September 2005
Copyright © 2005 World Expertise LLC – All rights reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S. Oberst, Ph.D.
5 – Employment
6 – Journals
7 – Meetings
UN declaration adopted – More than 150 world leaders approved a declaration on promoting human rights, combating poverty and terrorism, and confronting perpetrators of genocide and mass killings, as described by Colum Lynch in the September 17th Washington Post. The 35-page document is intended to refocus the UN for challenges on its 60th anniversary. Major topics covered included poverty and development, terrorism, human rights, war crimes, arms control, and streamlining the UN bureaucracy. Many provisions were scaled back because of disagreements during weeks of negotiations, however, and other issues – such as how to expand the Security Council – were put off for future attention. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
Corps of Engineers takes heat on levees – The failure of New Orleans’ famed levee system is dragging the US Army Corps of Engineers into a political firestorm, according to an article by Christopher Cooper and Gary Fields in the September 2nd Wall Street Journal. The Corps moved to the center of the story of Hurricane Katrina when it became clear that a 550-foot long stretch of the levee that kept the waters of Lake Pontchartrain at bay had collapsed. That collapse allowed a steady wall of water to flood New Orleans from the north, filling the city center with water as much as 20 feet deep. Two central questions are being asked: did the Bush administration shortchange the system in recent budgets, when enhancements were proposed; and did design or construction flaws in recent work on the system overseen by the Corps contribute to the problem? (See http://www.wsj.com)
Map of Katrina’s impact on higher ed now available
to all – The Chronicle of Higher Education has published an
interactive map of the areas in the US affected by hurricane Katrina.
This map, which can be viewed by non-subscribers, contains information
about the effects of the storm on individual colleges and universities in the
region, campus closures, the status of faculty hiring, etc.
(See http://chronicle.com/free/v52/i04/04a01601.htm)
NSF posts Katrina-related FAQs for researchers, applicants – The US National Science Foundation, among other funding agencies, has posted a list of frequently asked questions (FAQs) in response to concerns of researchers and applicants about the impact of hurricane Katrina. (See http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/policydocs/katrinafaqs.jsp)
Bush takes different tone at UN – In a pair of articles in the September 15th Washington Post, Glenn Kessler, Peter Baker and Colum Lynch describe and analyze the presentation made by President Bush at the annual assembly of world leaders at the United Nations. In his speech, Bush linked the war on terrorism to anti-poverty efforts, and noted that the US shares “a moral duty” to combat the root causes of poverty, oppression and hopelessness that lead to resentment and violence. While he linked his campaign against terrorism to the anti-poverty agenda advanced by other nations, he shied away from adopting some of the specific commitments sought by allies. His demeanor on this visit to the UN, where he stressed international harmony, contrasted with past visits which were marked by bitter disagreements over the war in Iraq. His posture continued a trend apparent since the start of his second term – trying to reach out to a world that has been dismayed with the foreign-policy choices and actions of his first term. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
US college admission test (ACT) reveals persistent weaknesses in math – The ACT, a college admission exam widely used in US higher education, is composed of four tests (English, reading, math and science) each graded on a scale of 1 to 36. In 2005, reports Eric Hoover in The Chronicle of Higher Education, the average composite ACT score was unchanged from the previous year, remaining at 20.9, despite a larger number of students taking the test. Only 26% earned a score of 24 or higher in the science test, and 41% earned a score of 22 or higher in math. Results suggest that there are still substantial numbers of students who arrive at college unprepared for first year math and science courses. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/08/2005081703n.htm)
US college admission test (SAT) reveals highest ever
average math scores – A 2005 report on the SAT, the second
major college admission test widely used in the US, reveals a record high
average math score of 520 (out of 800), while average verbal scores remained
unchanged from 2004, at 508. Male
students still scored higher than females in math, and Asian-American students
have made the most progress in math scores over the past ten years, adding 25
points to reach 580. This article by
Elizabeth F. Farrell in The Chronicle of
Higher Education also reports on the new SAT.
This year, 2005, is the last year for the old version, which will be
replaced by an already-piloted new test starting in 2006.
The new test includes a writing component and questions on grammar and
style. College admissions officers
are undecided whether the new tests will be an additional barrier to low-income
students applying to college. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/08/2005083104n.htm)
OECD warns US its education
system is declining – The Organization for Economic Cooperation and
Development is telling the world that the United States should be concerned
about its educational system, reports Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher
Education. Signs point to the US
losing its dominance in science, to its being outpaced by other countries in the
higher education of its younger generations, to persistent problems in both
literacy and math skills, and to the disappearance of an elite group of math
students coming up through the schools. (See
http://insidehighered.com/news/2005/09/14/oecd)
NSF increases support for TeraGrid – The US National Science Foundation has added $150 million to the $98 million it has already invested in the TeraGrid computing network, reports Vincent Kiernan in The Chronicle of Higher Education. TeraGrid is a high speed data network that links eight institutions, 16 computing systems and six data-storage archives, and is powerful enough to perform over 40 trillion mathematical calculations per second. Says NSF Director Arden Bement, Jr., “ ‘TeraGrid unites the science and engineering community so that larger, more complex scientific questions can be answered.’ ” (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/08/2005081901t.htm)
Open technology standards urged – A group of senior government officials from 13 countries is urging nations to adopt open-information technology standards as a vital step to accelerate economic growth, efficiency and innovation, according to an article by Steve Lohr in the September 9th New York Times. In a report presented to the World Bank, countries are urged to create national policies on open technology standards. The report comes as some governments are pursuing plans to reduce their dependency on proprietary software makers, notably Microsoft, by using more free, open-source software. The report states that government policy should “mandate technology choice, not software development models”. At the World Bank, the interest in open standards mostly involves using them as a tool to help stimulate economic growth in developing countries. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Internet2’s Abilene network to be replaced with HOPI – Researchers are pushing computer networks to permit rapid transmission of ever larger files, reports Vincent Kiernan in The Chronicle of Higher Education. Improvements to Internet2’s Abilene network are in the works, prompted both by researchers’ needs and by the expiration of Internet2’s contract with Qwest Communications in 2007. Before that time, networking specialists will conduct various experiments which should result in a better, faster academic service that combines the technologies currently used by Abilene and the newer fiber-optic network called National LambdaRail. Working under the title of Hybrid Optical and Packet Infrastructure Testbed (HOPI), developers will construct a network which would rely on packet switching, but allow circuit switching, thus increasing speed and capacity significantly. HOPI is not the only such project underway. The National Science Foundation is supporting UltraLight, a high capacity fiber optic network, and the US Department of Energy is supporting UltraScienceNet. These two networks will be connected to HOPI and to other networks around the world. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v52/i03/03a03191.htm)
Educational software for pc dives – Once a booming market, educational software for use on pc’s has lost momentum, according to an article by Matt Richtel in the August 22nd New York Times. In 2000, sales of educational software for home computers reached $498-million, and learning programs for pc’s were seen as a booming growth market. But in less than five years, the sales have plummeted to $152-million. What happened was an explosion of new, often free technologies competing to entertain and teach children. With free games and learning sites now available all over the Internet, parents are finding that they do not need to buy software. And there is a pass-along effect – programs are often handed down among brothers and sisters because titles do not change much over the years. In addition, the nearly universal availability of computers in classrooms has made using home pc’s for learning less appealing. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
The brains business – The September 10th issue of The
Economist contains a major section surveying the state of higher education. It
lists the world’s top universities – 17 in the US, two in the UK, and one in
Japan. And it contains several major articles: why America’s system of higher
education is the best in the world; Europe’s unlikely hopes to become the
world’s preeminent knowledge-based economy; developing countries see the point
of universities; higher education becomes a borderless world for students;
universities have become more businesslike; and a more market-oriented system of
higher education can do much better than a state-dominated model. (See http://www.economist.com)
More women in science – A major report in the August 19th Science analyzes the progress of women in technical fields at US universities in the 25 years since Congress passed the Women in Science and Technology Equal Opportunity Act. It concludes that while there have been major advances, academic institutions are still not fully utilizing the pool of women scientists they have produced. In engineering, 15.34% of Ph.D. graduates at the top 50 departments are women, but only 3.68% of full professors are women. At lower levels, 16.94% of assistant professors and 11.17% of associate professors of engineering at the 50 departments are women. The top 50 departments for each discipline are ranked by NSF according to research expenditures in that discipline.(See http://www.sciencemag.com)
Bundled software driving up cost of college texts – The US Government Accountability Office has issued a report declaring that the cost of college textbooks has risen at twice the rate of inflation over the past 20 years, and that bundled software and supplementary materials which 65% of professors don’t use are to blame for the increase. A full-time college student typically spends $900 a year on textbooks. The Association of American Publishers rejects the report’s conclusions, writes Thomas Bartlett in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/08/2005081701t.htm)
Princeton grants automatic probation extension for new faculty parents – Responding to a recommendation from its 2003 task force on the status of women in the natural sciences and engineering, Princeton University has decided to grant an automatic one year extension of the probationary period for tenure to any man or woman faculty member adopting or expecting a child. Previous to this, the faculty member had to request the extension, something many hesitated to do, writes Patrick Cole in an article posted on August 18, 2005 on The Boston Globe’s website. Princeton is the first university to make this policy change. (See http://www.boston.com)
The college payoff shrinks – Detailed analysis of the US Census Bureau income and poverty numbers for 2004 reveals that the college educated are taking it on the chin, according to an article by Michael Mandel in the September 12th Business Week. Real earnings for workers with only a bachelor’s degree have fallen for four straight years, for the first time since the 1970’s. And the decline – 5% since 2000 – shows no signs of abating. Several factors appear to play into the decline: outsourcing of skilled jobs to China and India; wages held down by oversupply; technology getting easier to use, requiring less education; and hangover from the tech bust. So far, college educated workers have given back only a portion of the 10% increase in earnings since 1994. The change in real earnings for advanced degree graduates was an increase of 2.5% between 2000 and 2004. (See http://www.businessweek.com)
Peering into your students’ minds – Beloit College (USA) has once again released its “mindset list” for the entering class of 2009, most of whom were born in 1987. The list is meant to serve as a reminder to faculty that their new students grow younger every year. This year’s list points out that for most students entering university this fall, “Al-Qaida has always existed with Osama bin Laden at its head, . . . Bill Gates has always been worth at least a billion dollars, . . . It has always been possible to walk from England to mainland Europe on dry land, . . . Scientists have always been able to see supernovas, . . . Irradiated food has always been available but controversial, . . . The Hubble Telescope has always been focused on new frontiers, . . . Digital cameras have always existed, . . . [and] They have always been challenged to distinguish between news and entertainment on cable TV.” (See http://www.beloit.edu)
US chemists urged
to give graduate students more international exposure –
At the American Chemical Society’s annual meeting in August conversation
shifted from the decrease in foreign students coming to the US to discussion of
how to get US students overseas, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed.
Chemistry in America is being held back, according to some, by neglecting
to develop international expertise in graduate students, who need global skills
whether they remain in academic life or take a job in industry.
Catherine E. Costello, a professor at Boston University, lays part of the
blame on the professors themselves, those who have created curricula so strict
that it is impossible for students to take a semester to go overseas for study
or research. Some say the situation
is so critical that even one week programs or any amount of study of foreign
languages would be of benefit. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2005/08/29/chem)
Women researchers disadvantaged in NIH funding – Women who apply for grants from the US National Institutes of Health receive only 63% of the money that male applicants receive, says a report from the Rand Corporation. Inside Higher Ed’s reporter Scott Jaschik says that the National Science Foundation and the US Congress requested the study. Neither the NSF nor the Department of Agriculture had such discrepancies. At the NIH, about one third of the gender gap comes from the largest grants. When factors such as age, size of grant, institution, were taken into account, female applicants receive only 83% of what male applicants receive. Despite these warning signals, the Rand report concludes that there are still deficiencies in data gathering that make its conclusions only tentative. The NIH is advised to gather more information to better determine the absence or presence of gender-related problems in its award of grants. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2005/09/14/gender)
Community and four year colleges told to work together on engineering pipeline – “Enhancing the Community College Pathway to Engineering Careers,” a report issued by the US National Academy of Engineering and the National Research Council, recommends building more strategic relationships between community colleges and four year engineering programs for several purposes, including increasing the diversity of the profession. In 1999 and 2000 40% of the graduates from baccalaureate and master’s degree engineering programs had attended a community college, suggesting the strong link between the two sorts of institutions, writes Jeffrey Brainard in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle,com/daily/2005/09/2005090806n.htm)
Why does college cost so much? – This fall’s probable average increase of 8% in tuition at public universities, added to double-digit hikes in the two previous years, means that tuition at a typical state university is up 36% over 2002, a period when consumer prices in general rose only 9%. According to an article by Richard Vedder in the August 23rd Wall Street Journal, there are six factors that explain the cost explosion: rising demand, lack of market discipline, de-emphasizing undergraduate education, price discrimination, stagnant (or falling) productivity, and better lives for the staff. As a result of the increased costs, US college enrollments are not increasing as much as before, and the US is falling behind other industrialized nations in population-adjusted college attendance. And new forms of competition are arising – for-profit institutions, online schooling, more use of community colleges, and new approaches to certifying skills. (See http://www.wsj.com)
5 – Employment
Off-shore on-line math tutoring – A USA
Today on-line article on off-shoring tutoring services begins with the
example of a 45 year old engineering student at the University of North Dakota,
taking courses on-line from his home in the Caribbean. He found help for his
calculus course with a tutor in India.
That tutor worked for Smarthinking, a US company providing tutoring services
under contract to the UND. “
‘When I want help, I don’t care how I get it,’ ” says Jeff Bowman, the
engineering student. US public
school educators are not so pragmatic: the subject of off-shored tutorial
services is a very sensitive one in the union-controlled and community based US
school systems, especially when outsourcing has already been scrutinized and
often vilified so energetically in other sectors of the economy.
Under President George Bush’s No Child Left Behind legislation, many
children qualify for free math and reading tutoring, which can be provided by
teachers, church groups, not-for-profit groups, and for profit companies.
The for profit companies, although acknowledging the huge market open by
the legislation, and the potential for exploiting the enormous pay differentials
between US and Indian tutors, still are constrained by credentialing issues,
security concerns, differences in culture and communication, and the overall
resistance of US citizens to the notion of off-shoring their children’s
primary and secondary education, reports Greg Toppo. Students don’t appear to
share the concerns of the adults. (See http://www.usatoday.com/printedition/life/20050830/d_cover30.art.htm)
Indian
outsourcing scores a milestone – A
major Dutch bank has agreed to pay $2.2-billion to outsource most of its
technology to five Indian companies, according to an article by Eric Bellman in
the September 2nd Wall Street Journal. According to officials
of the companies which will benefit from the contracts, this shows that the
outsourcing spread is gathering momentum. To date, Indian software companies
have dealt predominantly with clients from the US, with less than 25% of revenue
coming from Europe. It is now anticipated that an increasing amount of future
growth will come from Asia, Latin America and Europe, according to analysts.
(See http://www.wsj.com)
Offshoring into
Africa – An article in the
August 27th The Economist explores whether South Africa can
ride the outsourcing and offshoring wave. Last month Amazon, the online
retailer, opened a software development center in Cape Town. The company chose
South Africa because of its pool of high-calibre IT workers and good
infrastructure. A recent study indicates that South Africa is well placed to
benefit from the trend of firms shifting business processes to cheaper places,
and that this could create 100,000 jobs in South Africa by 2008. Global demand
for offshoring from US and British firms alone is forecast to rise from
$10-billion now to perhaps $60-billion by 2008 – more than countries such as
India, China and the Philippines are able to handle. (See http://www.economist.com)
6 – Journals
The Bridge – The
Fall 2005 issue of the journal of the US National Academy of Engineering focuses
on offshoring of engineering activities, with several articles discussing
globalization, competitiveness, and concerns about outsourcing of engineering
jobs and R&D. One article provides an overview of offshoring and the future
of US engineering, noting that US engineers are in competition with low-wage
engineers in developing countries. Other articles explore what will be needed to
ensure US competitiveness in the global economy, globalization of R&D, and
impacts of offshoring engineering tasks. (See http://www.nae.edu/TheBridge)
IEEE Transactions on Education – The August 2005 issue contains some 23 papers on approaches to the teaching of electrical and computer engineering. An editorial explores whether biology should be required in electrical and computer engineering curricula, citing the trend toward integration of the life sciences and electrical and computer technologies. (See http://www.ewh.ieee.org/soc/es)
7 – Meetings
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com