INTERNATIONAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION DIGEST
March
2007
Copyright © 2007 World Expertise LLC – All rights
reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education
leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S.
Jones, Ph.D.
CONTENTS
1 - International developments
- European
Union steps back from open-access
-
Russia
prepares to follow
Bologna
Declaration
-
US
universities expanding into
India
- International
Polar Year launched
- Foreign
student visas still a problem for US
2 -
US
developments
- Report
tells NSF to think more boldly
- ABET
sticks to dual-level accreditation prohibition
- US
needs to improve foreign language skills
- Democrats
rescue technology research program
- Guidelines
for licensing inventions
3 - Technology
- Scholars
find ways to circumvent Internet filtering
- Oil-rich
Emirate prepares for post-oil world
- Digital
overload?
- Alternative
energy booming
4 - Students, faculty, education
-
US
agencies quiz universities on the status of women in science
- Faculty
salaries favor engineering
- Early
retirement for faculty
- Support
for women faculty at RPI
- Ranking
of doctoral programs
- Copy-and-paste
papers put profs on offensive
- The
rankings revolt
- Pleading
for acceptance
5 - Employment,
competitiveness
- Shortage
of engineers?
-
Eastern
Europe
snags research labs
- Labor
shortages in
Europe
- International Journal of
Engineering Education
- European Journal of
Engineering Education
1 - International developments
European Union steps back from open-access –
Europe
recently focused on the growing international debate over free access to the
results of publicly funded research, as reported by Martin Enserink in the
February 23rd issue of Science.
An online petition signed by almost 14,000 researchers and 500 research
organizations in the EU was presented to a meeting of the European Commission,
asking it to take bold action on so-called open access. Traditional scientific
publishers mounted a counteroffensive, arguing that the future of scientific
communication – as well as their €3-billion European industry – is at
stake. The publishers’ argument carried the day for the moment, and the
Commission failed to enact a mandatory open-access policy for EU-funded
scientists. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Russia
prepares to follow
Bologna
Declaration –
Russia
is likely to restructure its higher education system for implementation this
fall by introducing a two tiered system of degrees that would bring it into line
with the stipulations of the Bologna Declaration.
The five year diploma would be replaced by a three to four year
bachelor’s degree, followed by a one to two year master’s, writes Bryon
MacWilliams in the March 23 issue of The Chronicle of Higher Education. The intent is to make higher
education more responsive to the needs of the economy, in part by permitting
students to change majors more easily. Engineering,
however, along with medicine and some other professions, would retain the
current five year diploma format. (See http://chronicle.com)
US
universities expanding into
India
–
India
is the new frontier for US colleges and universities that want to expand
overseas, writes Somini Sengupta in the March 26 edition of The
New York Times. With only 7% of
the 18 to 24 year old population in
India
entering into universities, opportunities for new institutions are vast.
Doubling that percentage would require building 1500 additional colleges
and universities, according to government figures. Rather than opening branch
campuses, as they have in places such as
Qatar
and
China
, US institutions are electing to form partnerships with Indian counterparts,
engaging in study abroad programs, distance education, and curriculum design
along US models. While laws
governing how foreign universities can operate in India are still not clear, a
new law is under consideration in the Indian Parliament that may give them more
latitude than government-accredited institutions currently have in terms of
salaries and curricula. (See http://nytimes.com)
International Polar Year launched – March 1 marked the
beginning of the International Polar Year, and the fiftieth anniversary of the
International Geophysical Year, writes Richard Monastersky in the March 9 issue
of The Chronicle of Higher Education. Sponsors
of the IPY include the International Council for Science and the World
Meteorological Organization. As many
of 50,000 researchers from 63 countries may take part in the two year study of
the
Arctic
and
Antarctica
, looking at those areas as early monitors of the changing earth environment.
Organizers hope that the activities will help inspire a new generation of
scientists, and serve as the basis for new curriculum development in high
schools and colleges. (See http://chronicle.com)
Foreign student visas still a problem for US - A new study is
casting a damper on the favorable interpretation of last November’s “Open
Doors” study, which some believed indicated that the crisis in foreign student
enrollments in the US was over. Education Sector, a
Washington
think-tank, studied the student visas actually issued by the
US
in various countries around the world. Despite
a 15% increase in the number of visas issued in 2005-2006, the total number of
visas issued is about 20,000 less than before 9/11.
At the same time, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed, the study points out that other countries such as
Australia
and
France
are working hard to attract foreign students and largely succeeding.
US
visas for students in
China
,
India
and
Korea
, which have traditionally sent large numbers of students to the States, are
increasing. International education
leaders in the
US
are confirming that much still needs to be done to attract more foreign
students, including have more consistent policies, so that Homeland Security,
for example, cannot cancel out decisions made by the State Department. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2007/03/22/visas)
2 -
US
developments
Report tells NSF to think more boldly – A draft report from
its oversight body calls on the National Science Foundation to be more receptive
to funding wild-eyed ideas that just maybe could revolutionize science,
according to an article in the March 9th Science
by Jeffrey Mervis. The Board’s proposal calls for a separate
“transformational research initiative,” but NSF Director Arden Bement feels
that adding another program would tax the already overburdened staff. NSF’s
peer-review system is widely seen as the gold standard for selecting
high-quality research proposals, but Board members say they are worried that
some scientists do not even apply for grants that cut across the scientific
grain because of “the external
perception that NSF is not as welcoming as it should be to such research”. The
Board report asks NSF to come up with a management plan for its suggested
direction by August. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
ABET sticks to dual-level accreditation prohibition – In
response to a recommendation in the National Academy of Engineering’s
“Engineer of 2020” report, ABET has reviewed its longstanding policy which
prohibits accreditation at both bachelors and advanced levels in a particular
curriculum at a given institution. In a recently released white paper,
introduced by ABET past president Richard Seagrave, the arguments presented for
and against allowing dual level accreditation of engineering programs are
reviewed. The discussion in this review is similar to that in 1968 and in 1989,
when the rule prohibiting dual level accreditation was previously reviewed.
Those supporting removal of the prohibition argue that the material necessary to
properly prepare graduates for the profession can no longer be accomplished in
four years, and that institutions that offer both bachelor’s and master’s
degrees deserve the opportunity to have them both accredited. Those opposed to a
change in the current prohibition argue that institutions would be pressured to
seek accreditation at both levels, that identifying the necessity of a fifth
year would negatively impact engineering enrollments, and that employers appear
to be satisfied with current four-year graduates. ABET has decided that “…it
is neither prudent nor appropriate for ABET to unilaterally change its policy at
this time without a clear consensus from the engineering community”. (See http://www.abet.org)
US needs to improve foreign language skills – A new report
from the National Research Council indicates that Department of Education
programs designed to strengthen education in foreign languages and in
international area studies have made some progress but lack the resources to
keep pace with their mission. The report indicates that more support from all
levels of the
US
education system is needed to develop an integrated approach to improving
foreign language skills and expertise in other cultures, beginning in the
primary grades. Universities should play key roles, partnering with federal
officials to create systems to continuously improve the programs. (See http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?RecordID=11841)
Democrats rescue technology research program –
Written off as dead by
critics and fans alike, the Advanced Technology Program has been given a
$79-million lifeline from Democrats in the US Congress, according to an article
by Eli Kintisch in the March 2nd Science.
ATP was begun in the early 1990’s as a way to help companies conduct
research aimed at commercializing new products. Critics have derided it as
so-called corporate welfare. But top congressional Democrats view the program as
an essential part of their “Innovation Agenda”. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Guidelines for licensing inventions – New guidelines have been
issued by some of the
US
universities that have been most successful in commercializing inventions.
These guidelines suggest ways to balance “doing well” and “doing
good.” For example, universities
are urged to sue only when necessary, to seek fewer exclusive licenses for ideas
which involve human health, and to ensure that licensing does not impede
benefits for developing nations. “In
the Public Interest: Nine Points to Consider in Licensing University
Technology,” is the white paper which resulted from a 2006 meeting held at
Stanford University, writes Goldie Blumenstyk in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. The eleven universities hope that their
experience will provide best practice advice to the increasing numbers of
institutions that are becoming active in licensing. (See http://chronicle.com)
3 - Technology
Scholars find ways to circumvent Internet filtering –
About forty countries around the world filter the Internet, thus
limiting their scholars’ access to information, reports Sam Kean in the March
23 issue of The Chronicle of Higher
Education. But software has been
developed that permits scholars to circumvent these filters and access forbidden
sites undetected. Tor, for example,
sends information through complex routes, thus discouraging anyone from
attempting to trace illegal use of the Internet.
Psiphon relies on social networks, where users in free societies can
create nodes for colleagues working in censored environments.
The colleagues then log into the node, establish a secure, encrypted
connection, and then can access the internet without being filtered.
(See http://chronicle.com)
Oil-rich Emirate prepares for post-oil world –
The Masdar Initiative is a comprehensive and multi-faceted effort by the
Abu Dhabi Emirate (UAE) to address energy-related issues and look toward a
post-oil world. Included under the
Masdar umbrella are the Clean Technology Fund (250 million
US
$) and a special economic zone for advanced energy industries.
Plans are underway for a 500 megawatt solar power plant to be operating
by 2009. A graduate level research
partnership has been designed in collaboration with MIT, with a focus on
renewable energy. MIT officials
point out that
Abu Dhabi
is the first oil producing state that is facing the fact that oil may not
always be the dominant form of energy in the world.
The plan is for
Abu Dhabi
, under Masdar’s leadership, to become a center of expertise in “solar
energy, photovoltaics, energy storage, carbon sequestration and hydrogen
fuel,” writes Hassan M. Fattah in the March 18 edition of The
New York Times. (See http://nytimes.com)
Digital overload? –
There are two reputable estimates of how much digital information exists
in the world, and whichever one you believe, the numbers are staggering.
In 2003, the
University
of
California
at
Berkeley
said the globe produced 5 exabytes (5 billion gigabytes) of information.
A new figure released by IDC, a technology research firm, gives the
figure as 161 exabytes, the equivalent of 12 piles of books stacked on Earth and
reaching to the sun. Contributing to
the numbers are such factors as the increasing large role of individuals in
creating information (think YouTube), and data-retention regulations.
This leads to concerns about storage of increasing amounts of data, and
the challenges associated with locating, retrieving and understanding it, says
this Associated Press article from the March 6 edition of The
New York Times. (See http://nytimes.com)
Alternative energy booming – Move over, dot.com, and
make way for watt.com.
Silicon Valley
is witnessing a new cycle of enthusiasm as entrepreneurs, venture capitalists
and miscellaneous professionals eager to catch the latest wave all discover the
field of alternative energy. Matt
Richtel, writing in the March 14 on-line edition of The
New York Times, describes what he characterizes as an “energy boomlet,”
not yet quite as dynamic as the dot.com frenzy which peaked in 2000, but similar
in attracting people who expect to make significant change in the world and to
make money doing so. In contrast to
the dot.com industries, alternative energy industries must develop products and
services. If successful, these developments may well decentralize energy
production to the level of solar panels on private homes.
(See http://nytimes.com)
4 - Students, faculty, education
US
agencies quiz universities on the status of women in science – The
US
government has begun questioning research universities to determine whether
their treatment of women students in science and engineering violates federal
law, according to an article by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the March 30th
issue of Science. Federal officials
have visited four academic departments on three campuses in the past 14 months
to monitor their compliance with a 1972 law that prohibits sex discrimination in
educational programs and activities receiving federal funds. The law’s Title
IX has traditionally been used to broaden women’s participation in sports;
educators say this is the first time the government has applied it to
long-standing gender imbalance in fields such as physical sciences and
engineering. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Faculty salaries favor engineering – Engineering, along with
business and law, remain the fields where professors earn the highest salaries
in the
US
, reports Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher
Ed. According to data released by the College and University Professional
Association for Human Resources, a new assistant professor of engineering
averages $69,510 annually while a new assistant professor of music averages
$46,212. At the full professor
level, the average engineering faculty earns $102,954, while the average full
professor of law and legal studies will take in $121,301.
Salary compression, where a newly appointed faculty member earns more
than a more senior colleague, can be detected in engineering: that new assistant
professor’s salary of $69,510 is only slightly below the average for all
assistant professors in engineering, $69,896.
(See http://insidehighered.com/news/2007/03/12/cupa.)
Early retirement for faculty – When 1361 institutions of
higher education were surveyed on their early retirement incentive programs, of
the 567 institutions which responded, 38% said that they had such a program, and
half of those had been made available since 2000.
Programs have a variety of features.
Eligibility occurs mostly at ages 50, 55 or 60, and is sometimes coupled
with a minimum number of years of service. Some
institutions are offering phased retirement, to permit faculty to reduce their
obligations in return for a promise to relinquish tenure at a future date.
Once retired, a variety of benefits may be offered, including access to
libraries, health facilities, e-mail, and parking, with a few institutions also
providing some travel support, office space or secretarial support.
This article was written by Scott Jaschik for Inside
Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2007/03/13/retirement)
Support for women faculty at RPI - RAMP-UP is the name of a new
initiative of Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI) designed to move its women
faculty through the academic ranks to full professor, writes Elia Powers in Inside
Higher Ed. The program, with
support from the National Science Foundation, follows up on various reports,
including one by the National Academies in 2006, that point out the
under-representation of women in science and engineering faculties due, in part,
to institutional policies and structures. RAMP-UP emphasizes mentoring, with
senior women helping more junior women to design a plan for development.
RPI will also hire “coaches” to work in each college advising
individual faculty and promotion and tenure committees.
There is also money available to help women in their research.
(See http://insidehighered.com/news/2007/03/28/rpi)
Ranking of doctoral programs – A new system of ranking
doctoral programs is being offered by PhDs.org, and provides an alternative to
the controversial U.S. News & World
Reports’ approach, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed. The new system gives
– for free – information on over 5,000 programs at 400 universities, and
allows users to select factors that are most important to them, for example
tuition costs, time to degree, job placement after graduation, etc.
Then a weighting system is used and a personalized ranking of departments
is generated, with both an overall rank and how the departments ranked in
different criteria. The data come
from information provided by institutions to the US Department of Education, the
National Research Council and the Survey of Earned Doctorates.
The NRC data are at this point old, leading to criticisms that these new
rankings are flawed, but on the other hand, the PhDs.org system allows for
work-arounds when data for a particular program are missing, something that the U.S.
News system doesn’t do. A representative from U.S.
News indicates that pretending that reputation, which is fundamental to that
publication’s ranking system, isn’t important is disingenuous.
(See http://insidehighered.com/2007/03/30/rankings)
Copy-and-paste papers put profs on offensive – More incidents
of college students plagiarizing other’s work are popping up today than ever
before, according to an article in the March The Institute. A survey of students indicates that 10% admitted to
plagiarizing in 1999, whereas almost 40% said they did so in 2005. Many
professors place the blame on the Internet, which has made plagiarizing a simple
copy-and paste process. But lack of understanding of what plagiarism is, and a
lack of basic education in ethics also add to the increase. One key to stopping
plagiarism is to make sure students understand proper attribution. Spotting
plagiarism has gotten easier with search engines such as Google, and special
detection software, but faculty members rarely run papers through such
time-consuming checks. One professor sets strict limits – using more than four
consecutive words or lifting an uncommon phrase may be plagiarizing. (See http://www.ieee.org/theinstitute)
The rankings revolt – Fed up with arbitrary ratings lists,
college presidents are teaming up to develop a better alternative. According to
an article in the April 2nd issue of Time, few colleges are willing to risk their prestige by dropping
out of what has become a hugely influential beauty contest –
U.S.
News and World Report’s annual
college rankings. U.S. News compiles
such lists because readers buy them, but lists can invite gamesmanship. This
year, however, a small but growing number of schools are starting to fight back.
The heads of a dozen private colleges are preparing a letter to send to their
counterparts at 570 or so small to midsize schools, asking whether they would be
willing to pull out of the U.S. News ranking
process. (See http://www.time.com)
Pleading for acceptance – Community college graduates are a
qualified group, but according to an article in the March Prism by Jeffrey Selingo, the door to four-year universities is
often tough to open. While two-year colleges have long been seen as a stepping
stone to a bachelor’s degree in the
US
, engineering is one of several academic fields in which four-year colleges have
been reluctant to establish formal transfer agreements with community colleges.
A report released in 2005 by the National Academy of Engineering found that
community colleges are “essential” to the education of American engineers,
but “have not reached their full potential”. The report noted that 40% of
recipients of bachelor’s and master’s degrees in engineering in 1999 and
2000 had attended a community college. (See http://www.asee.org/prism)
5 - Employment,
competitiveness
Shortage of engineers? –
A group of researchers from the Pratt School of Engineering at
Duke
University
has reported that there is no shortage of engineers in the
US
, but that shortages exist in both
India
and
China
, which are turning out record numbers of engineers.
The report, “Where the Engineers Are,” appeared in the spring issue
of Issues in Science and Technology,
writes Lauren Smith in the March 30 edition of The
Chronicle of Higher Education. The
researchers surveyed 58 American companies that are outsourcing engineering
jobs. According to them, 80% of
engineering jobs in their companies are filled within four months.
Offshoring is occurring not because of any deficiencies in
US
education or workers, but because it is cheaper to hire engineers overseas.
(See http://chronicle.com) Another
article, written for the March 19 issue of Business
Week by Pete Engardio, notes that
the Duke report suggests that the real challenge will be for the
US
to increase its emphasis on graduate work in engineering, in order to retain
its hold on research and design. (See
http://www.businessweek.com)
Eastern Europe snags research labs – Google has joined IBM,
Motorola and others and opened a research lab in Poland, to capture a share of
the well-educated computer science graduates of such universities as AGH
University of Science and Technology in Krakow, writes Colin Woodard in the
March 13 edition of The Christian Science
Monitor. In recent years Eastern
Europeans have won top programming competitions pitting them against
international contestants: this has attracted the attention of companies
searching for new talent. Science
and engineering both were emphasized under the former Soviet rule, and now
students in
Hungary
,
Poland
and the
Czech
Republic
have excellent education in mathematics and a keen interest in software.
While competition from
India
is strong, Eastern European students are at an advantage when dealing with
Western Europe
in terms of geographic proximity and some shared cultural values. Local
industry has discovered that partnerships with universities are vital to their
continuing success. One large
problem looms on the horizon, however. Since
academic jobs do not pay as highly as industry, universities worry that there
will not be enough students who will opt to pursue graduate degrees and become
the next generation of professors who will keep the momentum going.
(See http://www.csmonitor.com)
Labor shortages in
Europe
- Some
sectors of European economies are suffering from labor shortages, reports Carter
Dougherty (with contribution by Eric Sylvers) in The New York Times on March 10. The people who are looking for jobs
do not have the skills required by industries which are more high tech and less
involved in heavy industry. And
European universities are not turning out appropriately trained people fast
enough to supply the needs of growing companies.
The Association of German Engineers says that last year there was a 30%
increase in the number of engineering jobs available in
Germany
, with 22,000 open positions. Solutions
include recruiting from abroad, outsourcing, and going into the schools to
persuade students to study in fields where there are labor shortages.
(See http://nytimes.com)
6 – Journals
International Journal of
Engineering Education – The current issue, vol.23 no.1,
contains a special section on Trends in Pre-college (K-12) Engineering
Education. A dozen papers focus on topics such as integrating engineering in
middle and high school classrooms, partnering to bring engineering concepts to
elementary students, and infusing design into the grade 7-12 curriculum. The
issue also contains eleven papers on engineering education research,
university-industry cooperation, engineering design, etc. (See http://www.ijee.dit.ie)
European Journal of Engineering
Education – Issues 1 and 2 of Volume 32 have been released. The
first has articles on learning of structural engineering concepts, quality in
engineering education, peer assessment, and preparing foreign students for
engineering studies. The second includes articles on active learning, teaching
of sustainable design, enhancing university-industry cooperation, and
continuous improvement in engineering education, (See http://www.informaworld.com)
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International
Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com