January
2005
Copyright © 2005 World Expertise LLC – All rights reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S. Oberst, Ph.D.
5 – Employment
6 – Journals
7 -- Meetings
Help offered to students caught in backlash of
tsunami – The
Thai university organizes tsunami relief project –
Scientists seek clues to disaster prevention – Having claimed more than 150,000 lives and destroyed billions of dollars of property in the Indian Ocean Tsunami, nature has reminded the world of the cost of ignorance. Now, according to an article by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the January 7th Science, the nations devastated by the massive earthquake and tsunami are hoping to marshal the political and scientific will to reduce the toll from the next natural disaster. Researchers are gearing up for an international data-collection effort in the affected countries, aimed at improving models of how tsunamis form and setting up a warning system in the Indian Ocean. Scientists are traveling to the ravaged coasts to survey how far inland the water ran up at various points along the shorelines, how tall the waves were, and how fast they hit. Such data will enable researchers to test computer models that simulate the propagation of tsunami waves and the pattern of flooding when they break upon the shore. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Clamor grows for global network of ocean sensors – An
oft-ignored plea to the US government to improve a federally funded tsunami
warning system is falling on more receptive ears in the wake of the tragedy in
South Asia, according to an article by Eli Kintisch in the January 14th
Science. Scientists at the US National
Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), which runs a six-buoy network of
pressure sensors in the
Lesson in how not to rebuild –
Low enrollment of low-income students in
the
US slips in attracting the world’s best students – American
universities, which for half a century have attracted the world’s best and
brightest students with little effort, are suddenly facing intense competition
as higher education undergoes rapid globalization, according to an article by
Sam Dillon in the December 21st New
York Times. The European Union, moving methodically to compete with American
universities, is streamlining the continent’s higher education system and
offering American-style degree programs taught in English.
Algerian academic and political figure released on
bail in
Japanese junior faculty get name change – By tradition and
law, Japanese academic departments are broken up into chairs, in which a full
professor oversees one or two assistant professors as well as lecturers and
research associates. According to an article by Hiromi Yokoyama in the December
17th Science, change is
coming in that system due to a recommendation from a Ministry of Education
advisory committee. Assistant professors would become associate professors with
the same educational and research duties as professors, but at a lower rank.
Lecturers and research associates would also receive greater independence. The
committee is soliciting comments, and hopes to finalize its recommendations next
spring – to go into effect in 2006 or 2007. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Student deferrals revoked by Russian government – The Russian government has suddenly called for an immediate end to all military deferrals, including those granted to university students, writes Bryon MacWilliams for The Chronicle of Higher Education. This has resulted in students being dragged from their dormitories and put into the army, where they face violence and deprivation in the service of their country. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/01/2005011204n.htm)
European accreditation report – The EURopean ACredited
Engineer project (EUR-ACE) has completed its first stage and has made public the
first version of tentative “EUR-ACE Standards and Procedures for the
Accreditation of Engineering Programmes”. The aim of this effort is to
increase transparency and comparability in European engineering education in the
context of the
Settlement reached in Albanian university strike – A faculty strike which began at the Polytechnic University of Tirana, Albania, and then spread across other higher education institutions in the country, has ended with promises of higher pay for faculty and more autonomy and money for the universities. Both severe brain-drain and the pressures to conform to the Bologna Process of educational reform have placed faculty under pressure in recent years, according to the article written by Aisha Labi in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/12/2004121606n.htm)
Arab entrepreneur promotes student involvement –
Entrepreneurship in the Gulf region was given a boost when the Higher Colleges
of Technology in Sharjah, the
Books and lab equipment arrive in
Japanese budget accelerates competitive grants – The budget
recently adopted by the cabinet of the Japanese Prime Minister features a 2.6%
boost for the direct funding of research, far outpacing the 0.1% rise in overall
government spending. According to an article by Dennis Normile in the January 7th
Science, the budget also implements a
concerted effort to wean university scientists off a system of small but
universal block grants and onto one that rewards the best ideas, with a 30% rise
in funding for competitive grants. Universities will also feel the bite of
increased competition. They will have to become more dependent for their
operating expenses on overhead charges on grants to their faculty members,
instead of direct government funding to support operating expenses. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
US R&D outlays to rise in 2005 – A sharp rise in federal
spending on military systems is expected to drive total funding for research and
development in the
Engineers Week 2005 – The annual observance of Engineers Week,
February 20-26 this year, will focus on international aspects, according to an
article in the January issue of Engineering
Times. Materials from the “ZOOM into Engineering” effort, developed in
collaboration with the PBS television show “ZOOM”, are being translated into
Arabic, French, Hindi, Malayalam, and Russian on the EWeek web site, to
facilitate its international thrust. One feature of this year’s EWeek will be
highlighting of Engineers Without Borders –
NSF audits point to need for increased monitoring, accountability – The National Science Foundation (USA) received two audits of its operations, both containing some criticisms. The first report, an outside audit conducted by KPMG, stated that the agency should better monitor the institutions that receive money, especially those whose past performance puts them at high risk of mismanagement. The second, an internal audit conducted by NSF's inspector general, said that the foundation is still not able to insure that principal investigators file annual and final reports of funded projects on time, and that some researchers have received additional grants even when in default on their obligations under previous grants. In fact, over the past five years, 47% of the required reports have not been filed on time or have not been filed at all. The internal audit recommended tighter controls, writes Kelly Field in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/12/2004121603n.htm)
New model for funding tech transfer – Some
Harvard president upsets women – Harvard University President
Laurence Summers has provoked a new storm of controversy by suggesting that the
shortage of elite women scientists may stem in part from “innate”
differences between women and men, according to an article by Michael Dobbs in
the January 19th Washington
Post. At a meeting on the progress of women in academia, Summers laid out a
series of possible explanations for the underrepresentation of women in the
upper echelons of professional life, including upbringing, genetics and time
spent in child-rearing. Some women who attended the meeting said they felt that
Summers was implicitly endorsing the notion that there are genetic differences
that inhibit girls from excelling in math and science. In an interview after the
conference, Summers said that some critics had erroneously interpreted his
remarks as suggesting that women can’t do science. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
NIH plan for open access undergoes changes – In the latest development involving the proposal by the US National Institutes of Health to make available the results of research it has funded, the NIH announced compromises on two important issues. The first compromise would call for a six month lag between the publication of papers written on NIH funded research and the posting of those papers in an online archive for free public access. The second compromise is the statement that researchers would not be forced to release their papers to the online archive. Richard K. Johnson from the Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition praises these compromises. Other interested parties scoff at the suggestion that any researcher would be willing to jeopardize future NIH funding by refusing to release their writings. Possibly in response to the NIH project, twenty publishers and three patient groups have agreed to create patientInform, a project to translate into layperson's terms significant articles on diabetes, cancer and heart disease and make them available online. This article was written by Lila Guterman of The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v51/i18/18a02801.htm)
Whiskers threaten electronic devices – Engineers are racing to
avert what could become a plague of short circuits in electrical and electronic
devices, according to an article in the January 10th Fortune
by Ivan Amato. A group of theorists at the University of Maryland estimate
that tin whiskers have caused losses of billions of dollars to date –
including the loss of the Galaxy 4 communications satellite in 1998, which shut
down 40-million pagers, and interrupted ATM and credit card transactions. And
the problem could get worse, as the march of miniaturization means that even
smaller metal whiskers can short out the ever smaller distances between
electronic surfaces. The problem has been exacerbated by the move to get lead
out of electronic products, to reduce human exposure -- but lead inhibits the
growth of tin whiskers. Industry is seeking effective lead-free solutions, but
clear winning approaches have yet to result. (See http://www.fortune.com)
Google plans to digitize major library holdings –
Google announced recently that it had signed contracts with distinguished
libraries such as Harvard, Stanford, and
Costs for computer security rise on US campuses – Georgia State University’s computers are attacked over five million times each week, according to officials. With numbers such as these, it is not surprising that each year larger percentages of information technology budgets at US colleges and universities are being spent on computer security. Strategies include hiring an information security officer, installing firewalls, holding security awareness workshops, and developing formal security plans. With so many processes being run by computers, writes Andrea L. Foster in The Chronicle of Higher Education, there is too much at stake for colleges and universities to be lax in addressing the dangers of IT attacks. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v51/i17/17a00101.htm)
Frosh scoops Jobs – In late December a
Harvard freshman announced to the world that Apple Computer was about to release
a $499 Mac, thus scooping the company which had scheduled the big announcement
for January. Apple has sued; the
student claims he doesn't have the money to defend himself; and, according to
Jeffrey R. Young, reporter for The Chronicle of Higher Education, a
spokesperson for Apple was not available to comment.
Apple's claim is that the student, Nicholas M. Ciarelli, used illegal
means to extract information from employees. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2005/01/2005011405n.htm)
"Google Scholar" riles chemists – Google’s creation of a service it calls “Google Scholar” has caused the American Chemical Society to sue it, writes Jeffrey R. Young in The Chronicle of Higher Education. The society claims that the term violates its “common law” trademark on the term scholar, because its Scifinder Scholar is frequently referred to as simply “scholar.” The Google service, which is free, permits users to conduct full text searches of various scholarly materials, although some materials might require payment of fees. The ACS tool permits searching of scientific journals, patents and more. It charges users, mostly college and universities, significant fees to subscribe. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/12/2004121404n.htm)
Report ranking grad programs delayed – The National Research Council (USA) has delayed the publication of its well-known ranking of graduate programs until 2008 due to lack of funds, reports John Gravois in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/12/2004121306n.htm)
High tech visas fund NSF scholarships – A popular federal
scholarship program for low-income and disadvantaged undergraduates has been
extended, thanks to reforms in the process that allows foreign workers to hold
high-tech jobs in the
2003
Retention in engineering education – The cover story in the
January ASEE Prism, by Margaret
Loftus, recognizes that retention is a big issue in engineering education and
points out that more schools are developing programs to keep students from
dropping out. Engineering students are reported to look around and see
non-engineering students not working hard, and asking them selves “Why an I
killing myself for this?” Schools that are directly addressing the retention
issue find that students learn better and are retained at higher rates if they
are part of an academic community – perhaps studying together, having peer
mentors, or living together. Some schools have developed programs to ease the
high school to college transition, or provide professional counseling. A
nurturing atmosphere that has open-door access to faculty members in another
effective approach. (See http://www.asee.org/prism)
AP exams, not courses, good predictors of college
success – A new study has challenged the assumption that taking
Advanced Placement courses in high school has predictive value for success in
college. Two researchers, Kristin
Klopfenstein and M. Kathleen Thomas, queried records from
Impact of ABET EC2000 – The Accreditation Board for
Engineering and Technology has made an interim report on its longitudinal study
on the impact of outcomes-based accreditation criteria on ABET programs and
their graduates. More than 75% of program chairs report greater curricular
emphasis on knowledge and skills central to EC2000 a-k criteria. 70% of chairs
report high levels of faculty support for continuous improvement efforts. More
than 75% of employers rate new engineers as adequately or well prepared in basic
technical skills, problem solving, teamwork, and lifelong learning. 95% of
chairs report ABET is an important source of the increase in their program’s
use of assessment. (See http://www.abet.org)
Canadian students earn credit for development work abroad – The Canadian government has created a program through which Canadian students can earn academic credit for working with developing countries. Canada Corps hopes that each college or university will eventually send at least one student to engage in a project that promotes democracy, such as creating court procedures. Most of the internships will take place in countries where institutions already have academic links, according to Karen Birchard in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v51/i19/19a03303.htm)
Stopping tenure clock not enough – University policies aimed at giving women time to have a family and a career are no match for the pressure to publish, according to an article by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee in the December 17th Science. In the past decade, dozens of universities have changed their tenure policies to accommodate the family needs of their faculty members. They have adopted rules that provide time off from tenure-track positions, created part-time tenure slots, and spread the gospel about the need to make room for family choices in the climb up the academic ladder. But many women are fearful that choosing to take advantage of such policies will place them at a disadvantage. In a recent survey at a major research university, 42% of women did not request to go off the tenure clock, and too-thirds of them said that it was because of fear that an extension would have an adverse impact on their careers. There are scant data on whether stopping the clock actually hurts a faculty member’s chance of receiving tenure; but at one major university, none of the ten women who have taken extensions for childbirth or other family-related reasons have been denied tenure. Experts say that the academic community must figure out how to meet the needs of the next generation of women faculty members if academic research is to remain an attractive career for them. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Students bear more of college costs – College students in
virtually every state in the US will be required to shoulder more of the cost of
their education under new federal rules that govern most of the nation’s
financial aid, according to an article by Greg Winter in the December 23rd
New York Times. Because of the
changes, which take effect next year and are expected to save the government
$300-million in the 2005-06 academic year, at least 1.3-million students will
receive smaller Pell grants – the nation’s primary scholarship for those of
low income. Beyond the implications for Pell grants, the new rules are also
expected to tighten up access to billions of dollars in state and institutional
grants, thus increasing the reliance on loans to pay for college. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Pell reform announced, generating elation and concern
– Pell Grants are the
On the trail of academic fraud – An article by Alex Kingsbury
in the January 17th U.S. News
and World Report describes efforts of the FBI’s diploma mill task force to
pursue fraudsters who sell fake academic credentials using anonymous mailboxes,
website hoaxes and spam. It is estimated that there are thousands of such degree
mills in operation, and that their total market is about a billion dollars.
Public demand for phony degree credentials drives the supply; sometimes with the
speed of the business world, companies do not take the time to check the
credentials of the people they hire. (See http://www.USNews.com)
Student employees in US still exempt from Social Security tax – The US government took steps recently which will allow most student employees, including research and teaching assistants, to be exempt from paying Social Security taxes, notes Jeffrey Selingo in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v51/i18/18a03602.htm)
5 – Employment
Job outlook for college seniors brightens – According to a survey by the National Association of Colleges
and Employers, the job outlook for college seniors continues to improve. As
reported in a January 4th article by Megan Ballinger and Erin White
in the Wall Street Journal, surveyed
employers predicted an increase in hiring for the second year in a row –
indicating 2005 hiring 13.1% above the 2004 rate. About 70% of employers said
they planned to increase starting salaries for new college graduates – an
average increase of 3.7%. The five most “in demand” majors are accounting,
electrical engineering, mechanical engineering, business administration and
management, and economics and finance. (See http://www.wsj.com)
More offshore outsourcing seen – More than 80% of the
world’s top 2000 corporations will have established significant outsourcing
operations overseas by the end of 2005, according to a report conducted by a
consulting group in
6 – Journals
European Journal for Engineering Education – EJEE Volume 29-4 is a theme issue, on New Perspectives of the Engineering Disciplines – Active Learning in Engineering Education. Guest Editors Michel, Graaff and Christenson have assembled eleven papers on active learning, including topics such as project based education, online roleplay, virtual enterprise, interactive design course, and preparing students to co-operate, communicate and compete. (See http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals)
Issues in Science and Technology – The Winter 2005 issue
features a major paper by Michael Kearns, “Economics, Computer Science, and
Policy”, based on a recent named lecture at the National Academies. The author
illustrates his perspective that cross-fertilization of ideas and techniques
between economics and computer science is yielding fresh insights that can help
inform policy decisions. Other papers in this issue are on preventing a nuclear
9/11, moving drugs to market, international comparisons of student achievement,
managing the life sciences, and agricultural biotechnology. (See http://www.issues.org)
7 – Meetings
ICWES13 – The 13th International Conference of
Women Engineers and Scientists will be held in
ICEE 2005 – The International Conference on Engineering
Education, sponsored by iNEER, will be held at the
IGIP 34th annual conference – An engineering education symposium organized by Yeditepe University in Istanbul, Turkey, under the sponsorship of the International Society for Engineering Education (IGIP) is scheduled for 12-15 September 2005. The theme is “Design of Education in the 3rd Millennium – Frontiers in Engineering Education”. Abstracts are due by March 1st. (See http://www.igip-ees05.yeditepe.edu.tr)
WFEO 7th World Congress on Engineering Education – The
Committee on Education and Training of the World Federation of Engineering
Organizations is organizing a conference on 4-8 March 2006 in
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com