INTERNATIONAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION DIGEST
August
2006
Copyright © 2006 World Expertise LLC – All rights
reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education
leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S.
Jones, Ph.D.
CONTENTS
1 - International developments
- The
Bologna
process – transforming European higher education
- The
widening gulf
- Sexing
up science
- Taking
on TOEFL
- The future of globalization
- The
Middle
East
muddle
- Singapore-Hopkins partnership ends
- University
partnerships to aid developing countries
- Struggle
to fill
UK
VC positions
- Indian
test grading scam
- Accreditation collaboration in
Asia
-
China
enhances manufacturing capability
2 -
US
developments
- NASA chief blasts science advisors
- NSF awards $75.3 million for five new engineering
research centers
- US loosens policy on ties to UNESCO
- Congress working on bill to maintain US lead in
science
- Federal
panel on higher education draft report
- Rallying
behind open access
- Yahoo
stocks up with academics
- US
backs off increased restrictions on foreign scientists
- Technological literacy in the
US
- NSF
wants PIs to mentor their postdocs
- U
of
Texas
$2.56-billion for science and technology
- New engineering director at NSF
3 - Technology
- U
of
California
system joins book scanning project
4 - Students, faculty, education
- Mondialogo Engineering Award second round
- College Board broadens its push into the classroom
- To recruit and advance women in science and
engineering
- New
ideas for PhD education
-
Princeton
stands alone in “
US
News” rankings
- Canadian
universities bow out of ranking scheme
- Intro
to study abroad
- Chaos in the classroom in
China
- International
rebound
- ABET seeks comments on dual-level accreditation
- Student
plagiarism continues to stir controversy at
Ohio
U
-
Ohio
U hearings on plagiarism
5 – Employment, competitiveness
-
Germany
alarmed at lack of engineers
- Out
of visas, again
- Putting
that degree to work
6 – Journals
- Journal
of Engineering Education
- IEEE Transactions on Education
- Chemical
Engineering Education
7 – Meetings
- National Academies meeting on competitiveness
- NAE workshop on offshoring of engineering
________________________________________________________________________
1 - International developments
The
Bologna
process – transforming European higher education – An agreement
among the education ministries and the universities and colleges of 45 European
countries to create the European Higher Education Area (EHEA) by 2010 has been
named the Bologna Process. According to an article by Roderick Floud in the
July/August issue of Change, one core
agreement is the decision that all higher education institutions in
Europe
will adopt the three-tiered degree structure of bachelor’s, master’s and
doctoral degrees, familiar in
North America
. Underpinning these degree structures are agreements about quality assurance,
student mobility, new ways of measuring student achievement, and the
relationship between teaching and research. As a result, major changes are
underway in curricula, the missions of universities, their relationship with
national and regional authorities, and their governance. After some initial
hostility, academics throughout most of
Europe
have begun to embrace the idea of totally rethinking their programs. University
autonomy is a major issue, with states seeking to assert control through quality
assurance systems and control over budgets and student fees. (See http://www.heldref.org)
The widening gulf – A new report from the Rand Corporation
suggests that the primary beneficiaries of the technological progress that will
take place over the coming decades will be the nations currently in the
forefront of scientific and technological achievement, not developing nations.
In an article in the August Civil
Engineering, Anne Elizabeth Powell reports on the findings of a Rand study
entitled “The Global Technology Revolution 2020”, and examines what the
findings mean for American civil engineers. The study points out that the
nations that are the most advanced scientifically and technologically are also
the ones that are the most developed, so they will benefit most from the ongoing
technology revolution as they acquire and implement whatever technology
applications best satisfy their needs and achieve their goals. As a consequence,
the gulf that now divides the scientifically advanced nations from those that
lag scientifically will likely widen. Thus where people live will have a big
impact on how new technology applications affect their personal health and
standard of living, and will also play a part in determining the ability of
their countries to protect them and their environment. (See http://www.cemag@asce.org
for the article, and for more information on the study itself see http://www.rand.org/pubs/monographs/MG475)
Sexing up science – The president of
India
, an aeronautical engineer who stewarded his country’s guided missile program,
has made it his mission to raise
India
to glory through scientific scholarship. According to an article in the August
21-28 Newsweek International by Mac
Margolis and Karla Bruning, 74-year
old A.P.J. Abdul Kalam travels from school to school exhorting students to hit
the books and excel in science. By all indications the budding scientists of
India
have taken that advice to heart. Enrollment is soaring in engineering and
technical schools throughout
India
– and elsewhere in
Asia
.
India
,
China
and
South Korea
are producing legions of engineers much larger than the
US
, and those graduates are vying for and winning contracts, customers and patents
in an increasingly competitive global marketplace. And that is leading educators
in the wealthiest countries, such as the
US
, the
UK
and
Germany
, to lose sleep. These three engineering titans still lead the way in
technological innovation, but enrollment in university engineering programs is
stagnating and the dropout rate further diminishes numbers of graduates. Now
Western educators are trying to fix the problem by curricular changes, such as
presenting students with real-world challenges early on. And engineering
organizations are trying to correct the misconception that science and
engineering jobs are geeky, dirty and dull. (See http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14324892/site/newsweek)
Taking on TOEFL--
The Test of English as a Foreign Language (TOEFL), the high-stakes test
that is an ultimate gate-pass to admission to a US college or university, has
increased competition from the International English Language Testing System
(ILETS), reports Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed. ILETS, associated with Cambridge University and others, has long
been the most popular test for students wanting to study in the UK, Australia,
and other parts of the British Commonwealth.
While the tests are similar, there are two distinctive differences.
The price to take ILETS has been less, although now that the TOEFL has
switched to a sliding price scale, that distinction is diminishing.
And the speaking part of ILETS is administered face-to-face, while the
TOEFL requires candidates to record their speaking answers for assessment later
by a panel of six graders. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/08/07/ilets)
The
future of globalization –
The
Doha
round of trade talks ended in failure in July, after a five year
stalemate. According to an article in the July 29th The
Economist, the failure is a disaster, born of complacency and neglect, and
it signals a defeat of the common good by special-interest politics. If the
wreck is terminal, as seems likely, everyone will be the poorer – perhaps
gravely so. The round of talks was intended to lift millions out of poverty,
curb rich countries’ ruinous farm support, and open markets for countless
goods and services. In the long run, the lack of commitment to multilateral
trade that sunk the
Doha
round will also start to corrode the trading system as a whole. (See http://www.economist.com)
The
Middle
East
muddle -- When people interested in the US-Middle East Partnership
Initiative created in 2002 by the US State Department met in
Washington
,
DC
, recently there was much concern expressed about how current events in the
region have impeded university collaboration which was one of the key elements
of the program. Of the US$300
million already spent on promoting the spread of democracy, the empowerment of
women, economic development and strengthening of education, about US$2 million
has gone to several universities. Now
some promising projects involving
Lebanon
are on hold. Supporters of the
program, however, point to successes, including the establishment of an
engineering program for Saudi women run collaboratively by
Duke
University
and
Effat
College
, wrote Rob Capriccioso in Inside Higher
Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/08/10/mideast)
Singapore-Hopkins
partnership ends
–
Singapore
’s government
and
Johns
Hopkins
University
are shutting down a joint research and education program that
Singapore
has funded for 8 years at a cost of more than $50-million. According to
an article in the August 4th Science
by Dennis Normile, the partners are blaming each other for failing to
achieve goals on recruiting faculty, enrolling students, and transferring
technology to local industries. The partnership was focused on biomedical
sciences, and included formation of a clinic. A
Singapore
spokesman indicated that the joint effort was an experiment that did not
give the desired results, and noted that the government there is collaborating
with other universities such as MIT. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
University partnerships to aid developing countries - At the
annual meeting of Higher Education for Development, an organization which
sponsors links between US and foreign institutions of higher education for the
purpose of economic and social development, speakers described projects funded
by the US Agency for International Development (USAID).
One program aims at strengthening the national academies of science in
developing countries in order to provide governments with impartial information
when making important public policy decisions.
A speaker for the World Bank said that since the late 1990s the Bank had
been shifting its emphasis from basic to tertiary education with emphasis on
technology, quality assurance, and improved pedagogy.
According to reporters Beth McMurtrie and Burton Bollag, writing for The Chronicle of Higher Education, the point was made that these
education partnerships play an important role in gaining friends for the
US
. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081404n.htm)
Struggle to fill UK VC positions - Universities in the UK are
losing their vice chancellors at such a fast rate that there is a danger of
their not being able to find suitable candidates for replacement, writes Anna
Fazackerley in The Times Higher Education
Supplement on August 8. The
challenges of the job are pushing some to leave early, in hopes that fresh ideas
can help solve the myriad of difficult problems facing the institutions.
Some institutions are looking abroad for candidates, and training
opportunities for new leaders are being expanded.
(See http://www.thes.co.uk)
Indian test grading scam - Exam papers from students at
Chaudhary Charan Singh University in Uttar Pradesh, India, were being graded by
unqualified reviewers, creating a huge scandal, reports Shailaja Neelakantan in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. According
to reports, the university’s registrar, B.L. Arya, sent 80,000 answer sheets
to his son in
Agra
. Police raided the son’s home and
found that students at levels equivalent to juniors and seniors in US high
schools were grading the exams for a few rupees each.
Students who learned of the arrests turned violent.
No decision has been made about whether the students will have to retake
the exams. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081704n.htm)
Accreditation
collaboration in Asia
–
Malaysia
and
China
have agreed to work together on a mutual accreditation program for
tertiary students of both countries, according to a July 24th article
by Hoo Ban Khee in the Malaysian Star.
Malaysia
will establish a Malaysian Qualifications Agency to maintain a list of
accredited courses and colleges. One motivation is to promote the attraction of
more Chinese students to Malaysian educational facilities, focusing on regions
in mid-west
China
. Currently some 10,000 Chinese students are hosted in
Malaysia
. (See http://thestar.com.my)
China
enhances manufacturing capability – Raising the bar for competitors
around the world,
China
is shifting its manufacturing resources to increasingly sophisticated goods
such as auto parts. According to an article in the August 1st Wall
Street Journal by Andrew Batson, detractors have previously concluded that
the precision engineering required for the best parts was beyond the reach of
inexperienced Chinese companies and their low-cost workers. But quality has
improved so much that major Western auto makers like Volkswagen and Daimler
Chrysler are planning to buy billions of dollars of Chinese-made components such
as brakes, fuel pumps, wheels and steering systems. Such gains show how
China
continues to evolve as a manufacturer, posing new challenges for rivals in the
US
,
Japan
and
Europe
. (See http://www.wsj.com)
2 -
US
developments
NASA
chief blasts science advisors
– NASA Administrator Michael Griffin has read the riot act to the outside
scientists who advise him, accusing them of thinking more of themselves and
their research than the agency’s mission. According to an article in the
August 25th Science by
Andrew Lawler, these harsh comments came on the heels of the resignation of
three distinguished scientists from the NASA Advisory Council, two of whom
questioned Griffin’s plan to dramatically scale back a host of science
projects. A major disagreement is over President Bush’s plans to send humans
back to the moon and to Mars, and the resulting need to scale back robotic
efforts. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
NSF
awards $75.3 million for five new engineering research centers – The US National Science Foundation has awarded major funding for five new
Engineering Research Centers that will develop cross-disciplinary research
programs to advance technologies that address major societal problems and
provide the basis for new industries. The partnerships will pursue breakthroughs
in synthetic biology, fluid power, air monitoring, drug manufacturing, and
technologies for older adults and people with disabilities. The new centers are
Synthetic
Biology
Engineering
Research
Center
(SynBERC), Quality of Life Technology Engineering Research Center (QoLT),
Engineering
Research
Center
for Compact and Efficient Fluid Power (CEFP), Mid-Infrared Technologies
for Health and the Environment (MIRTHE), and
Engineering
Research
Center
for Structured Organic Composite (C-SOC). (See http://www.nsf.gov/news/news_summ.jsp?cntn_id=107939)
US
loosens policy on ties to UNESCO
– The US government has withdrawn restrictions it placed a year ago on
contact between US citizens and UNESCO, according to an article in the August 18th
Science by Yudhijit Bhattacharjee. In
May 2005 the
US
Ambassador to
UNESCO sent a memo to the UNESCO Director General asking the organization to
consult US officials before partnering with anybody in the
US
or planning
any
US
events. That directive was effectively retracted last month by a memo
that said that the
US
government merely wants to stay informed about contacts between UNESCO
and US entities. US scientific societies were relieved by the move, which they
say should help restore free exchange between US researchers and the
international body. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Congress
working on bill to maintain US lead in science – A small group of congressional
staffers is at work in Washington this summer on legislation that could
influence science spending for years to come, according to an article in the
August 18th Science by
Jeffrey Meyers. The aim is to develop legislation that would show the public
that the nation’s leaders have a long range plan of action on
US
competitiveness. The legislation draws upon several recent efforts at
examining
US
science and technology, including the National Academies’ “Rising
Above the Gathering Storm”. Various proposals have been put forth to expand
existing research and education activities at several agencies and set up new
programs, but the current effort is the consolidation of all such efforts into a
single bill. There is concern, however, that calls for increased spending in
this area are a sticking point for the President and the Republican Party, who
have pledged to reduce the federal deficit and shrink government. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Federal panel on higher education draft report - Last fall
US
Secretary of Education, Margaret Spellings set up a Commission on the Future of
Higher Education. After several
draft reports that evoked the wrath of many educators, that commission recently
approved a final draft report, with only one dissenting vote.
The report, which includes numerous recommendations, is designed to
improve access, accountability and competitiveness in US colleges and
universities. Many of the large
higher education associations issued statements which were both supportive of
some aspects of the report and critical of others.
David Ward, president of the American Council on Education, and a member
of the Commission, was the one dissenting vote, stating that he could not
support its homogenized view of higher education. The report was written by
Kelly Field in The Chronicle of Higher
Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081101n.htm)
Rallying behind open access - A group of provosts from
twenty-five major research universities wrote an open letter in support of open
access to research findings. This came within the context of the US Congress’s
consideration of the “Federal Public Research Access Act,’’ which would
require federal agencies to make publicly accessible the research results from
their funded projects within six months of initial publication.
Commercial publishers and scholarly associations which publish journals
are not happy with this increased pressure toward open access, reports Scott
Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed. But
the provosts wanted to make the point that the interests of scholars do not
necessarily coincide with those of commercial interests and to refocus the
debate on the topic. (See http://insidehighered/com/news/2006/07/28/provosts)
Yahoo stocks up with academics – Hoping to overtake its rivals
such as Google, Yahoo is hiring top notch economists and other researchers to
tackle some of its biggest challenges. According to an article in the August 25th
Wall Street Journal by Kevin Delaney,
Yahoo’s goal is to enhance its ability to record what millions of consumers do
each day and to study how the company’s web services affect their behavior.
Internet companies, which have largely lacked the systems and focus to mine data
for research purposes, are now viewing that ability as a key competitive
pursuit. Web operations are data-rich lands where internet companies can observe
in real-time the behavior of millions of consumers in varied marketplaces.
Researchers believe that collating web activity can be used to target Internet
advertising and to predict consumer activities. One concern to collecting and
analyzing such data is customer privacy, as was illustrated this summer when AOL
inadvertently released a slew of information relating to user’s search
queries. (See http://www.wsj.com)
US
backs off increased restrictions on foreign scientists - The US Defense
Department has backed away from the stringent requirements it proposed last
year, restricting even further the access that foreign researchers could have to
sensitive technologies in university labs. After
being hit with dozens of letters of protests from universities, writes Jeffrey
Brainard in The Chronicle of Higher
Education, Defense said it would instead add to its research contracts a
reminder to obey Defense and Commerce Department regulations.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081501n.htm)
Technological
literacy in the US
– A newly released study from the National Academy of Engineering and the
National Research Council indicates that the technological literacy of the
US
population is not well measured. The report, “Technological Literacy of
US Population Not Well-Assessed; Additional Surveys Needed”, states that
governments and the private sector should develop tests and surveys to measure
American’s knowledge of technology, how they use it in their daily lives, and
their ability to make informed decisions on issues involving technology. Data on
technological literacy could allow policymakers to better respond to people’s
concerns about technology, and help educators improve technology-related
curricula and teacher’s education. (See http://www8.nationalacademies.org/onpinews/newsitem.aspx?RecordID=11691)
NSF wants PIs to mentor their postdocs – US funding agencies
have traditionally steered clear of micromanaging the relationship between
principal investigators and their postdocs, according to an article in the
August 11th Science by
Yudhijit Bhattacharjee. Some postdocs say this hands-off policy encourages PIs
to treat them as skilled laborers rather than apprentice scientists. The US
National Science Foundation has taken a small step to addressing such concerns
with a directive aimed at getting scientists to take their mentoring roles more
seriously. A letter from NSF’s geosciences directorate asks grantees and grant
applicants to spell out their mentoring activities in both grant proposals and
in annual and final reports. The goal is to make sure that postdocs acquire
vital skills such as grant writing, lab management, research ethics, and
teaching at the same time that they are advancing the frontiers of science. (See
http://www.sciencemag.org)
U of Texas $2.56-billion for science and technology - The US
National Academy of Science report, “Rising Above the Gathering Storm:
Energizing and Employing American for a Brighter Economic Future,” is cited by
University of Texas officials as part of the impetus for a plan for the
University of Texas System to spend $2.56 billion on science and medical
research, reports Karin Fischer in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. The
money will enable the system to expand its research space by 30%, to undertake
44 capital construction projects, and to spend $80.4 million for a new
engineering research building at the
University
of
Texas
at
Arlington
. The University of Texas M.D.
Anderson Cancer Center in
Houston
and the
University
of
Texas
at
Austin
will receive the most money. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081104n.htm)
New
engineering director at NSF
– Richard O. Buckius has been named to head the Engineering Directorate at
the US National Science Foundation. An expert in thermal sciences, he has been
professor of mechanical engineering and is former head of the Department of
Mechanical and Industrial Engineering at the
University
of
Illinois
at Urbana-Champaign. He received his academic degrees in mechanical
engineering at the
University
of
California
,
Berkeley
. At NSF he previously served as head of the Thermal Systems and
Engineering Program and the Division of Chemical and Transport Systems, then
acting assistant director for engineering. (See http://www.nsf.gov/news/news_summ.jsp?cntn_id=107926)
3 - Technology
U of
California
system joins book scanning project - Google’s controversial project to
digitize all the books of the world in full text took another giant step forward
when the
University
of
California
system agreed to participate, giving access even to books still protected by
copyright, reported Jeffrey Young in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. Two
major lawsuits are pending, challenging Google’s right to scan copyrighted
materials, even though Google claims it will allow only excerpts to be offered
unless publishers agree. (See http://chronicle.com/free/2006/08/2006080901t.htm)
4 - Students, faculty, education
Mondialogo
Engineering Award second round – The first round of the
Mondialogo Engineering Award (2004-05) brought together over 1700 young
engineers from 79 countries in 111 teams. The overall goal of the Award program,
a DaimlerChrysler-UNESCO partnership, is to promote intercultural dialogue among
young people around the world. Teams of engineering students in universities in
developing and developed countries cooperate in the design, production and
presentation of project proposals that address basic needs in developing
countries, focusing on poverty eradication, sustainable development, and the
other UN Millennium Development Goals. (See http://www.mondialogo.org)
College
Board broadens its push into the classroom – The developer of the Scholastic
Aptitude Test (SAT), the College Board, is broadening its activities to reach
deeply into high school and even middle school classrooms nationwide. According
to an article by Karen Arenson in the August 16th New
York Times, the board is marketing new products such as English and math
curriculums for grades 6 through 12. In November it will open a new institute
for principals. While it says it is eager to bring new rigor to education, it
appears that the board is also being driven by competition from the ACT in
college admissions testing. And some colleges are making the SAT optional.
Critics of the new activities are concerned that the entry of the board into
middle and high schools will bring too much standardization of curriculum and
further promote a culture of testing. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
To
recruit and advance women in science and engineering – The National Academies have
released a new study, published as “To Recruit and Advance: Women Students and
Faculty in US Science and Engineering”. The book identifies and discusses
better practices for recruitment, retention and promotion for women scientists
and engineers in academia – describing actions actually taken by universities
to improve the situation for women. (See http://www.nap.edu/catalog/11624.html)
New ideas for PhD education - A recent meeting of the State
Higher Education Executive Officers (SHEEO) featured a discussion of some new
models of doctoral education. One
example was
Antioch
’s program in leadership and change, a non-residential program.
Students are all well over the usual age for doctoral students (85% are
over 40 years old). They are
attracted to doctoral studies by opportunities to take their life learning to
another level and to conduct serious research, not by increased earning
opportunities. The one familiar
aspect of this program is the dissertation requirement which maps onto more
tradition programs. Another approach
is for two or more institutions to collaborate in doctoral programs, across
state lines if necessary, but always insisting on real collaboration, down to
ensuring that students have equivalent parking rights on both campuses.
An example of this is the Virginia Tech and
Wake
Forest
program in biomedical engineering. Speakers
were enthusiastic about these new ideas, although there was some discussion
about how accreditation could be a problem.
Scott Jaschik reported for Inside
Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/08/18/grad)
Princeton
stands alone in
US
News rankings - After being tied for three years with
Harvard
University
for first place in the U.S. News &
World Report rankings of US colleges and universities,
Princeton
University
finally broke away and claimed the spot alone.
Harvard came in second, followed by Yale, with the California Institute
of Technology, MIT, and Stanford tied for fourth.
The
University
of
California
at
Berkeley
ranked first in public universities, with the
University
of
Michigan
at
Ann Arbor
and the
University
of
Virginia
tied for second. The publication of
these rankings brought about expected criticism, writes Eric Hoover in The Chronicle of Higher Education.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006081803n.htm)
Canadian universities bow out of ranking scheme - Eleven
Canadian universities, including the
University
of
Toronto
, sent a letter to Maclean’s to
announce that they would not take part in the magazine’s university rankings.
They explained that their reservations about Maclean’s
methodology had been expressed repeatedly in past years, but had been ignored.
In light of that, the institutions had declined to participate.
The letter, dated August 14, was published on the
University
of
Toronto
website. (See http://www.news.utoronto.ca/bin6/060814-2502.asp)
Intro to study abroad - A new form of study abroad aims at
whetting students’ appetite for international travel by offering two week
programs to incoming first year students. According
to staff at
Michigan
State
University
, the short programs overcome students’ fears about going overseas, thus
easing their decision to spend an entire term abroad.
The first class at
Michigan
State
to participate in these programs will graduate in 2007.
On average 28% of MSU undergraduates study abroad.
For this class, many of whom went on a pre-first year trip to
Quebec
, 70% of the students went abroad during their undergraduate career, writes Elia
Powers in Inside Higher Ed.
(See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/07/28/abroad)
Chaos
in the classroom in China
–
China
’s embrace of market forces has upturned the provision of public
services, including higher education, according to an article in the August 12th
The Economist. Most schools and
colleges are still funded by the government, but they now operate much more like
businesses, allowed to generate extra revenue and to raise student fees. Many
have started locally run schools of their own run as expensive private schools
for students who can afford high fees. Chinese households now provide 18% of the
revenue of schools and colleges, up from 4.4% in 1991. At every level the rich
now have much better access to good education than the less well-off. The
Ministry of Education is now trying to manage the rapid growth of the hybrid
state-private facilities. (See http://www.economist.com)
International rebound - The US Council of Graduate Studies
recently released data that show continued sharp increases in the number of
foreign graduate students who have applied to study in the
US
and in the number of offers of admissions, reports Scott Jaschik in Inside
Higher Ed. Later in the fall
more accurate numbers of foreign students actually enrolled will be available,
but for now, it appears that the foreign graduate school population will grow.
Large increases were seen from
India
and
China
, while numbers fell from the Middle Eastern countries.
Engineering programs saw an increase of 19% in the number of applications
from 2005 to 2006, with offers of admission increasing 26%.
But even with these positive numbers, the total number of foreign
graduate students in 2006 is not likely to reach the levels seen in 2003. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/08/09/intl)
ABET
seeks comments on dual-level accreditation – Accreditation of a program at
both the bachelor’s and master’s level at a given institution is currently
prohibited by the Engineering Accreditation Commission of ABET. A long standing
discussion of whether this prohibition should be removed in order to promote the
master’s degree as the first professional degree has been heightened by a
recommendation in the recent National Academy of Engineering “Engineer of
2020” report, which states that the bachelor’s degree should be considered
as a pre-engineering degree rather than the first professional degree. Opponents
of changing the definition argue that such a change would provide yet another
roadblock in the
US
engineering pipeline. ABET will not be a driver in this discussion, but
will be responsive to its constituencies, the 28 professional societies which
comprise it and the academic institutions that seek its accreditation. ABET has
invited comments on the issue of whether the EAC prohibition on dual level
accreditation should be removed, and asks that they be sent to current ABET
President Richard Seagrave at seagrave@iastste.edu.
Student plagiarism continues to stir controversy at Ohio U – A
lack of attribution in copying material from previous theses has led
Ohio
University
to take action against 39 mechanical engineering students, 36 of them from
abroad. Professors are under fire for not catching missteps of students they
were supervising. According to an article by Robert Tomsho in the August 15th
Wall Street Journal, the mechanical
engineering department’s longtime chairman has stepped down, and a second
professor has been told he will lose his job. A faculty review committee has
concluded that plagiarism in the department has been “rampant and flagrant”
for years, adding that “there can not be any tolerance of individuals who
participate in this serious misconduct”. No evidence has surfaced that the
accused students doctored lab data or fraudulently claimed others’ discoveries
as their own; the alleged plagiarism was found in the “literature review”
sections of theses. The affair raises questions about how well US universities
are teaching the fundamentals of research to foreign students, who have become
an important source of tuition dollars and research talent in engineering.
International students accounted for 43% of master’s degrees and 59% of
doctoral degrees in engineering awarded in the
US
in 2005. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Ohio
U
hearings on plagiarism - The plagiarism scandal that has plagued the
Russ College of Engineering and Technology at
Ohio
University
continues to simmer, reports Paula Wasley in The
Chronicle of Higher Education. In
June, 37 engineering graduates were notified that they had three choices: to
forfeit their degrees; to ask to rewrite or correct part of their theses; or to
challenge the findings of plagiarism in front of a university committee.
Of those 37, 25 responded, mostly asking to revise.
Now the current dean of the
Russ
College
has sent an additional letter saying that the graduates were obligated to
appear before a university panel who will decide whether they should have the
option to rewrite or whether more severe sanctions might be imposed.
Deliberation is on-going on how to treat the faculty who were involved as
advisors to the theses. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/08/2006082405n.htm)
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
Germany
alarmed at lack of engineers
– For centuries,
Germany
has led the world in technological prowess. But, according to an article
in the Christian Science Monitor by
Isabelle de Pommereau, young Germans have dramatically turned away from
engineering, and now the country needs 18,000 engineers. Alarmed that this gap
could endanger
Germany
’s engineering creativity, businesses are trying to stem the tide by
launching a publicity campaign to make engineering sound like fun. A group of 80
businesses, universities and research institutes is sponsoring school projects,
giving awards to youths making special scientific discoveries, awarding
scholarships, helping engineering students find internships, and helping young
researchers commercialize their inventions. (See http://ww.csmonitor.com)
Out of visas, again – Currently the
US
dispenses 65,000 H1-b visas annually to foreign professionals who work in
fields where enough qualified Americans are not available, such as engineering,
biotechnology and computer science. And once the regular cap is exhausted, the
US
makes available an additional 20,000 visas only for foreigners who have
graduated from an American university with a master’s degree or above.
According to an article in the August 2nd Wall Street Journal, in nine of the past 11 years, that cap has been
reached before the end of the fiscal year. And this year, as in the previous
two, it was reached before the fiscal year had even begun. Congress has long
played politics with these caps, giving in to Big Labor and other protectionists
who claim that US businesses hire foreign workers only because they can be paid
less. But the high-tech companies that hire such professionals point out that
they must be paid prevailing wages, and that they are more expensive to hire due
to cumbersome immigration and labor rules. The companies say they need such
foreign workers because too few Americans graduate with advanced degrees in math
and science. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Putting that degree to work - Only 40% of people who have a
bachelor’s degree in engineering, math or computer science went on to earn an
additional university degree, according to a report from the US National Science
Foundation. This compares with 60%
of physical science graduates, and 57% of life science graduates.
This might point to the value of the baccalaureate degree in engineering,
math or computer science. Two thirds
of those with only baccalaureate engineering or science degrees believed that
their current job was related to that degree, indicating the broad variety of
ways in which the degrees are applicable. Information
in this report comes from an NSF survey which usually obtains around 100,000
responses, writes David Epstein in Inside
Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/08/02/nsf)
6 – Journals
Journal of Engineering Education – The July 2006 issue of this
ASEE sponsored journal features seven articles on engineering education
research, plus a guest editorial by 2006-07 ASEE President David Wormley. The
articles include discussions on student attitudes towards cheating, experimental
learning environments, assessment of K-12 teachers’ perceptions on engineers,
and engineering problem solving. In addition, the editor of the Journal,
Dr. Jack R. Lohmann of Georgia Institute of Technology, has prepared and
distributed a comprehensive 2005 Annual Report. The report presents the JEE
strategic plan for 2005-10, which focuses it as an archival record of
scholarly research on engineering education. It also lists seven initiatives,
including special issues, broad community involvement, quality journal
operations, a research practice series, global collaborations, e-technologies in
scholarly discourse, and planning for an international research conference. (See
http://www.asee.org)
IEEE
Transactions on Education
– The August 2006 volume contains 11 papers, including descriptions of
innovative laboratory courses, an active methodology for teaching, project based
learning, enhanced classroom interactivity, and attraction of women to
electrical engineering. (See http://www.ewh.ieee.org/soc/es)
Chemical Engineering Education – The Summer 2006 volume
features 13 articles, including discussions of enhancing the undergraduate
computing experience, the role of industrial training in education, interactive
learning, and senior lab experiments. Also included is an article on chemical
engineering at the
University
of
Sherbrooke
. (See http://cee.che.ufl.edu/index.html)
7 – Meetings
National Academies meeting on competitiveness – The National Academies will convene leaders of industry, government,
research, and education from around the country on September 28th
to share knowledge and discuss ways to advance
US
competitiveness. They will focus on education, research and innovation,
action areas identified in the report “Rising Above the Gathering Storm”.
(See http://www.nationalacademies.org/gatheringstorm)
NAE workshop on offshoring of engineering – The National Academy of Engineering will host a free, public workshop on
engineering offshoring in
Washington
on October 24-25, 2006. The workshop will feature talks by national
engineering leaders from industry and academia, a review of trends in
engineering offshoring in several key industries, and an examination of
implications for the engineering profession, workforce, education, and
management. (See http://www.nae.edu/nae/engecocom.nsf/weblinks/PGIS-6SKKDZ?OpenDocument)
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International
Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com