May 2006
Copyright © 2006 World Expertise LLC – All rights reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S. Oberst, Ph.D.
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
6 – Journals
7 – Meetings
________________________________________________________________________
************************************************************
** **
** Electronic conference on engineering education call for papers **
** **
** The 5th ASEE Global Colloquium on Engineering Education, to **
** be held in
** electronic conference over two months this summer as input to the **
** live conference in the fall. Particularly invited to submit abstracts **
** are engineering educators in developing countries who seldom have **
** the opportunity to participate in face-to-face international meetings. **
** Information can be found at www.engr.colostate.edu/econference/ **
** **
*************************************************************
Canadian science policy review – The new
government in
Chirac unveils high-tech industrial plans – French
President Jacques Chirac has unveiled plans to invest in six high-tech projects,
including a European rival to Google, in a bid to secure
Japanese education ministry to modernize graduate schools – Over the past fifteen years, the profile of Japanese graduate students has changed, with traditional students, just graduated from undergraduate programs, being joined by significant numbers of foreign students and older people with work experience. This explains in part the growing dissatisfaction with Japanese graduate education, which recently led to a significant overhauling of the system, writes Alan Brender in The Chronicle of Higher Education. Gone are the rules and traditions which supported domineering professors who used graduate students as personal employees. And graduate schools are under increased pressure to align their programs more to the needs of society and industry, instead of seeing graduate education as solely designed for creating the next generation of university professors. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/05/2006051006n.htm)
Dissenting views of Chinese higher education – Despite huge
investments in higher education by the Chinese government in the past decade,
which saw infusions of $225 million to Tsinghua University, for example, and an
increase of students from 3.4 million in 1998 to 16 million currently enrolled,
many insiders are saying that the system still is far from breaking with
traditions of rote learning and over-emphasis on research to the detriment of
teaching. Critics say that students
are pressured into taking too many courses at the same time, and that admissions
practices, while designed to cut down on corruption in how students are admitted
into higher education, favor political correctness and work against students who
excel in interdisciplinary and creative fields.
Still, writes Paul Mooney in a major article in The
Chronicle of Higher Education, even critics admit that change of the
magnitude that
Indian government sets off protests with enrollment set-asides –
The Indian government has set off a firestorm of protests by proposing to
reserve more higher education seats for lower-caste citizens in government
operated universities. Violent
protests have already broken out, led by students who say that, taken together,
set-asides for members of “Other Backward Classes” and “Scheduled Castes
and Tribes” would amount to 49.5% of university seats being reserved, too high
in their estimation. Institutions
involved would include the elite Indian Institutes of Technology, universities
such as
Two Koreas build science ties – Some 200
researchers from North and South Korea met in secret in Pyongyang recently,
according to an article in the April 14th Science. The
unprecedented gathering was convened to discuss ways to jumpstart scientific
cooperation across the divided peninsula. Officials from the South Korean
organizations that sponsored the event say that they expect to catalyze joint
projects in nanotechnology, information technology, environmental sciences, and
biotechnology. The long term objective is to narrow the technological gap
between North and South to make it easier to eventually reunify
Chinese scientist accused of fraud – After
having praised a researcher at
Katrina aid from
UK seeking more students from overseas –
British Prime Minister Tony Blair recently wrote an article published on April
18, 2006, in the Guardian announcing
new initiatives to strengthen international ties between UK universities and
institutions around the world. He
set as a goal increasing the number of international students in his country by
100,000 by the year 2011. He
committed £7 million to universities to help them attract new international
students, and announced a collaborative project with
South Korean stem-cell researcher indicted – The
stem-cell scientist who led a research team to produce findings that were later
determined to be fabricated, Woo Suk Hwang, has been charged with fraud,
embezzling some $3-million, and bioethics violations. According to an article in
the May 15th Chronicle of Higher Education
by Lila Guterman, five other members of his research team face lesser
charges. In January a university panel determined that his results had been
fabricated, Science magazine retracted his papers, and prosecutors began
investigating the team. (See http://chronicle.com)
Libyan students can return to US – The US
State Department has announced the restoration of full diplomatic relations with
Industry shrinks academic support – After
two decades of steady increase, industrial funding for US academic research is
on the skids, according to a new report from the National Science Foundation as
reported by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the May 5th Science. A
cumulative 5% decline in the three year period 2002 – 2004 is the first ever
decline for a funding source since NSF began compiling such data in the
1950’s. It reflects a slowing economy and shrinking company research budgets.
Some fear that the decline will continue even as the economy picks up unless
companies and universities figure out how to better share the results of
company-sponsored research. University officials see collaborations with the
private sector as an increasingly important revenue source, but they also want
to maximize income from technologies developed on campus. Some industry
representatives say that US institutions have become so aggressive in protecting
intellectual property arising out of industry-funded projects that negotiating
research contracts is becoming very difficult and time consuming. Some companies
are transferring their research support to other countries, such as
K-12 situation critical – Study after study
paints a gloomy picture of K-12 student performance in math and science in the
Math and science degrees have fallen –
The US Government Accountability Office has reported that despite an increase in
college enrollments over the past decade, the proportion of students obtaining
degrees in science, technology, engineering and mathematics has fallen.
According to a report in the May 4th Chronicle of Higher
Education by Amy Rainey, the GAO reported to Congress that 27% of
students received degrees in the STEM fields in 2003-04, compared with 32% in
1994-95. It also noted that the number of degrees in engineering, the biological
sciences, and certain technical fields declined in the past decade. The number
of graduate degrees awarded in the STEM fields also declined. The GAO testimony
suggested increased outreach at the K-12 level, especially to female and
minority students, and increased use of mentors to encourage enrollment in those
fields. (See http://chronicle.com)
Brains and borders –
Texan to lead math panel – Larry R.
Faulkner, the former president of the
Prizes for breakthrough technologies – The
US Congress is considering legislation which would establish a $10-million pool
of money as prizes for breakthrough technologies. The “H-Prize” would follow
the form of the previous privately funded $10-million Ansari X Prize which led
to the first privately developed manned rocket to reach outer space twice,
according to an article in the May 16th Inside Higher Ed by
David Epstein. The proposed legislation would reward “transformation
technology” over the next ten years, with four prizes up to $1-million for
advances in hydrogen distribution, production, storage or utilization every
other year, in addition to one prize of up to $4-million for a hydrogen vehicle
prototype. (See http://insidehighered.com)
Bill seeks access to tax-funded research – Introduction of legislation in the Senate that would mandate that US taxpayers have free access to the results of all federally financed research has intensified the debate on this controversial issue, according to an article in the May 3rd Washington Post by Rick Weiss. The legislation would demand that most recipients of federal grants make their findings available free on the Internet within six months after they are published in a peer reviewed journal. It is a rebuke to scientific publishers, who have asserted that free access to their contents would undercut their paid subscription base. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
Earmarks obscure trends in science spending – Congressional
earmarking of federal research programs has become so extensive that it can be
difficult to tell whether spending by federal agencies for merit-reviewed
scientific grants is rising or falling, according to President Bush’s science
advisor, John Marburger. The volume
of directed grants, called “pork” by some, has reached a point where it
threatens the missions of the agencies. According to an article in the April 21st
New York Times by Jeffrey Brainard, earmarked funds often are for
purposes that do not support the agencies’ work plans. (See http://chronicle,com)
Degrees @ StateU.edu – Online university
enrollment at US universities is soaring, according to an article in the May 9th
Wall Street Journal by Daniel Golden. While overall higher education
enrollment in the
Intel to offer global Internet access – Aiming to help close the digital divide, the Intel Corporation plans to announce a design for a sub-$400 educational laptop and a five year, $1-billion program to train teachers and to extend wireless digital Internet access worldwide. According to an article in the May 2nd New York Times by John Markoff, the moves are intended to bolster Intel’s reach into new markets, as well as to have an effect on the American market for computers in education. The company, which has already supported the training of some 3-million teachers, plans to support the training of 10-million teachers around the globe. The Intel plan will focus on full-featured computer systems with enough power and memory to run Microsoft software. Intel’s rival chip maker, Advanced Micro Devices, has backed the concept of Nicholas Negroponte at MIT to develop a sub-$100 notebook computer for educational use in developing nations. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Distance education update – Universities around the world have embraced distance learning as a way to increase student enrollment without having to build more lecture halls and dorms. And, according to an article in the April ASEE Prism by Nancy Shute, distance learning also appeals to working students and to their employers, given the opportunity to advance educations without disrupting the workday. Schools of engineering are often leaders in distance education on campuses, given their expertise in applying technology to human endeavor. For many engineering schools, the move to distance education has been a response to the needs of corporations which are anxious to offer professional education to their employees conveniently and at competitive prices. One persistent concern is the lack of interaction between instructors, students and peers. Teleconferences, e-mail and chat rooms are utilized to address that issue. (See http://www.asee.org)
Fight for toll-free Internet – Universities
are discovering that users of the Internet can hit unexpected roadblocks,
according to an article in the April 27th Chronicle of Higher
Education by Andrea Foster. Telecom companies providing broadband
service may reject video feeds, for example, steering universities to their
commercial dedicated videoconference lines instead – with healthy charges.
Universities are concerned that such actions by telephone and cable companies
could thwart college’s attempts to deliver education and collaborate on
research over the Internet. Academe is pressing Congress to pass legislation
that would force telecommunications companies to keep the broadband pipes that
they manage open to any type of Web content or network application – even
those that compete with the companies’ own offerings. Those pressing for this
legislation call its principles “net neutrality”, meant to convey the idea
that broadband providers should be neutral toward the content and services that
flow through their networks. (See http://chronicle.com)
Improved academic high speed network – When negotiators for the merger of Internet2 and National LambdaRail called off talks recently, leaders of Internet2 forged ahead alone with a plan to contract with an undisclosed telecommunications company to provide service for a new network called NewNet. According to spokespersons for Internet2, NewNet would have two primary features: it would permit users to obtain increased capacity virtually on demand, and at the same time, it would relieve the network’s operators of the day to day responsibility of maintaining the fiber optic network. National LambdaRail owns its fiber optic network and claims that this frees them to offer researchers service as it likes, without being dependent on an industry provider. Vincent Kiernan wrote this article for The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/free/2006/04/2006042601t.htm)
Blackberry e-mail to be offered in
French higher learning clings to old ways – The
recent protests against a proposed law that would make it easier for French
employers to dismiss young workers has pointed out a fundamental problem with
higher education there, according to an article by Elaine Sciolino in the May 12th
New York Times. Universities in
Education for women in the
Costly textbooks draw scrutiny of lawmakers – College
students protesting high textbook prices are finding new allies in state and
federal lawmakers, according to an article in the April 25th Wall
Street Journal by Shearon Roberts. Virginia and Washington have enacted laws
designed to make textbooks more affordable, and lawmakers have introduced
similar bills in 10 other states. The cost of textbooks has received increased
attention as some book prices have climbed above $100. A 2005 federal government
study indicated that textbook prices have increased at twice the rate of
inflation during the past two decades. On average, college students spent $900
on books and supplies in 2003-04. The
Design failures as learning experiences -- Henry
Petroski, well known as an engineer and author, has written an article on
failure which was published in The
Chronicle of Higher Education in April.
Petroski believes that faculty must stimulate engineering students to
confront unknowns by studying failure. Examples
abound, including the Frank Gehry designed Weatherhead School of Management at
Case Western Reserve University, whose artistically sculpted design had to be
re-thought when an accumulation of snow and ice came cascading down onto the
sidewalk, endangering passersby. Such
a building in a warmer climate would not have posed that problem, so Petroski
says that students should learn from such situations in order to provoke them to
considering potential design flaws in detail. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v52/i34/34b03201.htm)
Technological advances in inquiry learning – Computer simulations enhance inquiry based learning, in which students actively discover information, by allowing scientific discovery within a realistic setting. An article by Ton de Jong in the April 28th Science states that young students need to learn how to regulate their own learning, to continue to gain new knowledge, and to update their existing knowledge. The author defines inquiry learning as a process of exploring the natural or material world that leads to asking questions, making discoveries, and rigorously testing those discoveries in the search for new understanding. Computer simulations are suggested as a helpful tool in producing effective and efficient learning situations. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Deadly sins of professors – An American university professor, writing under the pseudonym of Thomas H. Benton, has composed a list of the seven deadly sins of professors and published them in The Chronicle of Higher Education.. The list includes greed (as demonstrated by the refusal of senior faculty to support higher compensation and benefits of part-time colleagues); anger (cultivated for decades by faculty bound together in stifling departments); lust (which now perversely restrains even beneficial faculty-student relationships); gluttony (alcohol abuse); envy (social climbing, condescension, etc.); and pride (knowing more and more about less and less confers the right to pontificate about everything and anything). (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v52/i36/36c00101.htm)
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
Watch out,
Social Engineering – Writing in the April
19th Wall Street Journal, the CEO of Lockheed Martin –
Robert Stevens – addresses concerns about the trends in numbers of
undergraduate degrees in science and engineering in the
Red flag in the brain game – America’s
dismal showing in a recent contest of college programmers highlights how China,
India and Eastern Europe are closing the high tech gap, according to an article
in the May 1st Business Week by Steve Hamm. In the world
finals of the ACM International Collegiate Programming Contest in April, only
one US team finished in the top twelve positions, with teams from
6 – Journals
Chemical Engineering Education – The Spring 2006 issue opens with an article on “Tulane: Katrina and its Aftermath”. The bulk of the issue is dedicated to “The next millennium in chemical engineering”, with articles on the chemical industry and the curriculum of the future. (See http://cee.che.ufl.edu/index.html)
Journal of Engineering Education – The April 2006 issue of ASEE’s research journal includes articles on the globally competent engineer, inductive teaching and learning methods, problem solving, student perceptions of engineering entrepreneurship, and biomedical engineering ethics. The paper on the globally competent engineer focuses on working effectively with people who define problems differently. (See http://www.asee.org)
International Journal of Engineering Education – The
current issue includes 21 papers that cover the spectrum from gender studies to
engineering education research and policy. Topics include competency-based
education, case-based learning, engineering internships, the art of estimation,
lab on the web, rapid prototyping, and software design. (See
http://www.ijee.dit.ie/)
7 – Meetings
NAE Convocation – The annual convocation of
the US National Academy of Engineering and the Professional Engineering
Societies was held on May 8th and 9th, focused on
“Rising Above the Gathering Storm – Challenges to US Engineering Societies:
Internal Opportunities and External Responsibilities”.
Keynote speaker was Norman R. Augustine, retired CEO of Lockheed Martin
Corporation, who chaired the National Academies Committee on Prospering in a
Global Economy in the 21st Century. He described the findings of the
committee study: science and technology undergirds the
World Conference on Continuing Engineering Education – During
19-21 April, the International Association for Continuing Engineering Education
sponsored a major conference in
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com