April 2006
Copyright © 2006 World Expertise LLC – All rights reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., and Bethany S. Oberst, Ph.D.
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
6 – Journals
7 – Meetings
_______________________________________________________________________
More harm than good – Pledging money to
Knowledge innovation in China – At China’s 2006 National Science and Technology Conference, President Hu Jintao pledged to make 21st century China “an innovation-oriented society,” according to an article in the April 7th Science by Richard Suttmeier, Cong Cao and Denis Fred Simon. To that end the conference unveiled a 15 year Medium to Long Term Science and Technology Development Plan (2006-2020) setting national research priorities and providing substantial resources for meeting them. Gross expenditures on R&D are expected to rise from the current 1.3% of gross domestic product to 2.5% by the end of the plan period. The plan emphasizes “indigenous innovation” and “leapfrogging” in research. Science and technology are expected to support and lead future economic growth for the country. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
US colleges more affordable, less accessible, than
UK government streamlines research funding – The 2006-07 budget of the United Kingdom shuffles some responsibilities for science and technology, but has little new cash, according to an article in the March 31st Science by Eliot Marshall. The government plans to spend more on secondary school education, restructuring councils that oversee the biomedical and physical sciences, and create a simplified method of allocating research overheads to universities. University leaders seem pleased with the plan to overhaul the Research Assessment Exercise, a process that ranks departments by merit every 4 or 5 years and allocates funding for overhead costs of research. Critics say that the RAE has concentrated wealth in elite universities and destroyed some good departments elsewhere. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Italian research reform moves ahead –
Australia’s proposed ranking stirs debate – Australia is
considering a radical overhaul of the way it allocates funds to universities and
research institutions, according to an article in the April 14th Science
by Elizabeth Finkel. A proposed Research Quality Framework, similar to the
system currently used in the
Lessons from history – The 200th
anniversary of the birth of one of Britain’s greatest engineers, Isambard
Kingdom Brunel, is the occasion for the publication of a study funded by the
Economic and Social Research
Council, led by London School of Economics and Political Science’s Professor
Nicholas Crafts. After comparing the
technological revolutions brought about by the development of the steam engine
in the 19th century with the invention of information and
communication technologies in the 20th century, Crafts noted that
there were similarities which should have alerted investors to the likelihood of
the dot.com bust. While steam power
was patented by James Watt in 1769, it wasn’t until the mid-19th
century that the full impact of that innovation was felt, and even then there
was a major economic slump that spanned that era.
So investors who thought that the economic benefits of ICT would be
immediate and derive principally from the manufacture of related goods should
have taken a lesson from history. The benefits in terms of productivity unfold
more slowly, in more complex ways, than followers of Wall Street can imagine,
according to this report in EurekAlert dated
Strengthening the Arab intellectual and scientific
community – The Qatar Foundation in
Higher education bill aims to stir up academia – Congressional Republicans, who have lambasted traditional colleges for years as overpriced liberal bastions without making much headway against the nearly unassailable higher education establishment, are finally gaining ground. Legislation introduced in the House of Representatives tries to curb skyrocketing college tuition costs and protect the expression of conservative ideas on campus, according to an article in the March 30th Wall Street Journal by John Hechinger. The bill would also drop longstanding antifraud safeguards holding back for-profit colleges that are taking market share from traditional schools, which are public or private nonprofit organizations. The bill reauthorizes the Higher Education Act, which governs billions of dollars of federal funding for colleges and universities of all types. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Panel considers revamping college aid and accrediting – Months after suggesting that standardized testing should be brought to colleges and universities, a higher education commission established by the Bush administration is examining proposals to change sharply how US colleges are accredited and how federal student aid is administered. According to an article in the April 12th New York Times by Sam Dillon, one proposal calls for scrapping the current system of accreditation, done largely by private regional bodies, in favor of a National Accreditation Foundation that would be created by the President and Congress. Another proposal calls for streamlining the federal student aid system, replacing some 17 current grant, loan and tax-credit programs with just one, or perhaps three, federal aid programs. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Foreign grad students show renewed interest – Reversing a
2-year decline, foreign grad students flooded
Study tracks degree completion patterns in STEM fields – The American Council on Education announced on April 3 that it had published a report entitled “Increasing the Success of Minority Students in Science and Technology,” containing data from a longitudinal study conducted by the US Department of Education. The study tracked 12,000 undergraduates who entered college in 1995. Data show that 18.6% of African-American and 22.7% of Hispanic students came to college interested in majoring in science, technology, engineering or math (STEM), as compared with 18% of white students and 26.4% of Asian students. But by 2001 – four years later – 62.5% of African American and Hispanic students majoring in STEM subjects earned their bachelor/s degree, while 94.8% of Asian Americans and 86.7% of whites did so. The study indicates also that students who persist to completion of their degrees within four years were those who came from the most rigorous secondary schools, were not yet 19 years old when they began their studies, had one parent with a bachelor’s degree, had higher family income, and worked less while enrolled. (See http://www.acenet.edu)
Identifying the pork – The US Senate passed legislation which would require all Senate bills to list all “earmarks,” specially funded projects that are added in favor of constituencies such as colleges and universities. These earmarks are non-competitive appropriations that critics call frivolous. This sort of funding has increased dramatically in the past decade. Another piece of the legislation would make it easier for Senators to remove earmarks that are inserted in the process of reconciliation of House and Senate versions of similar bills. Few people think that this new legislation will lead to a significant decrease in the use of earmarks, writes Jeffrey Brainard in The Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2006/03/2006033002n.htm)
Preview of accreditation changes? – The US Department of Education’s higher education commission caused considerable concern recently when it took aim at the system of regional accreditation. A close reading of the various documents which allude to the deficiencies of the current system and describe possible changes indicates a dissatisfaction with the institutional focus of regional accreditation, with some members of the commission believing that it should be more consumer-focused. The accreditation process is accused of being too secretive, lacking sufficiently high standards, and being too respectful of regional concerns at a time when student mobility is increasing. A suggested cure of perceived weaknesses in the current system is the creation of a National Accreditation Foundation, a public-private partnership run by university officials, business leaders and policy makers. This foundation would be charged with setting national quality standards, designing new accreditation procedures, disseminating information to the public, and deciding on institutions’ eligibility for financial aid, reports Doug Lederman in Inside Higher Ed.. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/03/31/accrredit)
Carnegie Classification includes voluntary grouping – The Carnegie Classification of US colleges and universities has undergone a substantial change in the last six months and has now been released in its entirety. One important innovation is the creation of a new, voluntary classification of institutions with strong “community engagement.” Institutions will be required to submit evidence that they are in fact strongly engaged with their communities before they are so classified, and these initial decisions will be reviewed later, with the possibility of expanding or narrowing down the list of institutions in this category. And this first voluntary classification will likely be expanded in the future, to include institutions which have a significant commitment to the improvement of undergraduate education, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/04/04/carnegie)
Women in science and math to be studied by US government – The US Department of Education recently announced that it would start “compliance reviews” of a number of colleges and universities to see whether they are obeying federal laws related to the treatment of women in math and science, writes Scott Jaschik in Inside Higher Ed. These investigations may take years and will look at both the intent and the implementation of relevant policies. The Department of Education, according to Stephanie Monroe, Assistant Secretary for Civil Rights, will select institutions that have been accused of treating women unfairly. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/03/28/women)
Women at MIT: advance and retreat? – The
MIT biologist who wrote the influential 1990s study on gender bias in the
treatment of women faculty at MIT’s School of Science has now prepared a
second report, looking at the effect over time of that report.
Nancy Hopkins’s new report, “Diversity of a University Faculty:
Observations on Hiring Women Faculty in the Schools of Science and Engineering
at MIT,” shows that after the period of 1997 – 2000 when specific efforts
were made to hire and retain women, most departments have either stalled in
their efforts, or have seen declines in the number of women faculty.
Because faculty turnover at MIT is exceptionally low, trends such as this
one are not very visible until someone such as
US lags behind in high-speed Internet access – The US
continues to lag behind rich nations in Europe and Asia in adopting high-speed
Internet connections, according to OECD data reported in the April 12th
Wall Street Journal by Leila Abboud.
The
Instant feedback – Dan Carnevale, a reporter for The Chronicle of Higher Education, wrote about the increased use of “clickers” in university classrooms. The technology works like this: the professor asks a question and students signal their answers by using a clicker that sends a signal to a remote sensor in the classroom. The answers are tallied, with anonymous results given on a screen in front of the class, and individual answers displayed on the professor’s personal computer. The instructor knows whether the class has grasped a concept, and the students get instant feedback on their learning. In order to prevent random answers, occasionally questions will be graded. This method is especially useful in courses where the subject matter consists of material with definite answers. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v51/i42/42b00301.htm)
CORRECTION: The
March Digest incorrectly identified
Top high schools fight over science as overly simple – Some
Strengthening the education leg of licensure – The lead article in the April 2006 NCEES Licensure Exchange, by Claude Baker and Howard Harclerode, describes National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying efforts to require additional engineering education for licensure. This coming September, the Council will consider revising the Model Law language to effect such a requirement – concerned that engineering education is falling behind other professions in preparing students for practice. One concern is that there has been a persistent decrease in the credit hours required for an engineering degree over several decades. Another is that additional education will be necessary in the future to prepare students for practice at the professional level. The change to the Model Law being proposed is to add a requirement for students with a bachelor’s degree in engineering to earn 30 additional credits to sit for the PE exam. An MS or Ph.D. degree in engineering would satisfy this requirement. (See http://www.ncees.org)
Investigation substantiates claims of plagiarism –
The investigation launched at
Preparing minority scientists and engineers – Despite several decades of government supported programs to increase diversity, Americans from minority groups continue to be underrepresented among Ph.D. recipients and in the science and engineering workforce. According to an article by Michael Summers and Freeman Hrabowski in the March 31st Science, the US needs to identify and deal with factors that keep underrepresented minorities from persisting with science, factors such as academic and cultural isolation, motivation and performance vulnerability in the face of low expectations, peers who are not supportive of academic success, and perceived or actual discrimination. This article describes an undergraduate program at the University of Maryland Baltimore County involving mentorship, summer and other workshops, and targeting high-achieving high school students to improve participation of underrepresented minorities in science and engineering. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Engineering coaching is booming business in
Dropout nation – The cover story for the April 17th
Time, by Nathan Thornburgh, addresses
the issue of high school dropouts in the
Female enrollment falls at Canadian engineering schools – The
percentage of women in Canadian engineering schools dropped by 20% between 2000
and 2004, according to a Canadian Council of Professional Engineers study, as
reported by CBC News in a March 16th
article. The most dramatic drop was in first-year enrollment. The decline
followed a decade in which a record number of Canadian women broke into the
male-dominated world of engineering. The number of women who have enrolled in
undergraduate engineering programs has decreased only slightly over the period
studied, but overall student enrollment has increased during this period and the
percentage of women entering engineering has not kept pace with the total
increase. In 2004 women comprised 18.5% of the overall engineering undergraduate
student population. (See http://www.cbc.ca. For
the study itself, see http://www.ccpe.ca/e/files/report_enrollment_eng.pdf)
Nobel Laureate leaves US for science education
initiative in
Top colleges reject record numbers – Concluding one of the most brutal admission seasons ever, college officials say they are accepting an unusually low percentage of applicants. Elite colleges such as Brown, Stanford and Penn say they have accepted a smaller percentage than ever before, according to an article by Anne Marie Chaker in the April 5th Wall Street Journal. Brown, where 18,313 applications reflected an increase of 8% over last year, admitted only 13.8% of applicants – down from 14.6% last year. Several factors have shifted the admissions math in recent years. Students are sending out more applications to better their chances of landing somewhere – typically applying to six or more colleges. In addition, online applications make it easier to apply to more schools, and the number of high-school graduates is increasing each year. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Continuing education? –
Colleges impose restrictions on study-abroad programs – Colleges and universities have aggressively promoted study-abroad opportunities in recent years as part of their campaign to recruit top students. But now, according to an article in the April 12th Wall Street Journal by Elizabeth Bernstein, some schools are beginning to pull back, worried about losing out on tuition as a rapidly increasing number of students go overseas. In order to limit damage to their budgets, some schools are capping the number of participants in study-abroad programs and imposing new fees and requirements. Among the tactics: requiring students to pay full tuitions even if the foreign programs cost less; setting caps on the number of students or the amount of student aid sent abroad each year; setting high minimum grade point average requirements; and limiting how many students can go abroad during popular times, such as spring semester. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Schools cut back subjects to push reading and math – Thousands of schools across the US are responding to the reading and math testing requirements laid out in President Bush’s No Child Left Behind law by reducing or eliminating class time spent on other subjects. According to an article in the March 26th New York Times by Sam Dillon, some schools are as much as tripling the class time that low-proficiency students spend on reading and math. The 2002 law requires annual exams only in those subjects and punishes schools that fall short of rising benchmarks. The changes appear to principally affect schools and students who test below grade level. Courses being systematically trimmed in this narrowing of the curriculum typically include social studies, science and art. A recent survey indicates that 71% of the nation’s 15,000 school districts have reduced hours of instructional time spent on history, music and other subjects to open up more time for reading and math. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Engineering: the new “life style choice”? –
Under the leadership of the
Engineers take 8.6 years to earn doctorate – The US National Science Foundation’s report “Time to Degree of U.S. Research Doctorate Recipients,” contains data that show that it is taking slightly less time for students to receive their doctorate degrees than it did in the mid-90s. In 2003, the median time it took to earn the Ph.D. was 10.1 years, down from the 1996 high of 10.8 years. Engineering graduates took 8.6 years, while those in the physical sciences took 7.9 years. Doug Lederman was the reporter for this article in Inside Higher Ed. (See http://insidehighered.com/news/2006/03/28/phd)
5 – Employment,
competitiveness
Congress weighs steps to retain foreign talent –
Aging workforce poses nuclear power challenge – Plans around
the globe to increase reliance on nuclear power face a potential stumbling
block: a coming lack of know-how in designing, running and regulating new
plants. According to an article in the Wall
Street Journal by Hyan Young Lee, an industry group in the US estimates that
half of the nuclear industry employees are more than 47 years old, with as many
as 23,000 expected to retire or depart during the next five years – during
which time 15 new reactors are expected to be built. In
Outsourcing particularly threatening to
6 – Journals
European Journal of Engineering Education – The May 2006 issue contains articles on engineering curricula in sustainable development, teaching entrepreneurship, use of physical models in design education, active learning, and management of online delivery for teaching and learning – plus several more articles. (See http://tandf.co.uk)
Journal of Engineering Education – The April 2006 issue of this ASEE sponsored journal contains five articles, discussing the globally competent engineer, inductive teaching and learning methods, everyday problem solving in engineering, student perceptions of engineering entrepreneurship, and biomedical engineering ethics. (See http://www.asee.org)
Global Journal of Engineering Education – The current issue is
a special edition on the German Network of Engineering Education. The 12
articles are written in German. Topics include strengthening of engineering
education in
Issues in
Science and Technology – The Spring 2006 issue includes articles on conservation in
the western US, aquaculture in federal waters, regulation of genetic testing,
and the continuing problem of nuclear weapons. (See http://www.issues.org)
7 – Meetings
UPADI 2006
– The
30th convention of the Pan American Association of Engineering
Societies will be held at Georgia Tech in
International
Conference on Sustainable Engineering Development in Africa –
This conference, organized by the Association of Engineers of the Polytechnic
Institute in conjunction with Engineers Without Borders International and the
Capacity Building Committee of the World Federation of Engineering
Organizations, will be held in
Annual
US Engineering R&D Symposium - The 4th
Annual Symposium on May 17-18 will bring together leaders from
over 18
engineering organizations
for an intensive, two-day meeting to gain firsthand knowledge of the
administration's R&D priorities and the potential impact of the President's
fiscal year 2007 budget request on the science, engineering and technology
communities. (See http://www.engineeringpolicy.org)
To contribute information to this electronic newsletter,
please send it by e-mail to russel-c-jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest
provides summaries of published articles, both printed and electronic. World
Expertise does not endorse or corroborate the information in these articles.
Some publication web sites may require user registration before access is
granted to articles via the links provided above.
Back issues of this International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com