INTERNATIONAL ENGINEERING EDUCATION DIGEST
August
2004
Copyright © 2004 World Expertise LLC – All rights
reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education
leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S.
Oberst, Ph.D.
CONTENTS
1 - International developments
- WTO
accord reached
-
UK
plans large increase in research
- Renaissance
for Russian science
-
UK
and
US
governments urged to support open-access to research results
- Poll
shows growing Arab rancor at US
- German
universities urged to think carefully about US higher ed model
- Nations
collaborate to take planet’s pulse
- European
worker benefits begin to erode
- Venezuelan
engineering students at center of political activity
- Engineers
focus on capacity building at WFEO meeting
2 -
US
developments
- Large
cuts predicted for US science and technology funding agencies
- Bush
and Kerry on technology issues
- Bush
challenged by scientists
- Engineering
must adapt to maintain leadership
- Harvard
returns controversial UAE gift
- Engineering
grads earn larger starting salaries in 2004
- US
grants extension to grace period for H-1B visas
- Expanded
Space Station research planned
3 - Distance education, technology
- IBM
puts code in public domain
- Instructional
technology’s direct learning benefits lag
- Wi-Fi
expands its reach
- Toy
teaches health in
Afghanistan
-
US
government reshaping airport screening system
- Your
medical history on a microchip
- Space
for technology startups
- Hands-free
cellphones raise safety concerns
- Bar
code adds digit
- GWU
students will get free tunes
- Delete
bathwater, undelete baby
4 - Students, faculty, education
-
China
’s
MIT upgrades itself
- Engineering
schools abrim with talent
-
US
college tuition will rise, but actual cost expected to remain the same
- More
US
college students studying Arabic, report reveals
- First
Lady to serve as honorary chair for women engineers project
- Computer
programs evaluating essays
-
US
board declares grad student unions illegal at private universities
- Fewer
grants force younger scientists to leave
- academia
- Title
IX used to combat gender discrimination in engineering programs
- Missed
opportunities
5 – Employment
- Off-shoring
an economic benefit to US, but detracts from German economy
- IBM
to offshore less
- Combating
offshoring backlash
- Senator
Clinton proposes “bestshoring”
- “Brain
gain” to
India
as former nationals return
- German
engineers face Chinese competition
- PCs
now designed in
Asia
- Technology
gap helps
China
win jobs
- Relocating
for a job
6 – Journals
- Issues
in Science and Technology
- Journal
of Engineering Education
- European
Journal of Engineering Education
7 – Meetings
- Issues
in Science and Technology
- Journal
of Engineering Education
- European
Journal of Engineering Education
1 - International developments
WTO accord reached – The World Trade Organization, reviving
talks that collapsed 10 months ago in
Cancun
, has reached compromise agreements on global trade that could translate into
far reaching changes in farm policies and reduced trade barriers around the
world. According to an article in the August 1st Washington Post by Paul Blustein, representatives of the WTO’s 147
member nations agreed on a framework setting the parameters for completing the
Doha Round of negotiations. The earlier negotiations had stalled when a group of
developing countries, led by
Brazil
and
India
, squared off against the
United States
and the European Union over farm subsidies and other issues. Under the deal
struck in the new negotiations, wealthy nations would cut their subsidies to
farmers, especially payments that tend to lead to gluts in supply on world
markets. Such subsidies have been condemned for depressing global crop prices
and robbing farmers in poor nations of their livelihoods. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
UK
plans large increase in research – Science and technology research in
the
UK
is scheduled to receive a large boost in funding in 2007, according to Tim
Radford, science editor of The Guardian,
in an article on July 13. A growth
rate of funding amounting to 5.8% is part of a new science and innovation
investment framework, with a total of about £5.36 billion distributed to the
national research councils, universities, science teachers, and medical research
facilities. Representatives of the
Royal Society of Chemistry and the
Institute
of
Physics
, among others, point out that such an investment will only begin to achieve the
progress needed to keep
UK
science internationally competitive. (See
http://education.guardian.com.uk)
Renaissance for Russian science – Student enrollments in
engineering, mathematics and science are up in
Russia
, and multinationals are chasing the graduates. According to an article in the
August 9th Business Week, Russia
is graduating more than 200,000 students per year in these fields, despite an
emerging market economy that still suffers from widespread poverty. Although
state funding for scientific research and education plummeted with the collapse
of the
Soviet Union
, and many of
Russia
’s best and brightest left the country for higher paying jobs abroad,
Russia
’s universities and research institutes are slowly adapting to the market
economy by tapping private funding and research contracts. For now, at least,
Russians young and old continue to wow the world with their scientific and
mathematical talent. (See http://www.businessweek.com)
UK
and US governments urged to support open-access to research results –
Both the British and the
US
governments have been urged by legislators to require that results of
government-funded research be made available free of charge in on-line archives.
The British Parliament went a step further and also recommended that
journals develop a model in which authors would pay to publish their articles
and subscription fees would be eliminated. The
bill passed by the US Congress specifically references research funded by the
National Institutes of Health, while the British reference all government
funding agencies. Still at issue are
timeframes for posting of articles, and concerns remain about the effect of such
a system on peer review standards and the impact on the learned societies which
rely on subscription fees for survival, according to Andrea L. Foster and Lila
Guterman, writing for the Chronicle of
Higher Education. Scientific
publishers, which came in for criticism on both sides of the
Atlantic
for their escalating subscription prices, are unhappy.
(See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v50/i47/47a01302.htm)
Poll shows growing Arab rancor at US – Arab views of the
United States
, shaped largely by the Iraq War and a post September 11 climate of fear, have
worsened in the past two years. Surveys conducted in June, and reported on in
the July 23rd Washington Post by
Dafna Linzer, polled Arab men and women in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon,
Morocco and the United Arab Emirates. In
Egypt
, an important
US
ally in the region, nearly 100% of the population now holds an unfavorable
opinion of the country. There is a growing sympathy with al Qaeda coupled with
that resentment of the
US
. Comparing recent surveys, in 2002 the single policy issue that drove Arab
opinion was the Palestinians; now it is
Iraq
and
America
’s treatment of Arabs and Muslims in the
US
and abroad. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
German universities urged to think carefully about US higher ed model –
Thomas John Hochstettler, an American who was until recently the vice president
for academic affairs at the
International
University
Bremen
, wrote a long piece in the Chronicle of
Higher Education, arguing for the transformation of
Germany
higher education, but against wholesale and unthinking adoption of an American
model. He cites the serious decline
in quality in German institutions, demonstrated by the number of students and
faculty who have left
Germany
for the
US
, and the serious drop in government support on a per student basis.
But Hochstettler points out significant differences between the
US
and German education systems which make blind emulation unwise. For example,
US
higher education is expected to play a significant role in the maturation
process of young people, which is not the case in
Germany
. Liberal learning takes place in
secondary schools in
Germany
, and is not left to the undergraduate years as in the
US
. Mainly, however, Hochstettler
faults proposed changes in the German higher education system for lacking
intellectual coherence or a pedagogical rationale.
The author recommends that German universities be encouraged to change
along lines that permit them to retain their distinctive strengths, but not be
permitted to charge tuition across the board, nor to rely too much on alumni
donations to fund on-going programs. (See
http://chronicle.com/weekly/v50/i47/47b01001.htm)
Nations collaborate to take planet’s pulse – The Global
Earth Observation System of Systems, which has nearly 50 countries as
participants, is an ambitious attempt by governments, industry and scientists to
launch a network that will continuously monitor the globe’s land, sea and air.
As described by Juliet Eilperin in the July 26th Washington Post, the system could transform the way farmers plant
their crops, sailors plot their voyages, and doctors work to prevent the spread
of disease. Initially the system would link data from 10,000 manned and
automated weather stations, 1,000 buoys, and 100,000 daily observations by 7,000
ships and 3,000 aircraft. Ultimately it would also collect information from
myriad other sources, such as satellites monitoring ground and air movements,
and feed all the information into computers which would process it. The payoff
will come from such things as better drought prediction, cost savings from ships
which ply more efficient routes, and the easing of humanitarian and health
crises. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
European worker benefits begin to erode – Americans who have
idealized the Western European work style, including shorter workweeks, richer
benefits and longer vacations, may have to reconsider.
A July 27 article in USA Today, authored by Noelle Knox, warns that that pattern may
swiftly disappear, based on recent decisions by four large European companies to
restructure their compacts with workers because of cost-cutting pressures.
Siemens, Thomas Cook, DaimlerChrysler and Robert Bosch all recently moved
to increase work hours while holding wages steady or deferring planned raises.
This has not occurred without bitter disputes with labor unions, but the
May 1 expansion of the European Union to include low-wage countries such as
Poland and the Czech Republic made management threats of near-shoring a distinct
reality: workers by and large voted to accept the new arrangements in order to
retain their jobs. An OECD
(Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) report describes the
complex interplay between wages, productivity and quality of life.
In many EU countries worker productivity is about equal to that of US
workers. While the average European
works about a third less time, that same worker receives about one third less in
salary. So the trade-off is clear:
do you work to live or live to work? The
answer is being shaped by the current 8% average unemployment rate in
Europe
and the threat of accelerated job migration to the east. (See http://www.usatoday.com)
Venezuelan engineering students at center of political activity –
The school of engineering at
Venezuelan
Central
University
has been the center of political activity against the government of President
Hugo Chávez since 2001. And today,
students and administrators there are outspoken in their complaints about the
newly established
Bolivarian
University
. The Chávez government has funneled significant money into it, claiming that
established universities such as VCU are elitist institutions which have
neglected their obligations to educate the poor.
Mike Ceaser, writing for the Chronicle
of Higher Education, described the
Bolivarian
University
’s curriculum, which now offers three majors, in social communication,
environmental management, and management of local development, with an eye
toward adding majors in petroleum engineering, law and medicine.
This is part of President Chávez’s commitment to steering higher
education toward teaching the poor and supporting the development of his
desperately impoverished country. Critics
of this approach, including VCU engineering students, say that the money spent
on creating the new universities would be better spent on improving the weak
system of primary and secondary schools, which often fail to prepare students
ready to undertaken university studies. And
critics also point to evidence which they say proves that the new universities
are centers for indoctrinating students for pro-government political action.
On August 15 President Chávez will be subjected to a recall vote: if he
is ousted from office, his opponents vow to close the
Bolivarian
University
. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v50/i48/48a03501.htm)
Engineers focus on capacity building at WFEO meeting – Engineers
have long contributed to efforts to alleviate poverty in developing countries
through the design and construction of basic infrastructure and other projects
of key importance to economic development. Now, as described in an article by
Jay Landers in the July ASCE News, engineers
and others are increasingly turning to technical capacity building in developing
countries – creating the human, institutional and infrastructure resources
needed to allow them to fashion their own stable economies, governments, and
critical institutions. A June planning conference of the Committee on
Capacity
Building
of the World Federation of Engineering Organizations focused on what the global
engineering profession could and should do in enhancing capacity building in
developing countries. The aim of capacity building effort is the creation of a
solid base of technologically prepared people in developing countries, which
would confer three advantages: attracting investments from multinational
companies, assisting in making the most of foreign aid projects, and providing a
basis for business development by local entrepreneurs. (See http://www.pubs.asce.org)
2 -
US
developments
Large cuts predicted for
US
science and technology funding agencies – The 2005 funding for both
the US National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Aeronautics and Space
Administration (NASA) will be cut, by 2% and 1.5% respectively, according to an
article in the Chronicle of Higher
Education by Kelly Field. The overall
US
budget deficit was blamed for the cuts. In
2002 Congress authorized $7.4 billion for NSF, which included $5.5 billion for
research. This recent decision would
leave only $4.2 billion for research. The
Math and Science Partnership would be hard hit, losing $56.7 million from its
2004 budget. NASA’s new budget,
while reduced, contained funding for Administration-backed projects for
space-shuttle operations and a Mars program.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/07/2004072101n.htm)
Bush and Kerry on technology issues – Both President George
Bush and Democratic challenger John Kerry like to portray themselves as highly
attentive to America’s high tech future, according to an article by Barton
Reppert in IEEE-USA Today’s Engineer. Both
candidates view technology as key to bolstering the global competitiveness of
the
US
economy, as well as contributing substantially to national defense, the war
against terrorism, homeland security, energy development, environmental
protection, health care, transportation and other sectors. But Bush and Kerry
differ significantly on specific government programs and initiatives needed to
help reap maximum benefits from advanced technology. In the R&D funding
area, Bush is proposing steep cuts in most nondefense agencies while Kerry would
increase support for physical sciences and engineering research for agencies
such as NSF and NIST. Both candidates support nanotechnology development, and
both support making the research and experimentation tax credit permanent. Bush
would zero out funding for the Advanced Technology program, while Kerry would
continue its funding. With regard to offshoring, Bush says that concerns are
exaggerated, while Kerry opposes large-scale outsourcing of work abroad. Both
candidates support math and science partnership programs between schools and the
private sector to lead to a more technically prepared workforce. (See http://www.todaysengineer.org)
Bush challenged by scientists – The Bush administration is
being criticized for its use of information on divisive scientific issues,
according to an article by Antonio Regalado in the July 15th Wall
Street Journal. Some leaders in the scientific community are mounting a
political campaign to unseat President Bush this fall, accusing the
administration of twisting scientific facts to fit its policies on issues such
as global warming, sex education, and stem-cell research. The Bush campaign has
a different perspective, however, and will be talking about the Bush
administration’s record of support for science and research – including
hydrogen fuels, nanotechnology, and medical research. The increased political
activity among scientists comes against a backdrop of worry that the
US
is losing its technological pre-eminence to foreign competitors. (See http://www.wsj.com)
In a similar vein, a note by Andrew Lawler and Jocelyn Kaiser in the July 16th
Science reports charges that the Bush
administration has rejected candidates for scientific advisory panels whose
views were not sympathetic with the White House’s. (See http://www.sciencemeg.org)
Engineering must adapt to maintain leadership – A report
published this spring by the US National Academy of Engineering warns that the
engineering profession must adopt a new vision for its future to ensure that
engineers are broadly educated, assume leadership positions in the public and
private sectors, and represent all segments of society. The report, “The
Engineer of 2020: Visions of Engineering in the New Century”, is described in
an article in the July ASCE News. The
report considers which skills engineers of the future are likely to need by
considering several scenarios – for instance, one where new breakthroughs in
biotechnology, natural disasters triggered by climate change, and global
conflicts arising from an imbalance in resources could affect the world of 2020
in dramatic ways. By then, engineers will have to be prepared to accommodate new
social, economic, legal and political factors when planning projects. The report
suggests that the engineering profession must 1) agree on an exciting vision for
the future, 2) transform engineering education to help achieve that vision, 3)
build a clear image of the new roles for engineers as broad-based technology
leaders, 4) accommodate innovative developments from nonengineering fields, and
5) focus the energies of the various disciplines of engineering toward common
goals. Copies of the report may be obtained at http://books.nap.edu/catalog/10999.html.
(See http://www.pubs.asce.org)
Harvard returns controversial UAE gift – Sheikh Zayed bin
Sultan al-Nahyan, President of the
United Arab Emirates
, asked
Harvard
University
to returns his gift of $2.5 million, and the university readily complied. The
gift was originally given in 2000 to the
Divinity
School
to fund a professorship in Islamic religious studies, but had never been spent
because of the President’s support for a center in the UAE which presented
speakers with anti-Semitic and anti-American ideas. That
center was closed in 2003 by order of the President. Rachel Fish, a former
student at the
Divinity
School
who led the protest against acceptance of the gift, has urged other schools who
have received money from the UAE to reconsider, according to Erin Strout writing
for the Chronicle of Higher Education.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/07/2004072903n.htm)
Engineering grads earn larger starting salaries in 2004 – The
US-based National Association of Colleges and Employers released the results of
a survey which indicated that hiring of the class of 2004 was up by 11.2%, and
that starting salaries for college graduates were up as well.
An article published on cnn.money on July 27 indicates that while
engineering graduates are earning the most money, business majors are doing
well, too, and even liberal arts graduates are earning 2.6% more than their
counterparts of the previous year. The
surprising news was that nurses, who are so much in demand, are being hired at
1.9% less on the average than last year’s graduates, according to reporter
Deshundra Jefferson. (See http://cnnmoney.com)
US
grants extension to grace period for H-1B visas – On October 1, a new
quota of H-1B visas will be made available by the
US
government. These visas cover people with specialized skills that are in high
demand by businesses. (Academic employees are not included in this allocation.)
The current year’s H-1B quota was reached in February, thus leaving some
18,000 foreign students and scholars already in the
US
who want to switch their status to H-1B with the prospect of having to return
home then turning around and coming back within a few months.
To solve the problem, the
US
government recently extended the usual 30 – 60 day “grace period,” thus
permitting a cohort of people to remain in the States until their new visas can
be granted. This is the first time
such an extension has been made, according to Kelly Field writing for the Chronicle
of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/07/2004072803n.htm)
Expanded Space Station research planned – NASA has finished
its plans for completing the International Space Station by the end of the
decade, according to an article by Warren Leary in the July 18th New
York Times. Among other revisions, the plans call for expanding the size and
use of the
United States
’ Destiny science module aboard the station to do as much research as
possible, with as many as six astronauts working there, up from the current
limit of three. The plans are being reviewed with other governments involved in
the Station –
Russia
,
Japan
and the European Union. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
3 - Distance education, technology
IBM puts code in public domain – In a competitive move, IBM is
donating more than half a million lines of its software code to an open source
software group. According to an article by Steve Lohr in the August 3rd
New York Times, IBM is making the code
contribution – valued at $85-million – to try to make it easier and more
appealing for software developers to write applications in Java. Since IBM is
one of the leading supporters of the Java technology, originally developed by
Sun Microsystems, it hopes to develop more potential users for its platform that
runs and manages such applications. The IBM move is further evidence of its
support for open source software; its biggest commitment to date has been to
Linux, an alternative to the operating systems of its two leading rivals –
Microsoft and Sun Microsystems. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Instructional technology’s direct learning benefits lag –
The US-based
Educause
Center
for Applied Research this year conducted a survey of first and fourth year
students at various types of colleges asking them about the benefits of
technology in the learning process. While
76.1% of the respondents praised their experience with course management
systems, 48.5% said that the biggest advantage of instructional technology was
convenience, leading to the conclusion that IT has not yet revolutionized the
teaching-learning process as much as had been predicted.
Students were mostly centrist in their preference for IT: 41.2% said they
preferred “moderate use of IT,” while 31% wanted “extensive IT,” and
22.7% wanted “limited IT.” Richard
N. Katz, a vice president at Educause, noted what he believes is a preference
among young people for technology in their personal lives, but an expectation
that education will be about more than technology.
Students were also critical of their instructors’ command of
technology, noting in particular the bad use of Power Point slides (reading the
slides rather than lecturing from them), according to Jeffrey R. Young, writing
for the Chronicle of Higher Education.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/08/2004080403n.htm)
Wi-Fi expands its reach – Wi-Fi hot spots available to the
public will more than double at American airports this year, to 379 from 178 in
2003. The overall number of public hot spots in the
US
already surpasses 10,000, according to an article by Jane Levere in the July 27th
New York Times, and is likely to reach
65,000 by 2008. Hot spots in hotels, cafes and restaurants are popular, but most
extensive use is at airports where the concentration of laptops is high. Cost is
an issue for users, as is security of e-mail transmissions. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Toy teaches health in
Afghanistan
– A high tech toy, “LeapPad”, is doing double duty as a learning
device on health issues for rural Afghan women. According to an article by
Queena Sook Kim in the August 8th Wall
Street Journal, the educational toy designed to teach reading to children in
the US will be used to educate illiterate women in Afghanistan about the
benefits of immunization, the dangers of sexually transmitted diseases, and the
perils of some homespun remedies such as rubbing dirt in wounds to heal them. In
its normal child application, the unit recites out loud to kids when they touch
the words on a page; in the Afghan version the users will touch colorful
pictures showing village scenes and characters to trigger recorded speech in
their language. The project is being driven by US Health and Human Services
Secretary Tommy Thompson; HHS has purchased 20,000 LeapPads in a $1.25-million
deal. (See http://www.wsj.com)
US government reshaping airport screening system – The
government is backing away from a plan to use commercial databases in its
computerized system for determining which airline passengers might pose a
security risk, according to an article in the July 16th New
York Times by Matthew Wald. But it is pressing ahead with a new computer
based system that will rely on government databases. The goal is a better
screening tool that will select about 4% of all passengers for more intense
scrutiny, compared with the 14% identified by the current system – which
selects passengers on the basis of criteria such as last minute or cash ticket
purchases and one way tickets. The government already has a small “no-fly”
list, and a larger list of people who are to be put through secondary screening
if they seek to fly. Those two lists are thought to have fewer than 10,000
names, but the new computer system would integrate a list of names that is
dramatically larger. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Your medical history on a microchip – The current archaic
system of paper medical records makes it unlikely that your medical records
would be available in a timely way after a car accident or a heart attack.
According to an article in the July 27th Wall Street Journal by Laura Landro, the federal government plans to
create a vast new information system for patients and to provide incentives for
physicians to adopt electronic records. Unresolved are questions about who would
pay for the new technology and how much information will be shared. In the
meantime, a number of new tools and services are making it possible for
consumers to create and share their own medical records – from emergency
wallet cards printed off the web to portable gadgets that store a family’s
entire medical history on a microchip. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Space for technology startups – A new nonprofit complex is
providing “incubator” space for emerging technology companies in
North Brunswick
,
New Jersey
. According to an article in the August 4th New York Times, the Commercialization Center for Innovative
Technologies offers space in a modern facility at attractive rents. The center
is on the 50-acre campus of the Technology Center of New Jersey, a state
supported collection of research and production facilities with 380,000 square
feet in six buildings. The incubator can provide space to startups that need
smaller quarters than commercial developers are willing to provide, and it is
willing to build labs for small users. As the economic recovery gathers
strength, the competition for start-up companies is expected to intensify. In
another development, the state of
New Jersey
and
Rutgers
University
have started to erect a 100,000 square foot building in a technology center on
the
Camden
waterfront. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Hands-free cellphones raise safety concerns – Several states
are requiring drivers to use hands-free devices when talking on cellphones in
their cars. After initially fighting such laws, the nation’s cellphone
carriers are joining with car makers to promote the voluntary use of headsets to
address concerns about the safety of talking on the phone while driving. But,
according to an article by Jesse Drucker and Karen Lundegaard in the July 19th
Wall Street Journal, new research at
the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and others suggests that
hands-free devices may actually add to the overall risk. A sizeable body of
research concludes that headsets and speaker phones do not improve safety
because it is the mental distraction of talking on the phone not holding it,
that causes the danger while driving. And recent research suggests that
hands-free devices could actually increase the risk by encouraging people to
spend more time on their cellphones and drive faster while doing so. American
drivers currently spend a billion minutes a day talking on their cellular
phones, an estimated 40% of all cellular minutes. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Bar code adds digit – The humble bar code, ignored by shoppers
and indecipherable to humans, is joining the forced march to globalization.
According to an article in the July 12th Wall
Street Journal by Steve Lohr, Europe has won a battle to set a global bar
code standard that has 13 digits, one more than the 12 used by the 30-year old
US system. Barcodes allow faster, more efficient checkout processes and
instantaneous inventory and sales data. The Europeans pushed for the longer
format in order to handle country of origin information. For American retailers,
conforming to the new 13-digit standard requires retooling software programs.
There is some question about how bar code technology will fare now that new
generation radio frequency identification tags , which can transmit far more
data, are arriving on the scene. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
GWU students will get free tunes –
George
Washington
University
this fall will become one of a small number of colleges to attempt a novel
solution to the problem of students illegally downloading music from the
Internet. According to an article by Amy Argetsinger in the July 17th
Washington Post, the university is
going to give them music legally, for free. Through a deal with Napster, some
7100 students living in campus residence halls will be able to access hundreds
of thousands of songs over the university’s high-speed network. The Napster
solution was first tried early this year in pilot programs at
Penn
State
and the
University
of
Rochester
, and Napster is currently negotiating agreements with five other colleges. (See
http://www.washingtonpost.com)
Delete bathwater, undelete baby – In a lengthy review article
in the August 5th New York
Times, Katie Hafner reviews the current status of spam versus filters. The
best current filters, based on Bayesian scoring, can trap 97% of spam e-mails.
But even the best filters often trap legitimate messages, requiring users to
sort through lists to retrieve the few good ones. Filters applied at the
organizational level rather than on individual pc’s do not allow such reviews,
causing occasional communication problems. And spammers are quick to find their
way around new filters, sometimes taking as little as five minutes to adapt to a
change. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
4 - Students, faculty, education
China
’s
MIT upgrades itself –
Tsinghua
University
, long known as
China
’s MIT, is getting a makeover as the Chinese government seeks to create a
university to match its global ambitions and produce graduates to compete in its
market economy. Writing in the July 28th Wall Street Journal, Philip Tinari reports that Tsinghua is
transforming itself from a socialist-style polytechnic into a first-rate world
university. Tsinghua resembles an American university in many ways: aggressive
poaching of star faculty from around the world, fund raising, infrastructure
building, and curricular reform. While students still take courses in Marxist
philosophy and Mao Zedong thought, professors there note that Tsinghua’s
relatively open atmosphere allows them to research and teach on sensitive social
problems such as AIDS, population control, and unemployment.
China
’s top universities – Tsinghua,
Peking
University
and
Fudan
University
– are best able to transform themselves, and although other universities may
lack the resources of these top schools the changes there serve as a political
green light for others seeking to emulate them. While Tsinghua was founded in
1911 to prepare Chinese students to attend US colleges, it now is strong enough
to attract graduate students who even a decade ago would have looked abroad.
(See http://www.wsj.com)
Engineering schools abrim with talent – Although the
coursework is hard and the job market iffy, more
US
students are enrolled in engineering graduate school than ever before. Writing
in the July 16th EETimes, Colin
Johnson cites a new report from NSF that puts the number of such students at
almost half a million in 2002, surpassing the previous peak achieved in 1993 by
five percent. Demographics partially explain the uptick, following trends in the
total
US
college-age population. But in fields like electrical and biomedical
engineering, which jumped 10.7% and 20.3% respectively, the rises reflect the
student’s practical eye for interesting employment opportunities. Partially
due to 9/11 fallout, first time enrollments of foreign students in science and
engineering were reported to be down 7.9%; but first time graduate enrollment
increased by almost 14% for US citizens and permanent residents. (See http://www.eetimes.com)
A similar article in the July 9th Science
attributes the increase in graduate students in science and engineering to
the weak economy and higher stipends. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
US
college tuition will rise, but actual cost expected to remain the same –
The bad news is that on the average, college tuition in both public and private
colleges and universities in the
US
will rise this coming year. The
good news, according to a July 9 article posted on CNN.com, is that because of
increased financial aid, the actual price paid for tuition will remain about the
same. Increases are attributed to
higher costs over which the institutions have no control, such as employee
health insurance and periodical subscriptions, and to stagnant endowment income.
(See http://www.cnn.com)
More
US
college students studying Arabic, report reveals – Richard Brecht,
executive director of the Center for the Advanced Study of Language, threw cold
water on any optimism that might arise from a report that college enrollment in
Arab language courses doubled in the
US
between 1998 and 2002, from roughly 5,000 to 10,000.
He pointed out that assuming only one in ten of those students will
achieve working proficiency, that gives the country only 1,000 more people to
fill an overwhelming demand for such talent.
Brecht recommends that the Federal government fund programs starting at
the elementary and secondary levels, according to an article appearing on July
11 on boston.com. (See http://www.boston.com)
First Lady to serve as honorary chair for women engineers project -- Laura
Bush will serve as honorary chair of the advisory committee of the Extraordinary
Women Engineers Project, according to an article in the July ASCE
News. In a White House announcement, she applauded the project for inspiring
young women to be engineers and for promoting diversity within the engineering
profession. The EWSP was established in March by the American Society of Civil
Engineers, the American Association of Engineering Societies, and the Society of
Women Engineers – with the support of the National Academy of Engineering. It
is also supported by a coalition of other engineering organizations. The project
was developed to address several issues: fewer than 10% of the nation’s
engineers are women; girls do not lag behind boys in grades or test scores in
math or science but relatively few select engineering as a career; and by the
eighth grade twice as many boys as girls are interested in science or
engineering careers. The EWEP steering committee is chaired by Patricia
Galloway, currently president of ASCE. (See http://www.pubs.asce.org)
Computer programs evaluating essays – More than 2-million
essays have been scored by e-rater since it was adopted for the GMAT in 1999,
and the technology is now being considered for the Graduate Record Exam and
TOEFL. According to an article by Jay Mathews in the August 1st Washington
Post, testing experts predict that machines will eventually help grade the
SAT and ACT, which will add writing sections to their 2005 college admissions
tests, because computer scoring costs less and provides results faster than
human scoring. In the GMAT, which previously had a team of readers score essays,
just one human grader’s judgment is compared with the computer’s conclusion.
Critics are not convinced that computers cannot replace human readers in
evaluating style and cogency. Only on personal essays for college applications
do educators seem to be taking a hard line against computer scoring. (See http://www.washingtonpost.com)
US
board declares grad student unions illegal at private universities –
The US National Labor Relations Board recently overturned its year 2000 ruling
by declaring that graduate students at private universities do not have the
right to create labor unions, thus reversing several years of intense activity
by unions on campuses. In 2000 the
five member board, with a Democrat majority, had supported the right of
New York
University
graduate students to organize. In
2004, the board, with a Republican majority, took on a case from
Brown
University
and came down on the side of university administrations, which have long
contended that graduate students are not employees.
Union representatives, reacting to the ruling, were outraged and vowed to
continue their struggle to organize the students, writes Scott Smallwood for the
Chronicle of Higher Education.
(See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/07/2004071601n.htm)
Fewer grants force younger scientists to leave academia – As
the competition for government grants gets tighter, younger scientists are
increasingly quitting academia, according to an article by Bernard Wysocki in
the July 27th Wall Street
Journal. In addition to being cheap labor for universities, fresh Ph.D.s are
important for another reason: often they have the most original ideas. The trend
of departures is particularly noticeable in biomedical research, where grant
funding has gotten tight due to stagnant NIH budgets. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Title IX used to combat gender discrimination in engineering programs –
Two members of the US Senate, Barbara Boxer and Ron Wyden, asked the Government
Accountability Office to prepare a report on how successfully the government was
using Title IX to prevent discrimination against women in science, engineering
and mathematics. The report points to the National Science Foundation, the
Energy Department and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration as not
doing enough to enforce compliance with Title IX by colleges and universities
which receive their funds. While
Title IX is known as an effective tool for increasing women’s participation in
sports, it is less known to have academic applications as well.
The report recommends that the three agencies act more aggressively to
insure compliance by conducting site visits and otherwise monitoring the actions
of grant recipients. Piper Fogg
wrote this article for the Chronicle of
Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2004/07/2004072902n.htm)
Missed opportunities – The lead article in the July/August Change
discusses affordability as a challenge to access to higher education. Author
Brian Fitzgerald notes that nearly 40 years ago federal and state governments
created a system of higher education that would enable the Baby Boom generation
to enroll in college in historic numbers. Student aid programs – especially
grants – have provided unprecedented opportunity for low- and moderate-income
families and ensured that any qualified student would have access to higher
education regardless of family economic circumstances. As a result, millions of
students who would not otherwise have been able to enroll and attain degrees
have done so – which in turn has propelled unparalleled economic growth in the
late 20th century. But the writer says that the situation has
changed: rising financial barriers now limit college opportunity for low- and
moderate-income families. He examines the policy drift that has produced these
barriers, the implications of these trends for our economy and society, and what
might be done to address these problems. (See http://www.heldref.org)
5 – Employment
Off-shoring an economic benefit to US, but detracts from German economy –
A July 15 article in The Economist
explains why off-shoring seems to be beneficial overall to the
US
economy, while creating a loss to the German economy.
According to the McKinsey Global Institute, for every dollar sent
offshore, $1.13 of new wealth is generated in the
US
economy. In
Germany
, for every euro off-shored, the German economy suffers a 20 cent loss.
Reasons for this include the fact that the US generally off-shores to
India, where the labor costs are lower, while Germany still off-shores a
significant number of jobs to Eastern Europe, where wages are higher than in
India. Another factor is that the
salaries paid to workers in
India
are frequently spent on US-made goods, which are more attractive than German
goods. But the biggest factor is
that German workers who lose their jobs to off-shoring find it more difficult to
become re-employed, due to more restrictive labor laws which are disincentives
to employers’ hiring. 70% of
US
workers fired as a result of off-shoring are working again within six months,
while only 40% of Germans find work again in the same timeframe.
(See http://www.economist.com)
IBM to offshore less – Adopting new policies to take some of
the sting out of job offshoring, IBM expects to lay off fewer
US
employees this year because of work being transferred overseas. According to
William Bulkeley, writing in the July 29th
Wall Street Journal, the company became a lightening rod for critics
of offshoring earlier this year after internal documents revealed plans to send
nearly 5000 jobs to India, Brazil and other developing countries in order to
save on labor costs. Now the company has adopted new internal-transfer policies
aimed at filling more open positions at IBM with employees who would otherwise
get a pink slip due to offshoring. With the economy starting to recover, IBM is
increasing employment for the first time in three years. The company says it
expects the new policy will save money overall by reducing the costs associated
with hiring and firing. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Combating offshoring backlash – Late last year, after a deluge
of customer complaints about unintelligible English, lengthy telephone waits,
and poor service, Dell Inc. rerouted technical support for its
US
corporate clients from a call center in
India
to facilities in
Texas
,
Idaho
and
Tennessee
. According to an article by Julia King in the July 12th Computerworld, several other companies have made similar decisions
as backlash from employees and customers has triggered productivity and revenue
losses, as well as public relations
and political donnybrooks. But economics continue to drive many companies to
continue offshoring. So companies considering or doing offshoring are becoming
more sophisticated in strategy and communications regarding offshore plans.
Among other messages to customers is the unavoidable fact that consumers will
pay more for products and services from companies that do not outsource
overseas. (See http://www.computerworld.com)
Senator Clinton proposes “bestshoring” – Writing in the
July 26th Wall Street Journal, New
York Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton analyzes the economics of offshoring. She
points out that companies that offshore have many costs that offset wage
savings, such as planning, offshore transition, vendor selection, technology,
communications, offshore management, travel and security. She argues for a
strategy that focuses on critical areas – innovation, new job creation,
workforce development, connectivity expansion, and collaboration between
industry, academia, labor and government. Her bottom line is that with a smarter
national strategy and better information on real costs, many companies would
rethink offshore outsourcing. (See http://www.wsj.com)
“Brain gain” to India as former nationals return – On July
24 The New
York Times published a report by Amy Waldman describing the recent
phenomenon of “reverse brain drain,” or “brain gain,” the result of
significant numbers of highly educated and affluent Indians returning home after
successful careers in the US. In
areas such as
Bangalore
, off-shoring success has made it possible for Indians to lead lives similar to
those they knew in the
US
, with large homes, strong private schools, and consumer goods carrying familiar
labels. Some of the returnees begin
their own companies, and some are having success as volunteers working for the
improvement of life in their country of birth.
One notable case is Shikanth Nadhamuni, who was involved in the design of
the Intel Pentium chip, and is now working to improve government processes for
greater efficiency and accountability. On
the home front, returnees have the challenge of deciding how and to what extent
they will reintegrate themselves and their children into a country which is now
more foreign to them than the
US
they left. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
German engineers face Chinese competition – Siemens has begun
to turn east for engineering know-how, having relied primarily on the ingenuity
of its German engineers for more than 150 years. According to an article by
Matthew Karnitschnig in the July 15th Wall Street Journal, the management of the company – no longer
dominated by engineering – is moving engineering jobs to China where they can
produce high tech at low cost. The company has announced plans to hire 1000
Chinese engineers this year and to invest about $1.23-billion in
China
.
Germany
’s preeminence in engineering is being threatened by high labor costs, a
lagging education system, and sluggish innovation. Chancellor Gerhard Schroder,
in trying to shore up the engineering sector, has declared 2004 the “year of
innovation”. But so far that effort is sputtering, as
Germany
’s exploding deficit and stagnant growth forced Mr. Schroder to trim federal
support this year for research and development.
China
, in the meantime, is moving in the opposite direction – aggressively
improving technical education. (See http://www.wsj.com)
PCs now designed in
Asia
– For several years, PCs sold throughout the world have been
manufactured in
Asia
. Now, according to an article by Lee Gromes in the July 19th Wall
Street Journal, the growing sophistication of Asian manufacturers makes it
increasingly likely that they also have been designed there. “Original design
manufacturers” in
Asia
are also branching out to other fields, like cameras and cellphones. Western
brand name companies marketing such products claim that they only put their logo
on products that they help to design. It remains to be seen whether – or when
– such ODMs will enter the technology market with their own brands. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Technology gap helps
China
win jobs –
China
is challenging
India
as a low-cost home for software development, according to an article in the
July 18th
New York
Times by William Holstein.
India
has had the leadership for software development and outsourcing due to an early
jump start, but over the past couple of years the Chinese have become very
competitive by bringing their skill sets up. Both countries have an
inexhaustible source of human capital for the foreseeable future.
India
currently has an advantage in setting up complete services, a concept not yet
typical in
China
. But
China
has adopted a strategy of jumping ahead to new technologies, not constrained by
embedded practices. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Relocating for a job – More workers are facing a knotty
work-family challenge – being forced to move to keep their job. Writing in the
Wall Street Journal, Sue Shellenbarger
notes that corporate transfers are running 10 to 15% ahead of last year, putting
pressure on employees to deal with the hardships that transfers can cause kids
and marriages. An increasing number of couples are asking for, and getting,
counseling about such moves and job-finding help for the trailing spouse. Even
with offered perks such as more househunting trips, many employees find high
family resistance to moving and turn down transfers. (See http://www.wsj.com)
6 – Journals
Issues in Science and Technology – The Summer 2004 issue
includes major articles on threats to the
US
forest industry by global market changes, a patent system for the 21st
century, electrical blackouts, transformation of
US
military forces, attrition in the scientific workforce, and strengthening of
research in Asian countries. (See http://www.issues.org)
Journal of Engineering Education -
The July 2004 issue of this ASEE journal contains ten major
articles. The lead article is by Frank Barnes, based on his 2004 Bernard M.
Gordon Prize lecture: “Some Frontiers for Engineering Education”. Other
articles cover group size and duration in capstone design projects, student
learning in simulated experiments, active learning, assessment, library services
in design firms, and improving a school’s ranking. (See http://www.asee.org)
European Journal of Engineering Education – The September 2004
issue contains six papers on the theme of teaching value concepts to engineering
students, and six additional regular papers on topics including teaching on
renewable energy, creativity in teaching, developing decision-making skills in
teams, and the role of the supervisor in student projects. (See http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals)
7 – Meetings
NAE Engineer of 2020 Phase II workshop – On July 20-24, the US
National Academy of Engineering convened a group of top engineering educators
and industry representatives for an “Engineer of 2020 National Education
Summit”. The meeting was part of the second phase of the Engineer of 2020
Project – this phase aimed at how to shape future engineering education to
meet the needs of the engineering profession in 2020. Chaired by Georgia Tech
President Wayne Clough, the two-day session began with several keynote speeches,
a panel discussion on innovation and reform in engineering education, and a
review of the Engineer of 2020 Phase I Report. The group then divided into
breakout teams to pursue several key topics: an undergraduate engineering
education model to meet the aspirations in the Engineer of 2020 Report; proposed
new pedagogical approaches; the relation of engineering education to liberal
arts, social sciences and public policy; and needed revisions for department and
faculty roles. Each team was asked to present an action plan to make the most
important changes needed. (See http://www.nae.edu)
UPADI Education Congress – The biannual convention of the Pan
American Union of Engineering Associations, to be held in Mexico City in
September, includes a major two-day Engineering Education Congress on September
23rd and 24th. Major sessions include: New Models from the
US NSF Coalitions Program; The Panorama of Engineering Education in
Latin America
; and
Capacity
Building
in Developing Countries for Economic Development. Information on UPADI2004,
including registration and hotel forms, is available at http://www.upadi.org.mx,
in Spanish and in English. The overall convention extends for a week, and
includes thirteen specialty congresses.
Colloquium on International Engineering Education – The
seventh annual colloquium will focus on Engineering Education in the Age of
Globalization. Hosted by the
University
of
Rhode Island
on September 30 – October 3, the meeting will be held in
Providence
RI
. For information, see http://www.uri.edu/iep.
To unsubscribe from this
newsletter service, please respond to digest@worldexpertise.com
with the word UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line. Send address changes to the same
e-mail address.
To contribute information to
this electronic newsletter, please send it by e-mail to russel_jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest provides summaries
of published articles, both printed and electronic. World Expertise does not
endorse or corroborate the information in these articles. Some publication web
sites may require user registration before access is granted to articles via the
links provided above.
Back issues of this
International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com