Copyright © 2003 World Expertise LLC – All rights reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., with Bethany S. Oberst, Ph.D.
·
The
wireless last mile
·
·
IT
outlays returning
·
Voice
communications over the Internet
·
Korean
broadband explosion
·
Blackboard
in
·
New
online MBA program underway
·
Asia’s
answer to Windows
·
New
consortium builds on Internet2
·
Students
shall not download
·
Faculty
and students involved in illegal downloading
5 – Employment
Hong Kong Universities to merge? – The government of
Welcome mat out in
Effects of
Unified European research enterprise developing – New
developments in European science and technology policy indicate movement toward
a unified European research enterprise, according to Donald Kennedy writing in
the August 29th issue of Science.
Top researchers in
Laotians pedal their way onto the Internet – An international
team of 25 engineers, programmers and others have volunteered their time and
expertise to bridge the digital divide for a village in
Reform measures in Israeli universities create tensions – With
the academic year in
Damaged
Air Force Academy abuses ignored – A civilian commission investigating sexual abuse at the US Air Force Academy has reported that top leaders there disregarded persistent warnings over the last decade that frequent and unpunished sexual assaults were undermining the academy, according to an article in the September 23rd New York Times by Diana Jean Schemo. The commission said that sexual assault had been a problem at the academy throughout the last decade, and possibly since women were first admitted in 1976. It criticized an internal Air Force report on rape at the academy, saying that it was an effort to shield Air Force Headquarters from public criticism. Citing repeated warnings to the highest levels of Air Force leadership since at least 1993, the Commission concluded that the Air Force has known of serious sexual misconduct problems at the academy but has failed to take effective action. Air Force official said that they had yet to study the report, but that they were “committed to ensuring the culture at the academy reflects the core values and high standards we expect from each of our members in the Air Force”. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
White House mandates more peer review – The Bush Administration is proposing to require agencies to peer review all scientific evidence that shapes a major regulatory decision, according to an article in the September 5th Science by Jocelyn Kaiser. According to a White House spokesman, the new guidelines should raise the quality of federal rulemaking and lower the chances that the rules will be overturned in court. Some scientific experts support the new approach, saying that while peer review will not eliminate controversy, it can defuse criticism. But others worry that the change will make it harder for government agencies to issue new regulations. The new guidelines state that for some documents publication in a peer-reviewed journal might be sufficient, while for “especially significant information” an agency might need to assemble outside experts. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Pork-barrel projects scrutinized – To the surprise of some
observers, directed, non-competitive appropriations, (aka academic earmarks, or
pork-barrel projects) grew this year and exceeded the former high of $2 billion.
The new total represents a 10% increase over such funds made available to
universities by the US Congress, an increase in the number of institutions
receiving such funds, and an increase in the total number of earmarks.
The New Mexico Institute of Mining and Technology received the largest
single earmark ($21 million for an optical astronomy observatory) and the most
money in total (approximately $56 million).
The authors of the extensive analysis in the Chronicle
of Higher Education, Jeffrey Brainard and Anne Marie Borrego, point out that
there is little evidence that the quality of scientific research has been
improved by earmarks, and that ironically, this surge in additional support
began in earnest in the late 1990s, when universities had a lot of money of
their own to invest in such projects. While
many of the earmarks will be directed to security related projects, some will go
to a wide variety of other activities favored by the universities and their
local representatives in Congress. The
authors also detail the spread of money across institutions: the rules of the
game indicate that if you already have received large federal support, you will
receive more earmarks, and that you benefit from being in a state whose
representatives serve on appropriations committees.
As the federal deficit expands, and the costs of the recovery of
States struggle to meet education plan – Many states are
struggling to meet the standards of the No Child Left Behind Law, according to
an article in the September 17th Wall
Street Journal by June Kronholz. In
More NSF funds proposed for underserved groups – The scientific underprivileged moved up in priority as a Senate panel took its first crack at the 2004 NSF budget, according to an article in the September 12th Science by Jeffrey Mervis. Programs to serve minority students and institutions received especially favorable treatment in the Senate bill – for example $30-million earmarked to help minority serving colleges to purchase computer equipment and train faculty and students to use wireless and other advanced communications technologies. Legislators also told NSF to enlist more minority and women volunteers to review grant proposals. The Senate panel also wants NSF to show progress on its two-decade old effort to help researchers from ‘have not’ states compete with elite universities for NSF funding. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Updating C. P. Snow’s ‘Two Cultures’ –
Managing a $100-billion investment – The US government has established a new panel to improve how it manages its $100-billion a year investment in basic and applied research, according to a note by Jeffrey Mervis in the August 29th Science. The interagency panel, headed by a longtime grants administrator, will examine whether the current system of grants increases collaborative and interdisciplinary research, whether agencies can adopt common practices, and whether the administrative burden can be eased without a loss of accountability. Workshops will be held this fall to gather information from the research community. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
The wireless last mile – In several local instances, broadband service to Internet customers is now being provided via wireless technology, for the critical last mile. As described by Steven Cherry in the September 2003 issue of IEEE Spectrum, wireless metropolitan area networks (MANs) are beginning to do for neighborhoods and villages what Wi-Fi is doing for homes, coffee shops, airports and offices. The technology being used allows Internet connections and end users to bypass their telephone companies. This is yet a third approach to getting broadband service the last mile – competing with DSL and cable. (See http://www.spectrum.ieee.org)
IT outlays returning - Corporate IT outlays are at their strongest since early 2000, according to an article by Peter Burrows and Steve Hamm in the September 15th Business Week. According to the Commerce Department, second quarter spending on information-processing gear rose 7.6% over the previous year. It seems as if the long-awaited tech rebound may have arrived at last. Corporate profits are up, and chief information officers report higher spending. Consumer demand for PCs and digital cameras has been brisk for some time, now corporate buyers are starting to weigh in. (See http://www.businessweek.com)
Voice communications over the Internet – Internet telephony is growing in use, according to an article by Adam Bauman in the September 1st New York Times. Software technology that enables the Internet to route traffic has matured to the point that voice quality is virtually indistinguishable from that of a conventional phone call. Setups that use Internet Protocol technology route voice communications over the same lines as e-mail messages and other data traffic. About 2% of US businesses were using some form of Internet telephony at the end of last year, and projections are that one in five companies will be doing so by 2007. Industry analysts say that the equipment costs of an Internet telephone system are lower than those of a conventional PBX and its handsets. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Korean broadband explosion – While the US has supplied a
meager form of broadband to 20-million households (about 20% of the total),
South Korea has connected some 11-million households (73% of the Korean total)
with real multimegabit pipes, according to a Gilder Technology Report printed in
Forbes magazine. With that capacity,
Koreans now run one-third of their economic transactions through the Internet,
from stock trades to banking transactions to retail orders. While most of the
technology has originated in the
Blackboard in China – Blackboard, a relatively new
electronic-learning company, has won a deal in China that has eluded many more
seasoned companies, according to an article by Brian Knowlton in the September 1st
New York Times. Blackboard has entered
into a partnership with a Chinese education company which provides services to
more than 1000 universities in
New online MBA program underway – Universitas 21 Global enrolled 27 in its inaugural semester this fall. The students from around the world are studying online, in English, for their MBA. Universitas 21 is a consortium of 17 research universities located in 10 countries. While faculty come mainly from the participating institutions, course development is done through Thomson Learning, a 50% shareholder in Universitas 21 Global. Developing countries are the primary recruitment targets for the new endeavor. While the leaders of this effort state that they have every intention of building their program slowly and deliberately, some questions whether the online MBA field is already crowded with programs offered by strong and reputable institutions which can be accessed now by interested students around the world. The author of this article from the Chronicle of Higher Education, Florence Olsen, admits that it is difficult to compare Universitas 21 Global’s tuition to other programs, although she calculates that a student in one of the 10 countries represented in the consortium can expect to pay 80% less than they would have had they enrolled on campus at the participating university. (See http://chronicle.com/prm/weekly/v50/i05/05a04802.htm)
New consortium builds on Internet2 – National LambdaRail Inc. is the name of a new, nonprofit consortium that plans to build an infrastructure for research on optical networks and other types of advanced projects. Internet2 members are involved, as are various other universities and consortia. The new network will be four times faster than Internet2, and will belong to the institutions, thus differentiating itself further from Internet2, which is a network leased from Qwest Communications International, according to Florence Olsen in the Chronicle of Higher Education. The investment required over the first five years should amount to between $50 – 100 million. No one expects a cash return to participating universities. (See http://chronicle.com/prm/daily/200309/2003091701t.htm)
Students shall not download – When it comes to downloading music or movies off the Internet, students compare it with underage drinking, illegal, but not immoral, according to an article by Kate Zernike in the September 20th New York Times. Students have had the Internet for as long as they can remember, and have grown up thinking of its content as theirs for the taking. According to a study by the Pew Internet and American Life project last spring, 56% of college students download music, compared with about 25% of nonstudents. Some observers compare student attitudes about downloading to that on Internet plagiarism, which has risen steadily over the past few years. Universities are trying to convince students that both practices are wrong. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Faculty and students involved in illegal downloading – Scott Carlson, for the Chronicle of Higher Education, writes on the results of a survey conducted by the Business Software Alliance, an industry trade group, seeking information about the downloading of software by students, faculty and administrators. The practice is becoming more prevalent, and such software is frequently not paid for. The involvement of faculty and administrators in illegal downloading is particularly interesting, since the survey is intended as a first step in an educational program attempting to prevent software piracy using peer-to-peer networks. Faculty and administrators would presumably be involved with teaching students that this practice is illegal. While currently not as hot an issue as downloading music, it may loom larger on the horizon as the industry presses its case. (See http://chronicle.com/prm/daily/2003/09/2003091801t.htm)
Engineering degrees as steppingstones – With the decline in demand for engineering graduates, engineering degrees are now increasingly being touted as stepping stones to other professions. Writing in IEEE-USA Today’s Engineer, George Zobrist points out that engineering graduates automatically have a foundation that can be applied to most other professions. Engineering graduates have usable knowledge in mathematics, physics, chemistry, software, humanities, English, speech, social studies, history and economics as well as in engineering, giving them more breadth and depth of knowledge than most other disciplinary educations. That diversity can help engineering graduates migrate to other professions, such as medicine, law, business management, and computer science. (See http://www.todaysengineer.org)
Oversight of Title VI recipients raises concerns – The US House of Representatives voted unanimously for legislation which will increase federal oversight of international studies programs in colleges, including foreign language programs and area studies. Under this legislation, programs receiving Title VI money will be subjected to monitoring in order to receive recommendations on program improvement. Opponents of the original bill voiced strong concerns about the authority the federal government would have over programs and scholars. The wording of the legislation was subsequently modified in response to those objections. Even with the changes in language, some college officials are still very concerned that the legislation will be used as a means of restricting these programs to approved content, according to Stephen Burd for the Chronicle of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/prm/daily/2003/09/2003092601n.htm)
Educating future scientists and engineers – Writing in the September 12th issue of Science, Nancy Sung et al argue that the most exciting science and technology of the 21st century is likely to evolve among, not within, traditional disciplines. Writing from the perspective of biologists, the authors state that physical scientists, mathematicians, and engineers concerned with understanding complex systems will offer valuable viewpoints and approaches to biological developments – and that conversely, biological systems will catalyze technology developments in engineering and computer science. But the education of scientists and engineers has historically been constrained by disciplines – and that must change. The authors believe that bright young scientists will gravitate toward the rich opportunities at disciplinary boundaries, and that that productive movement can be enhanced if their mentors, institutions and funding agencies work at lowering institutional and cultural barriers to interdisciplinary work. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Suit filed on behalf of illegal immigrants seeking higher education –
Seven
E-mentoring network for women – MentorNet, the E-mentoring network for women in engineering and science, encourages women to pursue careers in engineering and science by providing connections between students and practicing professionals in those fields. Mentors and students communicate entirely by e-mail, with an average commitment of only 20 minutes per week by the practicing or retired professional. The program has proven effective by providing real world information, encouragement, advice and access to networks that are otherwise often unavailable to women in the male dominated fields of engineering and science. The program pairs women students in engineering and science at community colleges, undergraduate and graduate levels, and postdocs with female or male professionals as mentors for one-on-one e-mail based mentoring relationships. MentorNet has matched nearly 20,000 protégés and mentors to date, with good results. It is currently seeking more mentors. (See http://www.MentorNet.net)
What is an MBA worth? – The cover story of the September 22nd issue of Business Week attempts to answer the question of what an MBA is really worth by surveying the class of 1992 B-school alums for their opinions on salaries, satisfaction, and alumni networks. As described in an article by Jennifer Merritt, the B-school class of ’92 gives the degree high marks. Starting out with salaries in the mid $50,000 range, male MBAs report yearly salaries of $168,000 a decade later, plus other compensation of $273,000. Females lag with yearly salaries averaging $117,000 and other compensation of $84,000. The alums rate their jobs as satisfying – 58% say their current job is great, 29% say it is good, 7% ok, and only 3% problematic. Some observers question whether the good experiences of graduates from a decade ago can be expected by current MBA graduates. (See http://www.businesweek.com)
5 – Employment
A shortage of engineers and scientists? – Michael S.
Teitelbaum, a demographer at the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, recently published
an extensive article, “Do we need more scientists?” in The Public Interest. In it he dismantles current claims that a
shortage of scientists and engineers in the
Paring a foreign guest list – Three years ago technology
companies lobbied hard to expand a program that allows skilled immigrants to
enter the
Global issues cloud job market – Although the employment
market may not be in an upturn, at least layoffs have slowed, according to an
article by Terry Costlow in the September 2003 IEEE-USA Today’s Engineer. But unemployed and underemployed engineers are
concerned about the impact that changes in the global marketplace will have on
what is now being referred to as a jobless recovery. There is growing concern
that the high-tech job market is changing significantly, with globalization
leading to professional jobs moving offshore similar to the departure of
manufacturing jobs in the l980s. Some predict that offshore outsourcing will
grow because companies need to cut costs. Others argue that a company cannot
save itself into prosperity, and that it instead needs innovation – which
requires the right talent. There is a difference between jobs that move offshore
to save costs and those that help create revenue, with many of the latter
staying in the
The Administration’s blue-collar blues – President George W.
Bush has presided over the biggest loss in US manufacturing jobs since Herbert
Hoover, according to an article in the September 15th Business
Week by Richard Dunham. Since President Bush took office, 2.5-million
factory jobs – 16% of the total – have been lost. One major factor is that
6 – Journals
New IJEE approach to papers – The International Journal of Engineering Education is now publishing papers in animated interactive form online as well as in hard copy. The first paper being published in this way, “Computer-Based Instructional Media for Mechanics of Materials” is currently posted for review at http://www.ijee.dit.ie
________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe from this
newsletter service, please respond to digest@worldexpertise.com
with the word UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line. Send address changes to the same
e-mail address.
To contribute information to
this electronic newsletter, please send it by e-mail to russel_jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest provides summaries
of published articles, both printed and electronic. World Expertise does not
endorse or corroborate the information in these articles. Some publication web
sites may require user registration before access is granted to articles via the
links provided above.
Back issues of this International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com