Copyright © 2003 World Expertise LLC – All rights
reserved
A periodic electronic newsletter for engineering education
leaders,
edited by Russel C. Jones, Ph.D., P.E., with Bethany S.
Oberst, Ph.D.
5 – Employment
6 – Journals
7 – Meeting
________________________________________________________________________
Islamic research is casualty of terrorism war – Arab countries
spend less than 0.2% of their national output on research, according to a new
United Nations study reported on by Richard Stone in the October 24th
Science. Moreover, many collaborations
between Arab researchers and those in the West have been torn asunder by 9/11
developments, and are slow to mend. And Arab student numbers in the West are
down since 9/11 – in the
French court upholds university diversity efforts – An
affirmative-action type program in an elite French public university has
withstood a court challenge, according to Burton Bollag writing for the Chronicle
of Higher Education. In 2001 the
Parties struggle for control of universities in
British universities face funding gaps – British students are
protesting the Blair government’s proposed new system of “top up fees”
that will charge students up to $5100 per year, according to an article in the
November 10th Business Week by
Stanley Reed. Students complain that the fees will lead to an elitist system,
where only the rich will be able to get university educations. The
government’s proposal, scheduled for a vote in the parliamentary session that
begins in late November, has sparked a hot debate on how to finance the rising
costs of higher education. Critics fear that the funding crisis will affect
Plan to support former Iraqi weapons scientists proposed by US State
Department –
Young researchers in
Slow progress reported on internationalizing US campuses – The
American Council on Education recently released a major report, “Mapping
Internationalization on U.S. Campuses,” writes Alice Gomstyn in the Chronicle
of Higher Education. This survey of 752 colleges and universities, their
faculty and students, concludes that while some progress has been made in
internationalizing various types of programs over the past few decades, most
institutions have not made international learning a part of their mission
statement, let alone a strategic priority. There
is a gap between what faculty and students say they support, and their actual
participation in international programming.
While study abroad is an important part of the total internationalization
of a campus, the report concludes, major emphasis needs to be placed on changing
the curriculum, according to Madeleine Green of the ACE.
The report breaks down figures according to institutional type, and
covers such programs as foreign language instruction, international campus
activities, and studies abroad. (See
http://chronicle.com/daily/2003/10/2003102801n.htm)
One statement from the executive summary of the report, available online, will
be of particular interest to educators in large US research institutions.
“Compared with faculty at other types of institutions, faculty at research
universities were the least likely to have agreed that most undergraduates at
their institutions graduate with an awareness of other countries, cultures, or
global issues.” See http://www.acenet.edu/)
Special Arab immigrant registration to stop – The US Homeland
Security Department has decided to stop a program that required thousands of
Arab and Muslim men to register with immigration authorities, according to an
article in the November 23rd New
York Times by Rachel Swarns. Of 85,000 men who registered at immigration
offices, as well as thousands more screened at airports and border crossings,
only 11 were found to have links to terrorism. The program has been sharply
criticized by civil liberties groups and advocates for immigrants. That program
will be superceded by an effort in which immigration officials at 115 airports
and 14 seaports will begin collecting digital fingerprints and photographs from
foreign visitors who enter the
NIH continues disputed review process
– The US National Institutes of Health continue to examine a
list of about 190 studies they funded despite controversy over who called for
this examination and what was to have been its scope and purpose.
The studies under scrutiny all involve topics such as sexual behavior,
which have in the past been questioned or ridiculed by some members of Congress.
Some who favor closer scrutiny of federally-funded research say the issue
is basic accountability. Others see
this situation, despite its ambiguities, as an attempt to squelch, on
ideological grounds, peer-reviewed research into important issues. Jeffrey
Brainard wrote this report for the Chronicle
of Higher Education. (See http://chronicle.com/daily/2003/10/2003103101n.htm)
New course for licensure charted – A task force of the
National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying has released its
recommendations for how the licensing of professional engineers should evolve to
meet the changing needs of the profession in the 21st century,
according to an article by Danielle Boykin in the November 2003 Engineering
Times. The task force was charged with responding to several developments: a
growth of specialization within the profession, the low number of graduate
engineers who become licensed, concerns for changes in engineering education,
and initiatives put forth by professional societies. Recommendations include
continuation of the current model law requirements for licensure (ABET
accredited degree, experience, two exams), but sharpen up some of the details
(e.g., waive the Fundamentals Exam for candidates who have been awarded a
doctorate in engineering). (See http://www.nspe.org)
Foreign student enrollment in US holds even – Statistics show
that the number of foreign students enrolled in US colleges and universities in
2002-2003 held virtually steady when compared with the previous year.
But that in itself was significant, since the average growth over the
previous five years had been 5%. The
overall figures, published by the Institute for International Education and
reported in the Chronicle of Higher Education by Jennifer Jacobson, do not in
themselves reveal the large shift in foreign student enrollment by region,
however. Significant increases in
the numbers of Chinese, Indian and South Korean students made up for serious
declines in the number of students coming from Middle East countries, where
increased post-9/11 visa scrutiny has discouraged and delayed many potential
enrollees. Allan E. Goodman,
president of the IIE, is not pessimistic, however.
He sees other countries reaching their maximum capacities in higher
education, and believes that this dip in enrollments will be overcome by actual
increases in numbers in the coming years. Also
in the mix of possible explanatory factors are persistent world financial
problems and the increased recruiting efforts of other English-speaking
countries. US programs in
mathematics, engineering and science are being particularly affected. David
Cohen and Daniel del Castillo also contributed to this article. (See http://chronicle.com/weekly/v50/i11/11a00101.htm)
Sanctions on embargoed country authors – The US Treasury
Department has advised a major professional society, IEEE, that it must limit
members’ rights in four countries embargoed by the
Senate debates Internet tax bill – The temporary moratorium on
taxes on Internet access, in place since 1998, expired on November 1st,
and Congress is debating whether to extend it permanently. According to an
article by John Schwartz in the November 6th New York Times, the Bush administration is supporting a permanent
ban, arguing that it will create an environment for innovation and ensure that
electronic commerce remains a vital and growing part of the economy. Opponents
of the extension argue that state tax coffers are suffering as more areas of
commerce – such as telephone service – become Internet based. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Chinese Internet use gains breadth – Internet use is spreading
further than expected in China, according to recent surveys reported in an
article by Charles Hutzler in the November 18th Wall Street Journal. It is reaching smaller, less developed cities,
and would become even more popular if it were not for government controls. In
the major cities of
Open access journal unveiled – This month the Public Library
of Science unveiled a free electronic, open access journal based on author fees,
according to an article by David Malakoff in the October 24th Science.
The journal is available free online (www.plos.org)
and is funded by charges of $1500 per paper to the authors. A biology journal
has been launched, and the organizers plan to follow it with dozens more over
the next five years. Organizers hope to overturn the current scientific
publication establishment – a $7-billion a year industry – which they say no
longer serves the best interest of science or scientists. Librarians in
particular have complained about the escalating costs of the current print based
system. Younger researchers have expressed concern that such electronic
publications may not carry as much weight in tenure decisions as traditional
publications. (See http://www.sciencemag.org)
Wi-Fi industry hopes “roaming” will lure users – Providers
of Wi-Fi Internet connections are developing a strategy of cooperation that they
hope will keep the field growing, according to an article by Dennis Berman in
the November 6th Wall Street
Journal. Many providers of Wi-Fi are expected to begin signing agreements
that give their customers access to other providers’ “hot spots”, much
like the alliances that connect automated bank teller machines and mobile-phone
networks. Some 12,000 hot spots are now installed, with that number expected to
triple by 2005. But it is tough for Wi-Fi users who subscribe to a particular
provider’s service to get access in another provider’s hot spot. At prices
ranging from $20 to $40 a month, multiple subscriptions are unlikely. The large
scale Wi-Fi providers have become convinced that they cannot turn a profit
without reaching agreements with other companies building similar
infrastructure. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Industry concerns reported in ASEE session – At the annual
meeting of the American Society of Engineering Education this past summer, a
major session focused on what industry wants from universities. As reported in
the November 2003 ASEE Prism in an
article prepared by the Corporate Member Council of ASEE, industry wants to
interact with academia in several ways: broadening the perspectives of graduates
through implementation of accreditation guidelines, improving the curriculum to
include industry perspectives in areas such as integrated design and
manufacturing, increasing diversity and numbers of students in the engineering
graduate pipeline, promoting internships for students, increasing global
emphases, and improving interactions on R&D projects. The latter concern was
a particularly hot topic at the session. One industry representative has said
“Due to
Reward fund for finding hackers – Microsoft has set up a
$5-million reward fund for information that helps law enforcement in hacking
investigations, according to an article in the November 6th Wall
Street Journal by Gary Fields et al. The fund is a response to criticism
that Microsoft’s products are beset by security flaws and susceptible to
viruses. The first $500,000 is earmarked for information leading to the arrest
of the initial author of the latest attacks, the MSBlast worm and SoBig
virus, which disrupted millions of computers world wide this year. The
company is concerned that sales to corporations are being hurt by such attacks,
and that some customers are switching to the Linux operating system, which
hasn’t been targeted so widely by writers of viruses and worms. (See http://www.wsh.com)
Congress set to restrain spam – House and Senate leaders have
reached agreement on legislation to stem the flood of junk e-mail messages,
according to an article in the November 22nd New York Times by Edmund Andrews and Saul Hansell, making it likely
that Congress will approve a final version of the bill before it adjourns for
this year. The legislation would expose mass e-mailers to civil fines of up to
$250 a message if they disguise their identities or make themselves impossible
to trace. It would also authorize, but not require, the Federal Trade Commission
to create a “do not mail” registry which would prohibit marketers from
sending them unsolicited e-mails. Some e-mail experts cautioned that the
legislation includes many concessions to the marketing industry, and so may have
limited impact. The bill would override state laws that impose tougher
restrictions on junk e-mail. (See http://www.nytimes.com)
Bargain-priced “Big Mac” at Virginia Tech – Challenge:
compare
Lost Internet references – A study by Robert Dellavalle et al
reported in the October 31st Science
indicates that there is a significant problem with Internet references cited
in periodicals. In examining references in several high circulation scientific
journals, the authors found that 30% of articles contained one or more Internet
references. But unlike hard copy references, Internet references are subject to
change and becoming inaccessible. In the study, 3.8% of Internet references were
inactive after 3 months, 10% at 15 months, and 13% after 27 months. Inactive
Internet references were most commonly “.com” addresses (46% lost after 27
months), followed by “.edu” (30%), other (20%), “.gov” (10%) and
“.org” (5%). The authors suggest several possible remedies to the problem.
(See http://www.sciencemag.org)
To-do list for technology –
A special section in the November 17th Wall Street Journal contains
a series of articles describing problems facing the technology industry, and
describing what it is doing to solve them. The eight problems addressed are:
make software more reliable, simplify home networking, manage TV-channel
clutter, keep hackers out, help baffled consumers, lengthen battery life, get
corporate computer services to talk to each other, and safeguard confidential
personal information. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Shortage of engineers and scientists predicted – The US
National Science Board (a group that sets policy for the National Science
Foundation) has predicted a shortage of US-born engineers and scientists and has
called on the
Engineering students report weaker feedback – The National
Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE) was released on November 10 and contains the
following statement: “Business and Engineering majors are well below their
counterparts in other fields in terms of prompt feedback from faculty and the
frequency with which they engage in integrative activities.”
A summary of the comprehensive report, “Converting Data into Action:
Expanding the Boundaries of Institutional Improvement,” is available online.
(See http://www.iub.edu/~nsse/2003_annual_report/pdf/NSSE_2003_Viewpoint.pdf)
International Educators group calls for more study abroad scholarships –
NAFSA: Association of International Educators, recently recommended that the
More
Copyright in the digital age – The November/December 2003 Change
features a series of articles on copyright: “Copyright in the age of
photocopiers, word processors, and the Internet”; “Libraries, copyrights,
and the digital age”; “Copyright and distance education”; and “Educating
undergraduates for responsible citizenship.” The articles point out that
owners of intellectual property are responding to increased digital infringement
of copyrighted material with preventive and enforcement related measures. They
also note that it is up to faculty and administrators to work with institutional
counsel to understand the availability of fair use to further the educational
mission of the institution. And institutions are urged to create programs of
moral and civic education to put students on the high road with respect to the
intellectual property rights of others. (See http://www.heldref.org)
Teaching the teachers – An article in the November 2003 ASEE
Prism by Robert Gardner describes a summer institute conducted by the
Dual-level accreditation – Current ABET policy states that a
program may be accredited at only one level in a particular curriculum at a
particular institution. In an article in the November 2003 Engineering Times, Ernest Smerdon and Richard Anderson argue that
this prohibition should be dropped, to allow dual-level accreditation at
institutions that want to accredit programs at both the bachelors and masters
degree levels. Their rationale is that in many fields a masters degree is the
appropriate education for entry into the profession, and that the quality
assurance provided by ABET should be available for that level in addition to the
basic bachelors degree education at a given institution. They cite the current
efforts of the American Society of Civil Engineers to define a body of knowledge
needed to enter professional practice in several civil engineering fields as an
example of the need for dual-level accreditation. (See http://www.nspe.org)
Students rewarded for stock tip – A group of
New ethics video available – “Incident
at Morales,” an engineering ethics story on video for classroom use, covers a
wide rang of ethical dilemmas facing engineers working in today’s global
engineering profession. The video and study guide stimulate viewers to consider
how to resolve difficult ethical issues including international
responsibilities, consequences of technical and financial decisions, and
environmental concerns. The 36-minute video is designed for interactive use with
a discussion facilitator, and has built-in pauses for discussion. (See http://www.fppnet.org/products.cfm#incident)
Faculty licensure – Newly installed ASCE President Patricia
Galloway addresses the issue of faculty licensure as professional engineers in
an article in the November 2003 ASCE News.
Focusing on civil engineering faculty in particular, she argues that
engineering professors are practicing engineering when they teach students in
the classroom, and that students who see their faculty role models as licensed
professionals will be much more likely to seek such professional status
themselves. (See http://www.asce.org)
5 – Employment
Jobs going abroad is ok – In a major article in the November 2nd
Washington Post, former Secretary of
Labor Robert Reich states that high-tech jobs are going abroad, but that’s ok!
He points out that jobs in
Low demand predicted for undergraduate engineers in 2004 – Job
prospects for the
Tech job losses ease – The American Electronics Association
has reported that high-tech industries in the
NAFTA has not helped Mexican jobs – The North American Free
Trade Agreement has not helped the Mexican economy keep pace with the growing
demand for jobs, according to an article by Richard Lapper in the November 20th
Financial Times. A study by the
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace indicates that growth in the
manufacturing sector has been more than offset by a loss of jobs in the
agricultural sector. Growth in foreign trade and foreign investment has led to
an increase of 500,000 jobs in manufacturing from 1994 to 2002, but 1.3-million
jobs in the agricultural sector have been lost in that same period. In addition,
real wages are now lower than when NAFTA took effect, though much of that
decline is a result of the 1994 devaluation of the Peso. The flow of migrants to
the
“Hiring and firing” trend gains – Numerous companies are
adding new workers on the one hand while laying off current ones on the other,
according to an article by Kris Maher in the November 18th Wall
Street Journal. Executives state that they cannot shift employees around
when timing is critical and new employees with appropriate skill sets and
experience, and often lower wage rates, can readily be found to fill new
positions. Outsourcing firms say that they are seeing the hiring and firing
trend increase, with companies rarely doing redeployments or trying to match
skills with jobs. Some experts argue that companies would do well to consider
holding on to staffers and retraining them to avoid the hidden costs of lowered
morale and drain on organizational knowledge. (See http://www.wsj.com)
Employers ask job seekers for SAT scores – The SAT scores of
students that colleges use in admission decisions are now following many people
into the workplace as a defining performance measure, according to an article by
Kemba Dunham in the October 28th Wall Street Journal. A cadre of companies that hire large numbers of
fresh college graduates are asking for SAT scores, for use as a way to
differentiate among applicants in the current dismal job market where there are
many applicants for each position. Some companies even set SAT score
expectations in their help wanted ads: “Minimum expectations include an
overall score of 1350 on the SATs, and you will be required to provide official
scores and transcripts.” Employers see the SAT test as a good indicator of
future success, saying that people with high scores tend to do better. Some are
critical of this trend, noting that the SAT is not intended as a measure of
future job performance. (See http://www.wsj.com)
6 – Journals
Journal of Engineering Education – The October 2003 issue of
this ASEE journal contains nine papers, several on detailed classroom
innovations and several on broader topics such as stereotyping of women’s
performance in engineering, integrating communication and engineering education,
and the case for accessibility in making the grade with students. (See http://www.asee.org)
International Journal of Engineering Education – A special issue on Problem Based Learning has been prepared by guest editors Erik de Graaff, Anett Kolmos, and Renate Fruchter (volume 19, number 5). Nineteen papers on the topic are included, starting with an overview paper on characteristics of problem based learning by two of the guest editors. (See http://www.ijee.dit.ie)
European Journal of Engineering Education – The December 2003
issue of EJEE includes ten papers on a broad range of topics in engineering
education: Thematic Network E4, European research on women and engineering
education, a taxonomy of engineering design tasks, assessment of student
learning, etc. (See http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/)
IEEE Transactions on Education – The November 2003 issue
contains a special section on a vision for ECE education in 2013 and beyond, as
well as several regular issue papers. The special section includes papers on ECE
as a pre-professional undergraduate program, curriculum for an engineering
renaissance, computer engineering curriculum in the new millennium, the future
of electrical and computer engineering education, etc. (See http://www.ewh.ieee.org/soc/es/esinfo.html)
7 – Meeting
ABET Annual Meeting – The annual meeting of the Accreditation
Board for Engineering and Technology was held in
________________________________________________________________________
To unsubscribe from this
newsletter service, please respond to digest@worldexpertise.com
with the word UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line. Send address changes to the same
e-mail address.
To contribute information to
this electronic newsletter, please send it by e-mail to russel_jones@worldexpertise.com
This Digest provides summaries
of published articles, both printed and electronic. World Expertise does not
endorse or corroborate the information in these articles. Some publication web
sites may require user registration before access is granted to articles via the
links provided above.
Back issues of this
International Engineering Education Digest can be read on the Web at http://www.worldexpertise.com