
presidents toward academic earmarks. According to an article by Jeffrey Mervis
in the September 8th Science,
a survey of 110 US universities indicated that such directed spending on
research is now part of the fabric of higher education. Senator Tom Coburn asked
the universities to describe any federal research dollars obtained in the past 6
years through the good graces of their congressional delegations rather than by
competitive review. He also asked whether the universities had hired lobbyists
to help obtain earmarks, and the impact of the found money on their campuses and
on science. Respondents offered varying views of earmarking, but even major
university presidents who stated that they abhorred the practice acknowledged
occasional dalliances. Some universities see earmarks as a way to simultaneously
move up the academic food chain and strengthen the local economy. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
NAE nominates next president – The US National Academy of
Engineering has nominated Charles M. Vest, president emeritus of the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, to be its president for a six-year term
to begin next July 1st. According to an NAE news release, if elected
Vest will succeed William A. Wulf, whose second term as NAE president will end
next June 30th. Wulf, who is not eligible to run for a third term
under NAE bylaws, will return to his previous position as a Chaired University
Professor at the
University
of
Virginia
. Vest, age 65, served as MIT’s president from 1990 through 2004. During that
time he worked to strengthen federal-university-industry relations, and
undertook a number of initiatives to bring education and research issues to
broader public attention. Vest was elected to the NAE in 1993 for “technical
and educational contributions to holographic interferometry and leadership as an
educator”. (See http://www.nationalacademies.org)
Visa issues five years after 9/11 – An article by Geoff
Brumfield and Heidi Ledford in the September Nature, discusses how
US
visa issues have affected visiting scholars and scientists since September 11.
Five years after the terrorist attacks foreign scientists are reporting fewer
problems entering the
US
, with waiting times down and applications increasing. Lengthy visa delays and
persistent security checks have turned foreign scientists away from the
US
, but now the country is striving to woo them back. Many
US
universities are now reaching out to the international community, beefing up
international student offices and even opening recruiting offices in countries
such as
China
. The increase in recruitment and drop in waiting times seem to be having a
positive effect, with numbers of visas climbing steadily and the number of visa
complaints dropping dramatically. (See http://www.nature.com)
Predictions for US higher ed in 2015 – The US Education
Department’s
National
Center
for Education Statistics has released its projections about the year 2015,
saying that enrollment in degree-granting higher education institutions will
grow by 15% between now and then, slower than the 25% growth rate between 1990
and 2004. Between 2004 and 2015 undergraduate enrollments will increase by 14%
and graduate enrollments by 19%. Women
will continue to increase their lead in participation, with, for example, the
number of doctoral degrees projected to be awarded to women increasing by 31%,
as contrasted to 12% for men, reports Elia Powers in Inside Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/15/future)
New guidelines for teaching math – A Wall Street Journal article by John Hechinger from the September 12
edition reports on the new guidelines for teaching math published by the
National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.
The new recommendations are a significant departure for those given by
the same group in 1989, and which led to “reform math” programs used all
over the country. Perhaps reacting
to the steep declines in US students’ performance in math as compared to
children in other countries, the Council is turning back to teaching more basics
such as multiplication tables and long division.
Critics of reform math are pleased, believing that student math success
in countries such as
Singapore
is a result of more focus on a narrow range of basic skills.
The article outlines in some detail the controversies over math
instruction and the alternative curricula which have emerged over the past 15
years. (See http://online.wsj.com)
CEOs laud non-Ivy higher ed – About 90 percent of the CEOs of
top US companies didn’t attend an Ivy-league school for their undergraduate
education, reports Carol Hymowitz in the September 18th edition of The
Wall Street Journal. The title
of the article, “Any College Will Do" repeats the message many business
leaders give to students. Bill
Green, CEO of Accenture, was quoted extensively about his decision to attend
Dean
College
, a two year community college, where he discovered faculty who were dedicated
to their students and who taught him the skills needed to think and work well.
Some top CEOs never completed college – witness Bill Gates and Steve
Jobs – but that strategy works well only for a brilliant few.
And many graduates of state universities ultimately earned a graduate
degree from an Ivy-league institution. (See
http://online.wsj.com)
US is top destination for foreign students – OECD has issued
its annual “Education at a Glance” report, which shows an overall 41%
increase in the number of foreign university students worldwide between 2000 and
2004 – up to 2.7-million total. According to an OECD press release, Asian
students comprise the largest group studying abroad, making up 45% on
international students in OECD countries – with Chinese students accounting
for 15% of this total. The
US
share of the international student market is still by far the highest, and the
US
remains the most popular destination among globally mobile students. Four
leading destination countries host 52% of all international students:
United States
(22%),
United Kingdom
(11%),
Germany
(10%) and
France
(9%). The
US
share dropped from 25% to 22% in four years. Increases in market share were
reported for
New Zealand
,
France
and
South Africa
. Although the
US
has the most foreign students, they make up a relatively low proportion of
overall higher education students (3%), compared with countries like
Austria
(17%) and the
UK
and
Switzerland
(13% each). See http://www.oecd.org)
Levine strikes out at teacher education programs – Arthur
Levine, president of the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Program and former
president of Teachers College at
Columbia
University
, has issued a second report on teacher education, “Educating School Teachers,
writes Elia Powers in Inside Higher Ed. The
report contains a number of strong criticisms of how teachers are educated in
the
US
, based on visits to 28 colleges of teacher education and surveys of
stakeholders. Over 60% of teachers
surveyed said they were not prepared adequately for coping with their jobs.
Too many teacher ed programs are in middle tier institutions where
faculty were less qualified: Levine says those schools should be closed.
Levine recommends a five year model of teacher preparation, with students
majoring in a discipline rather than in teacher ed.
He also says that the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher
Education’s process is ineffective, noting that there is no difference between
students who graduate from accredited and non-accredited institutions.
(See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/19/teachered)
US
higher ed resting on its laurels, says report – The US National Center
for Public Policy and Higher Education just issued a report showing that
US
higher ed is slipping in quality when measured against other countries, and in
its affordability. “Measuring Up
2006: The National Report Card on Higher Education” grades each state on
affordability, preparation, completion and other measures.
The area that came in for the most criticism is affordability, where
tuition is rising faster than the availability of financial aid, writes Scott
Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/07/reportcard)
US Education Department collaborated with FBI on terrorist search –
The American Council on Education pointed out on its website on September 1 that
under an initiative called “Project Strike Back,” the US Department of
Education allowed the FBI to look at the financial records of some hundreds of
students in an effort to thwart terrorism immediately after the 9/11 attacks.
The files accessed were the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA)
files, which number about 14 million each year. (See http://www.acenet.edu)
3 - Technology
Desperate whistleblower turns to YouTube – An engineer has accused the world’s biggest defense contractor
of jeopardizing national security using a unique medium – a video posted on
YouTube. According to an August 30th news story posted on AOL
News, former Lockheed Martin engineer Michael DeKort aired his claims that
the defense contractor had built and the Coast Guard has accepted a number of
boats that fall short of government standards on the video site after getting no
satisfaction by going through the chain of command in his company and in the
government. Although DeKort’s video received only some 8000 hits during from
its posting on August 3rd until the end of the month, his story has
now appeared in print, on radio and on TV – indicating that the Internet has
given the average person a way to be heard. (See http://articles.news.aol.com)
Tech transfer, Wisconsin style – A major article on tech
transfer was recently written by Goldie Blumenstyk and published in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. It
concentrates on the highly successful Wisconsin Alumni Research Foundation which
for over 80 years has commercialized discoveries made at the
University
of
Wisconsin
. While the university has benefited hugely from WARF’s profits, the
Foundation has increasingly been seen as another impediment to stem-cell
research, already hindered by President Bush’s restrictions.
WARF owns the
US
patent that covers stem-cell research, and in addition five of the 21 stem-cell
lines approved for federal research support.
The way it protects those and other properties leads some critics to say
the Foundation is driving some of the research off-shore. The article includes
extended coverage of the origins of WARF and how its policies impact the
University
of
Wisconsin
and others. (See http://chronicle.com/money)
Alternative view of structure of New York’s twin towers –
Abolhassan Astaneh-Asl is a professor of structural engineering at the
University of California at Berkeley who has spent the past five years trying to
understand what permitted the World Trade Center towers to collapse after the
9/11 terrorist attacks. Through the
construction of a detailed computer model, he has concluded that the two
buildings were vulnerable because they were built to Port Authority of New York
and
New Jersey
standards, not to more exacting
New York City
building codes. He carefully avoids
blaming anyone other that the terrorists themselves for the death and
destruction, but says they could have been minimized, writes Jeffrey R. Young in
the September 8 issue of The Chronicle of
Higher Education. The innovative
structures which were a hallmark of the buildings permitted the wings of the
planes, not just the bodies, to penetrate the towers, carrying with them the
fuel which sustained the massive fires that ultimately brought the buildings
down. A report from the National
Institute of Standards and Technology and an investigation led by FEMA both
concluded that the innovative structure of the twin towers was not a factor in
the collapse of the buildings. (See http://chronicle.com)
Yale moves to put lectures on-line –
Yale
University
has announced that they are taking open sourcing of courses one step further.
While MIT started putting course materials on-line for free access
beginning in 2001, Yale will place three courses, including videotaped lectures,
on-line starting next year. The
three courses are Introduction to the Old Testament, Fundamentals of Physics and
Introduction to Political Philosophy. The
professors will not interact with students on-line, but universities in
developing countries would be free to design a course around the lectures as
long as the origin of the materials is given, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/20/yale)
Toys for engineers – LEGO Mindstorms is now offering NXT, a
toy robot with engineering appeal. NXT
offers an opportunity to build a robot that can be programmed in sophisticated
ways and almost infinite possibilities for playing.
Stephen H. Wildstrom, writing in BusinessWeek
on September 4 (page 18, print edition) says that although the NXT is
designed for children as young as 8, LEGO learned that many of the earlier
versions of the toy were actually purchased by engineers for themselves, and so
have included an advanced software development kit to appeal to more advanced
users. (For podcast version see http://www.businessweek.com)
4 - Students, faculty, education
Renaissance engineer of 21st century – Is
engineering the liberal arts degree of the 21st century? That
question has been asked by the dean of engineering and applied sciences at
Harvard, Venkatesh Narayanamurti, according to an article in the
August/September PE. Harvard and other
schools are moving toward a vision of an engineer with a broader education and
area of focus – a concept which he calls the “Renaissance Engineer”.
Harvard’s new technology, engineering and society concentration will give
students both a foundation of scientific and engineering basics and an exposure
to the connections between technology and aspects of society, such as policy,
law, business and ethics. The goal is to train these renaissance engineers to
understand how their work is informed by and influences society. Narayanamurti
believes that renaissance engineers will be the engineers leading society, but
that engineers with deeper, more specific knowledge will still be important in
application areas. (See http://www.nspe.org)
Knowledge integration in science -- Students grapple with
multiple, conflicting and often confusing ideas while they learn scientific
concepts, according to an article by Marcia C. Linn et
al in the August 25th Science.
Research has shown that inquiry learning – where teachers use students’
ideas as a starting point and guide the learners as they add new ideas and sort
them out in a variety of contexts – leads to better knowledge integration than
traditional teaching methods where teachers “cover” many required topics.
This research article describes how interactive visualizations combined with
online inquiry and embedded assessments can deepen student understanding of
complex ideas in science. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Prepackaged team hired – Academic departments typically grow
by adding one faculty member at a time, but the
University
of
Southern California
has experimented with a new approach – hiring a prepackaged team. According
to an article by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the September 1st Science, USC has hired seven scientists who pitched themselves to
the institution as a package. The institution sought to hire researchers who
were already organized into a team, by advertising for “an integrated group, a
mix of full, associate and assistant professors who are innovative,
entrepreneurial, interdisciplinary leaders”. The university both wanted to
break the limits of its own imagination, and achieve economies of scale –
where members of a group applying together would be more willing to share
resources than individuals hired separately. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
SAT scores see big decline – The high-school class of 2006
suffered the biggest drop in SAT scores in more than three decades, according to
an article in the August 30th Wall
Street Journal by Robert Tomsho, raising questions about the recently
revamped exam. Scores in critical reading (verbal) fell by five points to 503,
while math scores slipped two points to 518. The combined decrease of seven
points is the largest since 1975, when there was a 16 point drop. Overall, math
scores have been rising in the past decade, while reading scores have been
relatively flat. The current scores are the first to fully reflect the revised
test introduced in March 2005. Along with a writing section that consists of an
essay and multiple-choice questions, the new test added higher-level algebra and
did away with analogy questions in the reading section. The College Board, which
produces and administers the exam, called the revised SAT a better measure of
the skills students need to succeed in college and work, and minimized the
scoring decline saying that mathematically it means almost nothing. The College
Board’s standing was shaken in March when it acknowledged that errors had
caused more than 4000 test-takers to receive erroneously low scores, stopping
some from getting scholarships or getting into select schools. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Author warns of overbuilding of university research labs –
Daniel S. Greenberg, a journalist who is author of Science, Money, and Politics, wrote an opinion piece in the
September 8 issue of The Chronicle of
Higher Education, in which he summarizes his reasons for thinking that US
universities have overbuilt research facilities.
He thinks universities responded unrealistically to the large infusion of
funding into the National Institutes of Health from 1998 until 2003.
But now that expansion in funds has dried up, leaving open the
possibility that those buildings might not be populated with the research
programs once anticipated. If the US
is, in fact, overbuilt and underfinanced in its research programming, then
competition for ever-more-scarce grants might promote more unethical behavior on
the part of researchers, might result in an inability to even maintain the
buildings due to lack of indirect costs, and finally present a dismal picture to
young students considering a career in science.
(See http://chronicle.com)
Harvard wants to make teaching count more . . . –
Harvard
University
has embarked on a study of how to improve teaching and make it count more
toward tenure, writes Marcella Bombardieri in the September 5 online version of The
Boston
Globe.
The committee should report back by February 1, says Theda Skocpol, the
chair and Dean of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences.
Lee Shulman, president of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of
Teaching, expressed skepticism over Harvard’s ability to change.
He said that universities such as Harvard judge teaching only as to
whether the person is so bad that students are harmed.
Shulman himself attempted the same reform at Stanford over a decade ago,
trying to make teaching play a bigger role in tenure and salary decisions, but
the effort failed. (See http://www.boston.com)
Students at 2-year
colleges unready - As the new school year begins, the 1200 community
colleges in the
US
are being deluged with thousands of students unprepared for college level work.
According to an article by Diana Jean Schemo in the September 2nd Wall
Street Journal, researchers suggest that close to half the students who
enter college need remedial work. The shortfalls persist despite high-profile
efforts by public universities to crack down on ill-prepared students. At least
a dozen states now explicitly bar universities from providing remedial course,
so many who lack basic skills are clustered in community colleges. According to
scores on the 2006 ACT test, only 21% of students applying to four-year
institutions are ready for college-level work in all four areas tested –
reading, writing, math and biology. These statistics indicate a deep
disconnection between what high school teachers think their students need to
know and what professors, even at two-year colleges, expect them to know. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Booting up in
Texas
– Top levels of government, industry and academia in
Texas
are working together to attract more young people to engineering, to avoid
being caught short of the needed supply. According to an article by Thomas Grose
in the September ASEE Prism, the Texas
Engineering and Technical Consortium (TETC) raises money from industry and
government sources then provides seed funding to schools that come up with solid
proposals for increasing engineering graduation rates. Schools are primarily
accomplishing increased graduation numbers by improving recruitment and/or
retention. In addition to the goal of increasing engineering graduation rates,
TETC has two other missions: to increase diversity among those students and to
encourage more collaboration between industry and higher education. To date the
program has raised $16.8-million, and has awarded $14.6 million in 47 separate
grants to 23 schools. (See http://www.asee.org)
So that’s why they’re leaving – Congress has recently been
holding hearings about why a smaller proportion of American college students are
majoring in physical sciences and engineering than in the past. According to an
article by David Epstein in Inside Higher
Ed, some have suggested that biology is now the hot science and that it has
lured many top students away from other fields, or that poor undergraduate
instruction or nerd stigma are keeping students away. But interviews with a
range of scientists and experts on science education home in on other causes:
greener grade pastures (science students get lower grades than non-science
students); weeding out (science and engineering faculty tend to keep grades down
and weed out weaker students); large and impersonal (intro courses are often
taught in large sections); and math and science are taught vertically (student
often must slog through two years of formulaic introductory courses before they
get any taste of hands-on work). In response to these concerns, some
institutions are striving to make the grades in the natural sciences comparable
to those in other fields. And some are trying to teach intro courses in a more
engaging, interdisciplinary way. (See http://insidehighered.com)
Company designed courses at universities – Dissatisfied with
graduates, companies are designing and funding curricula at universities,
according to an article in the September 12th Wall Street Journal by Anne Marie Chaker. A fast-moving, competitive
economy – and the perception that students are unprepared for its demands –
are creating a new phenomenon at colleges and universities, courses supported by
and tailored for potential employers. Corporations such as IBM, Credit Suisse
Group, and BMW AG are seeking to increase their presence and influence on
campuses in this way. IBM has been most aggressive, in helping to create and
promote a new discipline – service sciences, management and engineering. The
discipline focuses on the relationship between clients and service providers by
combining studies in such disparate fields as computer science, engineering,
management sciences and business strategies. IBM contends that these areas are
too segregated in higher education, to the detriment of students, companies, and
ultimately the economy. (See http://www.wsj.com)
The art of engineering – An engineering faculty member at the
University
of
South Florida
has created a popular course that merges his research work with the world of
fine art, according to an NSF press release. Professor David Snider has merged
the two subjects by incorporating the works of the masters, the tools of
artists, and the perspective of engineers. He draws in students with topics that
range from the theories of light to the creation of cameras, and presents the
work of nearly 100 artists in the process. Snider says that his course is like
an optics review, where the laboratory is the art museum. (See press release
06-127 at http://www.nsf.gov/news)
National Academies document persistent bias – “Beyond Bias
and Barriers: Fulfilling the Potential of Women in Academic Science and
Engineering” is the title of the most recent study by the US National
Academies. It was written by a
committee made up of university leaders, scientists and policy makers, headed by
Donna Shalala, president of the
University
of
Miami
. The report points to “unintentional” bias and outdated policies and
practices in institutions as factors which work against women.
The report shows that women abandon “the pipeline” at every stage and
still face discrimination, albeit often subtle in form. Recommendations include
discussion of “climate issues” on campuses, efforts to achieve better
representation of women on editorial boards, and actions by university trustees
and presidents to hold departments more accountable for their hiring processes
and outcomes, reports Doug Lederman in Inside
Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/19/women)
An alternative view on gender discrimination – Following on
the recent publication by the National Academies that points to persistent but
“unintentional” discrimination as a big factor in discouraging women from
careers in science and engineering, two social scientists – from Harvard and
George Mason universities – agreed to release some unpublished and as yet
unanalyzed data from a survey of university professors.
Those data show that a large percentage of professors believe that men
and women have different interests, and that, rather than bias, is the reason
for the low numbers of women. Respondents
were given a choice between three reasons for the predominance of male
professors in math, science and engineering.
One percent indicted difference in ability, 24 percent indicated
discrimination, and 75 percent thought it was attributable to differing
interests, reports Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/09/20/women)
Buying college admission – A review of author Daniel
Golden’s book The Price of Admission:
How American’s Ruling Class Buys Its Way Into Elite Colleges – and Who Gets
Left Outside the Gates written by Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed, outlines Golden’s contention that colleges are
with disturbing frequency admitting students of the rich and famous, as well as
the children of previous graduates, in order to gain monetary benefits.
The book is notable for its frankness, with people and institutions being
named.
Duke
University
, for example, was supposed to have sent signals to private schools a few years
ago that they wanted to admit students whose parents could become big donors,
even though those students might not be notably qualified.
Admissions officers interviewed for this article defend the practice, but
indicate that it is less widespread than it might seem. One chapter is dedicated
to the subject of Title IX. Golden
claims that some schools create women’s teams in costly sports such as
horseback riding and sailing in order to cater to rich white girls with
admissions slots and scholarships. (See http://insidehighed.com/news/2006/09/05/admit)
Harvard drops early admissions – Breaking with a major trend
in college admissions,
Harvard
University
is eliminating its early admissions program next year. According to an article
in the September 12th New York
Times by Alan Finder and Karen Arenson, university officials argue that such
programs put low-income and minority applicants at a distinct disadvantage in
the competition to get into selective universities. Of the 2124 students
admitted by Harvard last year, 813 were granted early admission (38%). Some
universities now admit as much as half of their freshman class this way, and
many (although not Harvard) require an ironclad commitment from students that
they will attend in return for the early acceptance. Harvard’s decision is
likely to put pressure on other colleges, which acknowledge the same concerns
but have been reluctant to take any steps that could put them at a disadvantage
in the heated competition for top students. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Note:
Princeton
University
has announced that it will also drop its early admissions program, according to
a note by Mary Beth Marklein in the September 19th USA
Today (See http://www.usatoday.com)
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
Offshore outsourcing finds fans – Conventional wisdom holds
that globalization has its downsides – it hurts the wages of the lower
skilled, leads to possibly dangerous trade imbalances, and can threaten economic
stability through financial market volatility. For example, offshoring of jobs
to lower wage countries is usually said to make workers in a high wage country
worse off, but the country as a whole better off because consumers enjoy lower
prices on the products made overseas. But at the recent annual symposium of the
US Federal Reserve, speakers offered a much more upbeat vision of a globally
integrated world, according to an article in the August 28th Wall
Street Journal by Greg Ip. A pair of experts from
Princeton
University
argued that offshoring can lead to higher wages for unskilled workers in a
generally high wage country because companies become more productive and thus
can expand and hire more workers. Participants in the conference also discussed
trade deficits and international investment flows, and the interaction of
housing prices with unusually low long-term interest rates. (See http://www.wsj.com)
India
should prepare for offshoring of engineering services –
India
should prepare itself to take advantage of increased off-shoring of engineering
services, especially in automotive, telecom, defense and aerospace, according to
a report published on-line on Zee News on September 6.
The country would need to promote an “Engineered in
India
” brand, construct needed infrastructure, increase linkages with experts, and
work on government policies and planning. All
this would have to be done by 2020 to take advantage of the increased benefits
of providing engineering services, which will increase
India
’s economy more than BPO outsourcing.
(See http://www.zeenews.com)
6 – Journals
European Journal of Engineering
Education – The October 2006 issue of EJEE contains a dozen articles
covering topics that include: do engineering students spend enough time
studying, personality assessment for improved student design team performance,
what makes a good engineering lecturer, how can engineering education contribute
to a sustainable future, enhancing the front-end phase of design methodology,
cryptography teaching strategy, and the Annals of Research on Engineering
Education. (See http://www.tandf.co.uk)
STEM Journal – The
current issue of the electronic Journal of STEM Education, Innovation and
Research contains six articles, covering topics that include assessment of an
engineering course for non-majors, laboratory e-notebooks, and student
perceptions of communications. (See http://www.auburn.edu/research/litee/jstem)
7 – Meetings
ASEE annual meeting call for
papers – Authors are invited to submit abstracts for the 2007
American Society for Engineering Education annual conference, to be held in
Honolulu
,
Hawaii
from 24-27 June 2007. Detailed
information on papers sought by the various divisions of ASEE is contained in
the September issue of Prism and on
the 2007 conference web site. (See
http://www.asee.org)
Colloquium on international
engineering education - The
University
of
Rhode Island International Engineering Program
will host the Ninth Annual Colloquium
on International Engineering Education in
Newport
,
Rhode Island
, November 2-5. The colloquium is designed for engineering and language
educators, international program administrators, deans, provosts, presidents,
corporate leaders, as well as public sector representatives. It provides
an interdisciplinary forum for discussing and sharing ideas and practices
pertaining to the education of engineers for today's global workplace.
(See http://www.uri.edu/iep/colloquia/2006/)
SEFI and IGIP Joint Annual
Conference – A joint annual conference between the European Society
for Engineering Education and the International Society for Engineering
Education will be held at the
University
of
Miskolc
in
Hungary
from
July 1-4, 2007
. (See http://www.sefi-igip2007.com)
UPADI 2006 in
Atlanta
– The biannual convention of the Pan American Federation of
Engineering Societies was held at Georgia Tech from 20-22 September. The theme
of the meeting was engineering a sustainable infrastructure in the American
Hemisphere through education, technology, innovation and economic development.
Keynote speakers covered development bank investment strategies and
transparency as a tool to limit corruption. Several parallel technical
congresses explored responsible engineering practice, hydrologic basins, ocean
and coastal engineering, doing business in the
Americas
, civil engineering and seismic resistant structures, urban development and
population growth, maintenance, engineering education, energy, disasters,
sustainability and transportation. The associated Pan American Academy of
Engineers conducted an extensive Forum on efforts to limit corruption in
engineering projects. (See http://www.UPADI2006.com)
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International
Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com